01. New problems raised by the special governance
In July 2026, the Party Central Committee deployed a one-year nationwide campaign to deepen the special struggle against organized crime, with the focus extending to new types of organized crime carried out in an organized manner using online platforms and "soft violence" methods.[2] Among the subsequently announced key types, "public opinion extortion" and "malicious claims" are listed alongside nude chat extortion, illegal debt collection, forced consumption, labor-related setup fraud and other acts.[3] The first round of concentrated arrests has already covered cases of malicious complaints against online stores, online routine loans, labor-related setup fraud and other categories.[4] It can be foreseen that conflicts between complaints, reports, exposure, claims and the order of enterprise operations will become an important issue in criminal justice for some time to come.
The special governance responds to real and urgent social risks. Some people deliberately create food quality problems and repeatedly claim compensation by exploiting operators' fear of administrative penalties and online public opinion; some build self-media matrices, splicing, exaggerating or even fabricating negative information about enterprises, and then charge fees in the name of deleting posts, stopping publication and "public opinion services"; still other gangs combine complaint platforms, online traffic and administrative procedures into a replicable tool for obtaining property. These acts continuously harm enterprises' goodwill, operational security and public complaint resources, and punishing them according to law is fully necessary.
The same appearance may also occur in legitimate rights protection. A consumer complains to a regulatory authority after being misled in a sale, a worker uses a report of illegal employment to promote compensation, a victim uses media supervision to push forward negotiations, or a lawyer or consulting agency is entrusted to organize materials and charges a service fee—all of these bring pressure to bear on the complained-against enterprise. If investigating authorities directly apply the crime of extortion upon seeing "payment after complaint," "organized assistance" or "charging by result," administrative remedies and civil negotiation will be placed under criminal risk. The central deployment also emphasizes strictly acting according to law and adhering to seeking truth from facts, requiring that "not a single gang or evil force be missed, and not a single one be counted in if it is not a gang or evil force." This statement should become the basic yardstick for handling such cases.
"Malicious claims" and "public opinion extortion" are typological summaries at the governance level; the current Criminal Law does not establish independent charges under these two names. Once in criminal proceedings, they must still be reviewed under specific charges such as the crime of extortion, the crime of fraud, the crime of forced transactions, and the crime of picking quarrels and provoking trouble. Policy concepts can help discover leads, but cannot replace judgment on subjective purpose, objective means, causation and the standard of proof.
02. The structure of the dispute presented by the Shang Meina case
Shang Meina operated Shenyang Pinda Legal Services Co., Ltd., providing policyholders with insurance rights protection consulting, organization of complaint materials, mailing and other services. The procuratorate alleged that Shang Meina recruited clients on the condition of full refund of insurance premiums, guided policyholders to record evidence, wrote complaint letters describing "fabricated and inflated" violations by the insurance company, and repeatedly complained to the financial regulatory authorities, causing the insurance company to refund full premiums to 11 policyholders or pay amounts higher than the cash value. The indictment determined the insurance company's loss to be 542,574.84 yuan.
After the author was retained as Shang Meina's defense counsel, the case had already formed a massive evidence system. The prosecution's narrative was very impactful, with words such as "agency surrender of insurance," "black industry," "uniform scripts," "malicious complaints" and "special stability maintenance funds" constantly appearing, as if a criminal chain could naturally be pieced together. Once actually in the case file, the problems were far more complex than the labels.
The defense work did not stop at general statements about the right to complain. We divided the 11 policyholders into 11 evidence units, then divided each complaint letter into several specific facts, and checked item by item the recording time points, WeChat chats, transfer records, policy contents, complaint handling forms, the insurance company's internal work reports, penalty decisions against salespersons and refund approval materials. The core questions of the verification were very specific: which statement in the complaint letter lacked a source; whether the recording could support that statement; whether the insurance company internally confirmed sales defects; on what approval grounds the refund was actually based; who paid the service fee and into whose account it went; whether Shang Meina participated in negotiations over the refund amount.
The trial lasted nearly a month. On December 4, 2025, Shang Meina regained her freedom after 872 days in custody; on December 30 of the same year, the procuratorate withdrew the prosecution and decided not to prosecute, and Shang Meina obtained a decision of substantive innocence.[5] This result does not mean that all agency complaint conduct is legitimate, nor can it eliminate the illegal surrender-of-insurance agency that truly exists in the industry. What it reveals is that there is a distance that must be crossed by evidence between an enterprise bearing pressure due to regulatory complaints and an actor forcing an enterprise to deliver property through unlawful threats.
03. Restoring governance concepts after they enter criminal law evaluation
(1) The crime of extortion still centers on the statutory elements
Article 274 of the Criminal Law provides for the crime of extortion.[6] In the usual normative structure, the actor must have the purpose of illegal possession, carry out threats or coercion sufficient to create psychological compulsion, the victim must dispose of property based on that psychological compulsion, and there must also be a corresponding relationship between the actor's and the victim's gain and loss of property. If any link is missing, it cannot be supplied by "causing pressure" or "obtaining benefits."
The 2019 Opinion of the "Two Highs and Two Ministries" on "soft violence" further limits it: "soft violence" requires the actor, in order to seek unlawful benefits or form an illegal influence, to adopt means such as harassment, pestering, making noise, and gathering crowds to create momentum, reaching a level sufficient to cause others fear and panic and form psychological compulsion, or sufficient to affect normal life, work, production and operation.[7] This provision contains three interrelated limitations: the benefit or influence is unlawful, the manner of conduct has a criminal or illegal nature, and the psychological compulsion reaches a considerable intensity. Mere negotiation pressure, performance pressure, regulatory pressure and public opinion supervision pressure do not automatically fall within the scope of "soft violence."
(2) "Organized implementation" has an independent limiting function
This round of the special struggle places "organized implementation" in a prominent position. According to the Anti-Organized Crime Law, an evil force organization needs to have characteristics such as frequent gathering, repeatedly committing illegal and criminal acts, doing evil, oppressing the masses, and causing relatively bad social impact.[8] A company has employees, a case has division of labor, and materials have templates—these can only show that the conduct has an organizational form. Whether it constitutes organized crime in the sense of gang-related or evil-force-related crime still requires returning to whether each underlying act is illegal, whether members take illegal and criminal activities as the content of their common activities, and whether the organization has formed illegal control or a dominant position.
"Organized" modifies illegal and criminal activities. If the underlying acts are entrusted consulting, evidence organization and statutory complaints, the standardization of business processes will not change the nature of the acts. Conversely, if a gang uniformly creates defects, forges evidence, controls accounts to hype, and sells post-deletion services at fixed prices, organization will significantly enhance the social harm and psychological compulsion of the acts. Accumulating the quantity of lawful acts into a crime, or first attaching the label of "black industry" and then reasoning backward that each act is illegal, will reverse the order of evaluation.
04. The basis of rights and the purpose of illegal possession
(1) Complaints and claims have clear institutional entry points
Our law has established a complete system for complaints, reports and remedies for consumer disputes. Article 41 of the Constitution guarantees citizens' right to make appeals, accusations and reports, while prohibiting the fabrication or distortion of facts to falsely accuse and frame others.[9] The Consumer Rights Protection Law allows consumers to resolve disputes through negotiation, mediation, administrative complaints, arbitration and litigation.[10] The Insurance Law also explicitly prohibits insurance companies and their staff from deceiving policyholders, concealing important circumstances relating to insurance contracts, and giving benefits outside those agreed in insurance contracts, and extends the corresponding norms to insurance agents and insurance brokers.[11]
It can thus be seen that after a policyholder discovers that a salesperson has exaggerated returns, concealed surrender losses, paid rebates, falsely filled in insurance application materials or other problems, complaining to the regulatory authorities and demanding termination of the contract and return of premiums at least has a basis of rights that can enter civil and administrative review. Whether a full refund can ultimately be obtained requires judgment in light of fraud, material misunderstanding, contract validity, degree of fault and the content of the parties' settlement. Whether a claim right is disputed and whether the claim right is entirely created by the actor have fundamentally different significance in criminal law.
(2) The basis of rights should be reviewed in layers
In practice, claims can be roughly placed at four levels. The first level is where the right has already been clearly confirmed by contract, law or an effective judgment; the second level is where there is real damage and a considerable factual basis, and the scope of the right remains disputed; the third level is where the claim lacks a sufficient legal basis, but the actor in good faith believes based on certain facts that he has the right to assert it; the fourth level is where the actor actively creates the facts of damage or knows that there is no basis of rights at all, yet still uses complaints and exposure as a tool to obtain property.
The first three levels usually need to be absorbed first by civil and administrative mechanisms. A high claim amount, a mistaken understanding of the law, or a tough negotiating position can affect whether the claim is supported and can also serve as auxiliary facts for judging subjective purpose, but they can hardly prove the purpose of illegal possession on their own. A recent theoretical article by the Supreme People's Procuratorate on the purpose of illegal possession in property crimes also suggests that sensitive circumstances in civil and commercial matters such as major breach of contract, misrepresentation and forged signatures cannot be directly equated with the purpose of illegal possession, and that subjective and objective consistency should be maintained and the substantive legal relationship examined.[12] Academic research likewise emphasizes that the basis of rights, and the connection and proportionality between purpose and means, should be examined, to prevent the crime of extortion from swallowing undisputed exercise of rights.[13]
The fourth level has clear signals of criminality. Where the actor first places foreign objects, forges photographs, or fabricates enterprise violations, and then exchanges complaints or exposure for property, the so-called right is from the outset part of the scheme to obtain property. At this point, fabricated facts, the purpose of illegal possession and coercive means corroborate one another, and the criminal law evaluation has a stable foundation.
(3) Service fees cannot independently prove the purpose of illegal possession
In the Shang Meina case, the prosecution treated Pinda Company's collection of service fees based on the results of policy surrenders as important evidence of the intent to illegally possess. The paid handling of entrusted affairs is generally lawful under civil law, and the trustee may obtain remuneration as agreed after completing the affair.[14] In criminal cases, the fee ratio, fee method and profit level certainly need to be examined, but the correct order should be to first determine whether the entrusted affair and the means of achieving it are unlawful, and then evaluate whether the remuneration constitutes criminal proceeds.
If the service content is fabricating evidence, organizing harassment, purchasing traffic, or manufacturing public opinion, the fees may become evidence of criminal division of labor and distribution of illegal benefits. If the service content includes reviewing materials, organizing recordings, drafting complaints, and following up on regulatory procedures, the fees are paid by the policyholder as agreed, the surrender proceeds first enter the policyholder's own account, and the fact of charging fees itself cannot prove that the actor intended to possess the insurance company's property. In the Shang Meina case, most refunds went directly into policyholders' accounts, and Pinda Company obtained service remuneration from the policyholders. The flow of property is clearly different from the typical "enterprise pays the poster a fee to delete posts."
05. Criminal law evaluation of the truth of facts and the text of complaints
(1) A distinction should be drawn between core facts, deviations in details, and legal evaluation
In complaint-type cases, the prosecution cannot be satisfied with general allegations of "inflating or fabricating." It needs to clearly identify which complaint letter, which factual statement, and which source of evidence is false, who formed that statement, when the actor knew it was false, and how the false fact affected the other party's payment. Only by breaking the accusation down into factual units that can be cross-examined can criminal proof have a foothold.
Complaint texts usually contain factual narration, evidentiary explanation, and legal evaluation at the same time. Whether the salesperson said "you get your principal back when the policy matures," whether commissions were returned, and whether gifts outside the contract were given are factual questions; whether the above conduct constitutes deception within the meaning of insurance law and whether it is sufficient to rescind the contract are legal evaluations. There are disagreements in legal application, and they cannot be converted into "fabricating facts." Even if individual wording in a complaint letter is not rigorous enough, it should still be determined whether the core complaint facts are true and whether local deviations were caused by policyholder memory error, document summarization, or intentional fabrication.
(2) There is a boundary between guiding recordings and manufacturing evidence
In the Shang Meina case, the public prosecution authority called the guided recordings of conversations between policyholders and salespersons "scripted evidence collection" and treated them as an important part of fabricated complaints. The questions in the recordings are leading and may reduce probative value; if the questioner intentionally conceals the surrounding context, edits and splices, or asks the other party to confirm facts that never occurred, corresponding legal consequences certainly must be borne.
However, when a consumer, after a dispute arises, again verifies the sales promises with the salesperson and fixes the other party's answers through recording, the recording does not lose legality merely because someone provided the questioning framework. Criminal judgment should examine the original medium, the complete context, the time of formation, and the corroborative relationship with other evidence. The manner of questioning affects the weight of evidence and cannot automatically prove that the content of the recording is forged. Even less can it be presumed that all complaint facts were created out of thin air by the agency simply because the complaint texts adopt a similar structure.
(3) The common feature of typical malicious claim cases is the manufacture of rights
In January 2026, the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, and the State Administration for Market Regulation jointly released typical cases on regulating professional claims, explicitly supporting reasonable rights protection while punishing unlawful claims.[15] Among them, Su deliberately placed foreign objects in restaurant food and then used reporting as a threat to extort property;[16] Xiang and others traveled across multiple locations, punctured food packaging and inserted foreign objects, created quality problems, and then pressured through exposure and complaints;[17] Huang and others forged express delivery receipts and videos and photos of swollen and leaking food packaging to fabricate quality problems and obtain refunds by deception.[18] The criminal basis of these cases is very clear: the facts of damage were manufactured by the actors, the appearance of rights was constructed through forged evidence, and the complaint procedure was merely a tool for obtaining property.
The Zeng case in the same batch of cases adopted a different approach. Where the purchase quantity exceeded reasonable living consumption needs, the court supported punitive damages only within a reasonable scope and limited the remaining claims through civil adjudication.[19] This arrangement shows that where claim requests are excessive and the degree of professionalism is strong, it is still necessary to distinguish civil regulation from criminal accountability. The key point of criminal law intervention usually falls on links such as manufacturing unlawful facts, forging evidence, and implementing coercive property acquisition.
The evidence structure of the Shang Meina case is substantively different from the above "placing foreign objects" cases. The policyholders first had genuine insurance contracts and long-term premium payment facts; the recordings, WeChat messages, transfers, and policy information in the complaint materials were all formed in specific transaction relationships; and the insurance company's internal materials also confirmed some sales problems. Whether certain complaint details are accurate can be disputed item by item, but the overall factual basis cannot be erased because of templated expression.
06. Regulatory pressure, public opinion pressure, and psychological coercion in criminal law
(1) The source of pressure determines the nature of the means
Psychological coercion in extortion needs to be caused by the unlawful disadvantage that the actor has threatened or implemented. Where the victim worries about personal injury, privacy exposure, false public opinion, continuous harassment, or the blocking of business premises, this can usually reflect the unlawfulness of the means. Where a complained-against enterprise worries that a regulatory authority will investigate in accordance with law, impose penalties for genuine violations, bear contractual liability, or face social evaluation based on true facts, what it bears is legal risk in business operations. Both types of pressure may be psychologically intense, but their criminal law nature cannot be conflated.
If an enterprise's concern about regulatory piece-rate assessment, performance deductions, and loss of goodwill is directly characterized as "fear," then any effective complaint may be interpreted as coercion. The complaint system works precisely because regulatory review will bring pressure to correct errors to the complained-against subject. Criminal law needs to examine whether the actor increased unlawful harm outside the system through false facts, unlawful dissemination, harassment and pestering, and cannot attribute the binding force of the system itself to the complainant.
(2) "Purchasing silence" is an important identifying point of public opinion extortion
The typical cases on news extortion released by the Supreme People's Procuratorate provide a valuable contrast for distinguishing public opinion supervision from extortion.[20] Song used self-media to continuously publish false and negative information and, on the condition of stopping dissemination and deleting posts, forced enterprises to pay "public relations fees";[21] Zhu and others first compiled and published negative articles about enterprises and then exchanged signing "public opinion service agreements" for rapid post deletion.[22] In such cases, payment has nothing to do with any actual compensation for damage; what the enterprise buys is the poster's cessation of infringement, deletion of information, and maintenance of silence. The so-called service contract lacks genuine service content, and the essence of the transaction is exchanging public opinion risk for property.
The property relationship in complaint-based surrender cases is usually different. The insurance company refunds the policyholder, formally handling the insurance contract and sales dispute; the agency's remuneration is paid by the policyholder. If the complaint has a factual basis, the refund amount is internally approved by the insurance company and a settlement is reached with the policyholder, and the disposition of property remains connected to the original contractual relationship. At this point, to find extortion, the prosecution needs to further prove that the contract dispute was merely a shell and that the actor used false facts and unlawful coercion to create a payment obligation that did not originally exist.
(3) An enterprise's statement that it was "under pressure" is insufficient to complete causal proof
In criminal proceedings, enterprises often use "under pressure," "to smooth things over," and "for reputation" to describe the reason for payment. These statements have evidentiary significance but cannot replace examination of the objective disposition process. Whether the company investigated the complaint facts, whether it determined that employees were responsible, whether it went through legal and compliance approval, whether it could refuse payment and explain to the regulatory authority, and whether the refund was recorded under customer disputes, sales liability, or stability maintenance accounts will all affect the judgment of the reason for disposition.
In the Shang Meina case, the insurance company's internal materials contain records such as "company fault," "salesperson had problems," and "penalize and recover commissions," as well as subsequent statements that "the complaint was not true but refunds were made to avoid piece-rate assessment." The former shows that the refund may have included factors of correcting sales defects and resolving contract disputes, while the latter emphasizes complaint volume and performance pressure. Where multiple motives coexist, the public prosecution authority should prove that the unlawful threat played a decisive role in the disposition of property. Merely relying on the fact that the refund amount was higher than the cash value and that enterprise personnel subjectively felt pressure makes it difficult to exclude reasonable explanations such as civil settlement and resolution of administrative disputes.
07. Practical implications of the Shang Meina case for the special campaign
The Shang Meina case occurred before this round of the special campaign, yet it presented in advance the boundary issues most worthy of vigilance in the special governance. The indictment summarized the regulatory piece-rate assessment, employee deductions, and company reputation pressure caused by complaints as "fear and panic," then summarized refunds higher than the cash value as "losses," and finally inferred the intent to illegally possess from the service fees. This argument appears complete but in fact omits key links such as whether the complaint facts were true, whether the insurance company was at fault, whether the refund was a dispute settlement, and whether the service fee was based on an entrustment relationship.
During the trial, the author repeatedly emphasized that criminal accusations must answer verifiable questions. Which complaint fact was fabricated by Shang Meina, which recording was edited, which refund was paid only because of a false threat, which policyholder had no basis of rights at all, and which service fee came directly from the insurance company. Only by completing proof item by item can "agency surrender" be converted into criminal law facts. The case ultimately ended with non-prosecution, showing that constituent element review remains an effective method of resisting label-based criminalization.
The 872 days of detention also remind judicial authorities that the cost of boundary judgments is borne by specific individuals. Complaint-type cases often involve huge files, numerous participating subjects, and complex industry rules, and there may also be tension between internal enterprise documents and report statements. The more case-handling authorities face pressure from the special campaign, the more they need to adhere to evidence-based adjudication and avoid replacing legal concepts with industry concepts, replacing psychological coercion with enterprise feelings, and inferring criminal purpose from refund outcomes.
The special campaign protects the lawful rights and interests of enterprises and should also protect the space for consumers, workers, and ordinary citizens to complain and report in accordance with law. Acts of fabricating facts, manufacturing public opinion, selling silence, and organized property acquisition should be severely punished in accordance with law; acts with a genuine dispute basis that express demands through statutory channels should be allowed to let civil and administrative mechanisms play their role. In the typical cases on news extortion, the Supreme People's Procuratorate proposed accurately distinguishing public opinion supervision from committing crimes under the guise of supervision, and what it emphasized is precisely this kind of substantive review.[23]
Conclusion
The entry of "malicious claims" and "public opinion extortion" into the vision of special governance reflects the reality that crime forms are developing toward networking, non-contact, and organization. Effective governance requires more refined legal judgment. The pressure that complaints place on enterprises does not of course constitute a threat in criminal law; claims exceeding ordinary standards cannot directly prove intent to illegally possess; and the collection of remuneration by an agency certainly cannot exempt review of the service content, factual basis, and flow of funds.
The defense process in the Shang Meina case shows that, in the face of strong labels such as "black industry," "malicious complaints," and "soft violence," criminal defense lawyers need to place the case back into the coordinates of evidence. Where each complaint fact came from, how each internal finding of responsibility was formed, why each refund was paid, and who bore each remuneration are all basic questions that determine guilt or innocence. Abstract slogans easily create a sense of certainty; only item-by-item verification can approach the facts.
Shang Meina was released without charge after 872 days in custody and subsequently received a decision not to prosecute. The time already lost cannot be returned, but this outcome still leaves a clear warning for future cases. Severely punishing genuine public-opinion extortion and malicious claims must be premised on strictly distinguishing the exercise of legitimate rights. Only by running the intensity of special rectification in parallel with the precision of criminal law boundaries can we simultaneously safeguard the order of business operations, the public's right to supervise, and judicial fairness.
Appendix
Questions and answers
How did the Shang Meina case illustrate the evidentiary challenges in alleged public opinion extortion?
The defense divided the 11 policyholders into evidence units and checked each complaint fact against recordings, chats, transfers, and internal insurance company documents. The case ended with non-prosecution after 872 days in custody, showing that criminal accusations must prove which facts were fabricated and how they caused payment.
How do courts distinguish public opinion supervision from public opinion extortion?
Public opinion extortion typically involves purchasing silence: the actor publishes false negative information and charges fees to stop dissemination or delete posts, with no genuine service content. In contrast, complaints based on real facts that lead to refunds through statutory procedures are connected to the original contractual relationship and lack the exchange of public opinion risk for property.
What are the implications of the Shang Meina case for the special campaign against organized crime?
The case warns against label-based criminalization and emphasizes item-by-item verification of complaint facts, internal responsibility findings, refund reasons, and fee flows. It shows that punishing genuine malicious claims must be premised on strictly distinguishing legitimate rights exercise, balancing enterprise protection with citizens' right to complain.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Article 274 of the Criminal Law
- Anti-Organized Crime Law
- Article 41 of the Constitution
- Consumer Rights Protection Law
- Insurance Law
Judicial interpretations
- 2019 Opinion of the "Two Highs and Two Ministries" on "soft violence"
Cases
- typical cases on regulating professional claims
- Zeng case
- typical cases on news extortion
References
- The author, Xu Qin, was the defense counsel in the case of Shang Meina, who was charged with extortion.
- See "Chen Wenqing Stresses at the National Video Conference on the Special Campaign Against Gang Crime: Solidly Carry Out and Deepen the Special Campaign Against Gang Crime, Strive to Build a Higher-Level Safe China," Xinhua News Agency, July 31, 2026.
- See "Cracking Down Hard on Online-Related Gang and Evil Forces and Others: Key Points of This Special Campaign Against Gang Crime Announced," CCTV.com, August 3, 2026. The article lists public-opinion extortion, malicious claims, and other gang and evil crimes and related crimes organized and carried out using online platforms and "soft violence" methods.
- In August 2026, the Ministry of Public Security deployed the first round of centralized arrest operations; public security organs nationwide eliminated more than 1,000 criminal gangs of various types, arrested more than 8,200 criminal suspects, and solved more than 5,400 criminal cases. See "The First Round of Centralized Arrest Operations in the National Public Security Organs' Deepening of the Special Campaign Against Gang Crime," August 11, 2026.
- On December 4, 2025, Shang Meina regained her freedom after 872 days in custody and was released without charge.
- Article 274 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China.
- Article 1 of the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Criminal Cases Involving the Implementation of "Soft Violence," April 9, 2019.
- Articles 2 and 5 of the Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China. The Law defines an evil-force organization as a criminal organization that frequently gathers, repeatedly carries out illegal and criminal activities within a certain region or industry sector, does evil and bullies the masses, and causes relatively bad social impact, and at the same time requires that anti-organized-crime work be carried out in accordance with the law and that human rights be respected and protected.
- Article 41 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of China.
- Article 39 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests.
- Articles 116 and 131 of the Insurance Law of the People's Republic of China.
- See "Adhering to the Unity of Subjective and Objective Elements to Break the Dilemma of Determining 'Purpose of Illegal Possession'," Procuratorate Daily, July 4, 2026, theory edition. The article points out that sensitive circumstances such as untrue statements and material breach in civil and commercial matters cannot by themselves be equated with the purpose of illegal possession.
- Zou Hongjian: "On the Criminal Law Regulation of the Conduct of Seeking Wealth Through Illegal Petitions—From the Perspective of the Restrictive Application of the Crime of Extortion," Jiangxi Social Sciences, 2024, No. 12. The article advocates restricting the expansive application of the crime of extortion from aspects such as the basis of rights, the connection and proportionality between purpose and means.
- Articles 919 and 928 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China. A commission contract permits the agent to handle the commissioned affairs and to obtain remuneration as agreed. The existence of remuneration still needs to be judged in light of the content of the commission, the performance, and the flow of funds, and cannot by itself bear the function of criminal attribution.
- Supreme People's Court, Supreme People's Procuratorate, State Administration for Market Regulation: Typical Cases of Regulating Professional Claims and Safeguarding Market Order, January 29, 2026.
- The Su Mou extortion case among the typical cases of the three departments cited above. The perpetrator deliberately placed foreign objects in restaurant food and then threatened to report and expose the matter to demand property.
- The Xiang Mou and others extortion case among the typical cases of the three departments cited above. The perpetrators punctured food packaging across regions and inserted foreign objects, creating quality problems and then threatening to complain and expose the matter to demand compensation.
- The Huang Mou and others fraud case among the typical cases of the three departments cited above. The perpetrators forged buyers' express delivery receipts and videos and photos of food packaging swelling and leaking air, fabricating quality problems to obtain refunds.
- The Zeng Mou v. Chen Mou and a Certain Agricultural and Sideline Products Processing Factory product liability dispute case among the typical cases of the three departments cited above. The court supported punitive damages within the scope of reasonable living consumption needs and did not support the excess portion, reflecting the hierarchical distinction between civil regulation and criminal accountability.
- Supreme People's Procuratorate: Typical Cases of Procuratorial Organs Punishing the Crimes of News Extortion and Fake News in Accordance with the Law, December 25, 2024.
- The Song Mou extortion case among the typical cases of the Supreme People's Procuratorate cited above. Song Mou used self-media to continuously publish untrue and negative information and, on the condition of stopping dissemination and deleting content, forced enterprises to pay "public relations fees."
- The Zhu Mou and others extortion case among the typical cases of the Supreme People's Procuratorate cited above. The perpetrators packaged transactions under so-called "public-opinion service agreements," first compiling and publishing negative articles about enterprises, and then exchanging the signing of cooperation and payment of fees for deletion of posts.
- In the question-and-answer session with reporters on the typical cases of news extortion released in 2024, the Supreme People's Procuratorate proposed that public-opinion supervision and the commission of crimes under the guise of supervision should be accurately distinguished, with focus on examining the truthfulness of negative information, the purpose of obtaining wealth, the substance of the transaction, and the degree of coercion.