01. Individual case judgments should not become group labels

According to a Jiemian News report on September 11, 2026, "Tietou" was sentenced in the first instance to eight years' imprisonment with multiple crimes punished together. Previously, the Changchun police had publicly solicited leads on Shen Mousong and others of "Songge Dah Hu" suspected of underworld-nature crimes. The sentencing report and the investigation notice have successively entered public view, but their nature differs; the latter in particular cannot be rewritten as an already-adjudicated "professional anti-counterfeiting underworld case."[1]

The author previously gave an interview to Jiemian News and expressed views on the boundary between professional anti-counterfeiting, online supervision and criminal offenses.[2] In discussions encountered afterward, an impression gradually deepened: legal professional discussions still focus on specific conduct and evidence and remain relatively restrained on characterization, but some public discussion has already linked "professional anti-counterfeiting" with "extortion." There is no need here to make an unstatistical judgment about public opinion, but this kind of inference sliding from an individual case to a group tends toward overgeneralization and is also unhelpful for combating the manufacture and sale of counterfeit goods, so it is indeed necessary to analyze it. This article is precisely a further elaboration of the views expressed in the aforementioned interview.

Conduct that uses the name of anti-counterfeiting to infringe on normal business operations and consume social goodwill should be stopped. Deliberately creating product problems, distorting facts to organize online sieges, and using operators' worry about reputational damage to forcibly take property all warrant vigilance. The law's imposition of sanctions on such conduct does not mean that all anti-counterfeiting activities involving remuneration, profit or organizational division of labor have lost their legitimacy. It is equally unreasonable for producers to be suspected because others counterfeit, or for consumers to lose the qualification to complain because others extort.

What the author calls "only conditional professional anti-counterfeiting may be suspected of extortion" has a strict legal meaning. It requires that, beyond the external conduct of anti-counterfeiting, the purpose of illegal possession, the act of threat or coercion, and the corresponding property infringement be ascertained. Fabricating facts, exaggerating damage, and lack of connection can serve as evidence for judging these elements; no single label can by itself perform the function of conviction. In particular, it cannot be understood to mean that merely finding one false statement, or determining that a claim is too high, already proves extortion. For example, in the case of Shang Meina, whom the author defended against a charge of extortion, one of the main reasons Shang Meina was acquitted after 873 days in custody was that the defense insisted on this view. In addition, the completed form of the crime must also prove that the other party disposed of property because of the threat and that the amount was relatively large or the conduct was repeated as required by law; attempt is determined separately according to its provisions.[3]

This distinction should also run through the judgment of the nature of an organization. A large team and a wide geographic scope of complaints can indicate the direction of investigation; whether it constitutes a criminal group, an evil force or an underworld-nature organization must still be determined according to their respective legal conditions. From a specific crime to an organizational crime, every step requires evidence. A change in name cannot replace an increase in proof.

02. The law does not make selflessness a condition for protecting rights

Debate over professional anti-counterfeiting often begins with motive. Some act to safeguard the public interest, some hope to obtain gains through punitive damages, and some have both purposes. Moral evaluation may differ, but criminal law should still distinguish profit motive from the purpose of illegal possession. Compensation that the law clearly permits to be obtained does not become an illegal benefit merely because the claimant hopes to obtain it.

Professor Zhang Mingkai, in "Properly Treat Rights-Protection Conduct to Avoid Encouraging Illegal Crime," set out a clear protective position on professional anti-counterfeiting. He distinguished ordinary knowing purchase of counterfeit goods and rights-protection claims from the conduct of deliberately creating quality problems to defraud compensation, and emphasized that restrictions on rights protection in other branches of law cannot be directly converted into criminal liability; improperly punishing rights-protection conduct may also, in reverse, encourage the illegal crime that is exposed.[4] The importance of this discussion lies in reminding criminal justice to observe the consequences of both punishing and not punishing. Punishing a claimant may protect normal business operations, but may also let operators who have indeed violated the law escape their due responsibility; the distinction can only be found in specific facts.

This article agrees with the distinctions drawn therein regarding profit motive, responsibility under other branches of law, and the boundaries of criminal law. But doctrine and current adjudicative rules must still be kept separate. Giving full protection to genuine reports does not prevent examining whether there is coercive taking of property detached from a rights basis; remaining restrained toward improper conduct in rights protection does not mean permitting infringement of others' person or property. Therefore, Professor Zhang Mingkai's discussion should prompt case handlers to improve their ability to discriminate, and cannot be excerpted as an automatic exemption for any "anti-counterfeiting person."

The current system itself also preserves this distinction. Article 55 of the Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China provides for increased compensation in cases of fraud, and Article 148 of the Food Safety Law of the People's Republic of China provides for punitive damages when conditions are met.[5] These systems allow compensation to exceed direct loss and have the function of urging operators to comply with the law. Proving illegal possession by "the gain exceeds the purchase price" would conflict with the compensation mechanism that the law deliberately establishes. Whether professional status can affect a particular civil claim must still be judged according to the specific law and its scope of application.

The Supreme People's Court's 2024 judicial interpretation on punitive damages for food and drugs, on the one hand, supports claims made with knowledge that food does not meet safety standards within the scope of reasonable daily consumption needs; on the other hand, it provides that where a person deliberately creates the false appearance of a producer or operator violating the law and uses complaints, litigation or other means to carry out suspected extortion, the matter should be transferred to the public security organ.[6] The two directions are written in the same interpretation, meaning that protection and punishment can proceed in parallel. The rules in the food and drug field have their particularity and cannot be extended without distinction into a uniform conclusion for all goods and services.

In January 2026, typical cases released by the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the State Administration for Market Regulation were even more intuitive. Xiang and others punctured food packaging, inserted foreign objects and then claimed compensation, and when merchants questioned them, threatened exposure or complaints; they were found to constitute extortion. In another case, Shi bought expired food for profit, yet the court still supported a refund and 1,000 yuan in compensation within the scope of reasonable daily consumption.[7] Both sets of conduct were broadly placed under "professional claims," yet the outcomes were entirely different. The facts that determine the difference are far more important than the occupational label.

03. Conditions for complaint-and-claim to enter criminal-law evaluation

(1) Whether the property sought has an identifiable rights basis

The distinction between rights protection and extortion should first ascertain why the payment is requested. Refunds, compensation for breach of contract, compensation for tort, punitive damages, and settlements reached over genuine disputes each have their own factual and normative bases. The existence of a disputed claim does not mean the actor knew they had no right. Criminal adjudication cannot directly turn the amount later determined by a civil judge into a boundary that the actor must precisely observe when negotiating.

Room must be preserved here for good-faith mistake. An ordinary consumer may understand a breach as fraud, understand an administrative violation as a voidable contract, or may miscalculate losses. Such understandings should be clarified in civil proceedings, but there is a substantive difference between a mistaken understanding of the law and knowingly taking property by force without right. Determining the purpose of illegal possession requires judging, in light of the course of the transaction, the materials held, the negotiations between the parties and the use of the funds, whether the person genuinely believed their claim had a basis; a reverse inference cannot be drawn merely from the fact that civil support was ultimately not obtained.

The rights basis is also not limited to consumption by the claimant personally. An injured person may entrust an agent to negotiate, and a lawfully established agency relationship does not disappear because it is compensated. The principal's rights, the scope of authorization and the agent's specific conduct should all be ascertained.[8] Otherwise, requiring a paid representative to first become a direct victim before being qualified to assist in rights protection would not only be inconsistent with the agency system but would also make it harder for consumers lacking professional ability to obtain help.

But the right to report and the right to claim compensation are, after all, different. A tourist who discovers a fire-safety hazard in a scenic area may report the situation in accordance with law; if that matter is insufficient to support their personal property claim but is used to demand that the scenic area pay a sum unrelated to damage, contract or statutory compensation, it must be further examined whether a genuine problem is being used to carry out coercive taking of property. The fact that a scenic area has indeed violated the law does not automatically create an obligation to pay a large sum to every discoverer.

(2) The truth or falsity of facts and the scope of the claim must be examined separately

Deliberately putting foreign objects into food, or fabricating the facts of purchase or damage, has already changed the basis of rights protection. If an operator pays because it believes a fabricated damage, fraud may be involved; if it knows a dispute exists but is forced to pay because of threats such as exposure or persistent harassment, extortion may be involved. Deliberate fabrication does not automatically correspond to a particular crime; the mechanism by which property is obtained must also be ascertained.[9]

It is equally necessary to distinguish factual statements, legal evaluations and emotional expressions. "The goods expired on a certain date" is a verifiable fact; "this constitutes fraud" is a legal judgment; "the service is so bad it is unacceptable" carries an evaluative tone. Treating every erroneous legal characterization or heated wording as fabrication of facts would require ordinary people to first meet the expressive standards of legal professionals before daring to file a complaint. What truly requires focused investigation is whether the actor knew key facts were false and still used them to create a disadvantage sufficient to force the other party to pay. As for questions such as "whether Luo Yonghao has the right as a consumer to evaluate Xibei's dishes" and "whether a car reviewer has the right to evaluate car companies based on his own experience," there is in fact not much legal controversy on this issue.

True facts can also be used for extortion. Article 6 of the Supreme People's Court and Supreme People's Procuratorate judicial interpretation on criminal cases such as defamation carried out using information networks includes within the evaluation of extortion the conduct of threatening or coercing others to demand property by handling online information through publication, deletion or other means and meeting statutory conditions, without making falsity of the information a necessary condition.[10] Therefore, truthfulness cannot be the sole reason for innocence; conversely, information unfavorable to an operator cannot automatically be a reason for guilt.

The amount likewise has no independent determinative effect. A consumer's claim higher than actual loss may include statutory increased compensation and reasonable expenses, or may simply be an initial settlement offer. An operator may also accept a plan higher than the likely adjudicated amount in order to save the cost of dispute resolution. This space for negotiation cannot be entirely erased by criminal law. "One hundred times the ticket price" can prompt case handlers to trace the basis of the claim, but there is no rule applicable to all transactions that "exceeding a certain multiple constitutes extortion."

Of course, the amount is by no means irrelevant. An enormous demand wholly divorced from known losses and assertable rights, if accompanied by facts such as knowing one has no entitlement, threatening escalation, and repeatedly changing the name of the payment, can strengthen proof of the intent to illegally possess. One should avoid mechanically treating the entire difference not supported under civil law as the criminal amount, and should also avoid using a small initial dispute to conceal extortion separately carried out later. The original request, subsequent changes, and each payment should be investigated separately.

(3) Whether there is a substantive connection between the pressure applied and the realization of the right

The so-called relatedness is mainly used to test the legitimate connection between the method of pressure and the right asserted. Where an operator sells substandard goods, and the purchaser, in connection with that transaction, demands compensation according to law and states that it will complain to the regulatory authority, there is an easily identifiable connection. Where a person possesses another piece of unfavorable information about the operator and then uses that information to demand benefits unrelated to that person's own rights, a different structure is presented.

However, relatedness cannot be contracted into the rigid requirement of the same subject, the same transaction, and the same facts. One agent may represent multiple consumers, and a continuing illegal problem may also involve multiple transactions. Conversely, even within the same transaction, there may be situations of fabricating damage and separately demanding unrelated payments. Relatedness only provides a reason for judging purpose and means; it cannot replace proof of the complete elements of a crime.

As for the one-hundred-fold claim at the scenic area, the meaning of the so-called "no damage suffered" should first be clarified. The absence of personal injury does not equal the absence of consumer fraud; the absence of quantifiable additional loss does not automatically exclude statutory punitive damages. However, merely discovering clues of illegality unrelated to one's own transactional rights does not entitle one to appoint oneself as the punisher. Citizens may initiate supervision procedures, but administrative fines and other public-law liabilities are handled by the competent authorities according to law and cannot be arbitrarily converted by private individuals into their own income.

(4) Commercial pressure and threats under criminal law cannot be conflated

An operator's wish to reduce complaints, avoid inspections, and protect goodwill has realistic commercial reasons. Genuine consumer reviews and lawful complaints may inherently cause illegal business operations to bear costs.[11] Treating all reputational pressure as fear under criminal law would deprive public opinion supervision of its effect; explaining all business decisions as rational and voluntary would also let pass conduct that uses destruction of goodwill to force payment.

It should be examined what consequences were specifically communicated, whether the actor made them a condition for obtaining money, and why the other party paid. Complaint materials, complete negotiation records, handling approvals, payment times, and the destination of funds explain the issue better than a retrospective statement of "under pressure." Where the facts have been clarified and there is truly no basis for the claim, threatening to continuously create false exposure and organize harassment cannot receive the same evaluation as raising compensation for a genuine consumer dispute and complaining according to law.

Complaining first and then claiming compensation has no automatic legitimizing effect. Claiming compensation first and then complaining also conforms to the usual resolution process of many consumer disputes. Article 39 of the Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China recognizes negotiation, mediation, administrative complaint, arbitration, and litigation, and does not prescribe a precondition of first reporting to the regulatory authority for a lawful claim.[12] The center of judgment is always the content of the conduct and its evidence; sequence cannot replace substantive review.

Withdrawing a disputed complaint after compensation or stating that the dispute has been resolved does not automatically mean selling silence. The question is whether the dispute resolved was genuine, whether the payment had a basis in right, and whether coercion existed. Conversely, a written settlement, a publicity contract, or even the other party's voluntary offer does not automatically exclude extortion. Lawful negotiation and forced acceptance of terms may adopt the same written form.

04. After determining the specific crime, the nature of organized crime and evil forces must still be independently proven

Online content production usually requires division of labor such as planning, filming, editing, and operations. Fixed personnel, unified accounts, and profit distribution may exist in a lawful team and may also be used for crime. To determine joint crime, joint intent and participation conduct must be ascertained; to determine a criminal group, the conditions must also be met that three or more persons form a relatively fixed criminal organization for jointly committing crimes.[13] It cannot be presumed that all personnel knew of and participated in all crimes merely because the arrested persons all worked at the same company.

A mafia-type organization must also simultaneously possess the four characteristics in Article 294, paragraph 5 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China. Organizationally, there should be a relatively stable criminal organization, a relatively large number of persons, clear organizers and leaders, and basically fixed core members; economically, there should be organized acquisition of economic benefits and a certain economic strength to support organizational activities; behaviorally, there should be organized, repeated implementation of illegal and criminal activities by violence, threats, or other means, doing evil, oppressing and harming the masses; and in terms of harm, illegal control or major influence should be formed in a certain region or industry through illegal and criminal activities or by exploiting the protection and connivance of state functionaries, seriously disrupting economic and social order.[14]

These four aspects must be determined in combination; the number of followers cannot replace the economic characteristic, the scope of dissemination cannot replace illegal control, and the number of complainants cannot replace organized illegal and criminal activity. Cross-regional implementation does not automatically exclude organized crime, but nationwide online coverage and the formation of illegal domination in the relevant industry still differ markedly. An operator adjusting its conduct because it accepts lawful supervision is also not subject to control by a criminal organization.

The determination of evil forces applies the conditions provided in Article 2 of the Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China, involving frequent gathering, use of violence, threats, or other means, repeated implementation of illegal and criminal activities, doing evil and oppressing the masses, causing relatively bad social impact, and is bounded by not yet having formed a mafia-type organization. An evil-force criminal group must also meet the statutory conditions of a criminal group.[15] "Mafia-type," "evil force," and "criminal group" cannot be used interchangeably, and the Criminal Law also has no independent "evil force crime" that can encompass all improper conduct.

Supreme People's Court Guiding Case No. 187 is especially instructive. Wu Qiang and others committed extortion, robbery, intentional injury, and other crimes, yet the court still distinguished an ordinary criminal group from an evil-force criminal group. Its adjudication points require examination of doing evil, oppressing the people, and relatively bad social impact, and attention to the openness of the conduct, the coerciveness of the means, and the degree of suppression.[16] Even multiple proven crimes cannot automatically complete the determination of evil forces, and several lawful complaints are even less capable of acquiring the nature of mafia-type or evil-force activity merely by aggregation.

The so-called first determining specific illegal and criminal conduct and then discussing organizational nature is a logical order in proof; it does not require that every case first have a final effective judgment before investigation of organized crime is permitted. Investigation may proceed simultaneously, and evidence may corroborate one another; but an impression of organization cannot in turn lower the incrimination standard for specific conduct, and large-scale implementation cannot be treated as a substitute for the four characteristics.

(2) "Soft violence" does not lower the proof requirements for a specific crime

Organized disturbance, pestering, siege, and online围攻 may form sustained psychological coercion, and their harm is not necessarily manifested as physical injury. Therefore, the absence of traditional violence does not automatically exclude the nature of mafia-type or evil-force activity. Article 23 of the Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China provides for relevant means for the purpose of seeking illegal benefits or forming illegal influence.[17] This provision has practical relevance, but its limitations on purpose, method, and degree of harm should also apply simultaneously.

The scholar Ma Long, in research on soft violence, distinguishes three levels: general, illegal, and constitutive of crime, and emphasizes that the judgment of illegality must still connect with the requirements of the specific charge.[18] Following this approach, affixing the label "soft violence" cannot omit the intent to illegally possess in extortion, nor can it omit the conduct type and order infringement in picking quarrels and provoking trouble. Article 8 of the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Criminal Cases of Implementing "Soft Violence" likewise requires simultaneous conformity with the other constitutive elements of the crime provided in Article 274 of the Criminal Law.[19]

Picking quarrels and provoking trouble should also not become a substitute conclusion when proof of extortion is insufficient. The 2013 judicial interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate distinguishes making trouble without cause, making trouble on pretext, and conduct arising from specific disputes, and the relevant conduct must also meet the statutory circumstances.[20] Frequent complaints, refusal to accept a merchant's proposal, and continuous publication of criticism with a factual basis cannot be classified under this crime merely because the operator feels annoyed. Whether business is obstructed, others are harassed, or other statutory harm is formed requires specific evidence.

VI. Curbing abuse should simultaneously preserve supervision

In governing abuse in professional claims, different measures such as civil, administrative, and criminal measures may be adopted. The Measures for the Handling of Complaints and Reports by Market Supervision Administrations, effective in 2026, permit judgment of whether a complaint is a consumer complaint for daily living based on factors such as purchase quantity and frequency, and expressly distinguish complaints from reports, encouraging social supervision and public opinion supervision.[21] The non-acceptance of a particular complaint addresses the applicability of a specific administrative remedy channel; it cannot directly prove that no illegal clues exist, much less prove that the claimant committed a crime.

Similarly, between reducing unreasonable compensation and stopping repeated occupation of procedural resources, on the one hand, and pursuing criminal liability, on the other, the boundaries of different systems must be preserved. Leaving all problems to criminal law easily turns ordinary people's cost of trial and error into personal liberty. Regulatory authorities investigating according to law, operators preserving genuine transaction and handling records, and platforms stopping rumor-mongering and harassment while preserving space for reasonable criticism are often more helpful in reducing disputes than generalized criminal labels.

In criminal proceedings, the operator's report materials should be verified according to law, and the complainant's favorable evidence should also be collected according to law. Under Articles 52 and 55 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China, both guilt and innocence must be examined around evidence, and conviction should exclude reasonable doubt.[22] Establishing that a claimant is suspected of a crime does not mean that the originally reported production and sale of counterfeit or substandard goods or other illegality may no longer be handled; exposing an operator's illegality also does not exempt the claimant from crimes separately committed. The responsibilities of both parties should be borne separately.

Investigative authorities issuing notices soliciting clues according to law serves their case-handling needs, and the use of the expression "suspected" also has a procedural basis. The public and the media should still preserve this qualification and cannot write investigative judgments as effective adjudications. The principle established in Article 12 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China that no one may be determined guilty without a judgment of the People's Court according to law especially needs to be upheld when public opinion is heated.[23] Objective wording protects both the person under investigation and the factual investigation not yet completed.

Professional anti-counterfeiting claimants should not enjoy extrajudicial privilege, nor should they bear original sin by identity. Criminal law needs to stop infringements carried out in the name of supervision, while avoiding making those who carefully preserve evidence and complain and claim compensation according to law fear being convicted because their rights protection was effective. A proper adjudication should let illegal operators know that illegality has a cost, let malicious money seekers know that coercion has boundaries, and let normal rights defenders know that the law can still be relied upon. Resolutely pursuing liability for specific illegality and exercising restraint toward group labels can proceed in parallel, and should proceed in parallel.

Article Appendix

Questions and answers

When can professional anti-counterfeiting be considered extortion under Chinese law?

It may be extortion only if, beyond anti-counterfeiting conduct, the purpose of illegal possession, the act of threat or coercion, and corresponding property infringement are proven. Fabricating facts, exaggerating damage, or lack of connection can be evidence, but no single label alone convicts.

Does a high compensation claim by a professional anti-counterfeiter automatically constitute extortion?

No. A claim higher than actual loss may include statutory increased compensation and reasonable expenses, or be an initial settlement offer. The amount has no independent determinative effect; there is no rule that exceeding a certain multiple constitutes extortion.

What are the four characteristics required for a mafia-type organization under Article 294 of the Criminal Law?

The four characteristics are: organizational (stable criminal organization with clear leaders), economic (organized acquisition of economic benefits and economic strength), behavioral (repeated illegal activities by violence, threats, or other means), and harm (illegal control or major influence in a region or industry). All must be determined in combination.

Can true facts be used for extortion?

Yes. Article 6 of the judicial interpretation on defamation via information networks includes threatening or coercing others to demand property by publishing or deleting online information, without making falsity a necessary condition. Truthfulness alone does not guarantee innocence, nor does unfavorable information automatically prove guilt.

How does the Consumer Rights Protection Law treat professional anti-counterfeiting claims?

Article 55 provides increased compensation for fraud, and Article 39 recognizes negotiation, mediation, administrative complaint, arbitration, and litigation without requiring prior reporting. Proving illegal possession merely because gain exceeds purchase price would conflict with this compensation mechanism.

Laws and cases cited

Laws

  • Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China
  • Food Safety Law of the People's Republic of China
  • Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China
  • Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China
  • Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China

Regulations

  • Measures for the Handling of Complaints and Reports by Market Supervision Administrations

Judicial interpretations

  • Supreme People's Court's 2024 judicial interpretation on punitive damages for food and drugs
  • Supreme People's Court and Supreme People's Procuratorate judicial interpretation on criminal cases such as defamation carried out using information networks
  • Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Criminal Cases of Implementing "Soft Violence"
  • 2013 judicial interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate

Cases

  • Supreme People's Court Guiding Case No. 187

References

  1. See Xin Yuan, "Anti-counterfeiting internet celebrity 'Tietou' sentenced to 8 years in first instance, conspired with others to threaten exposure of damaging information in exchange for gold", Jiemian News, September 11, 2026. Changchun Public Security Bureau notice soliciting leads dated August 28, 2026, see Zhang Yuxin, "Blogger with a million followers arrested in organized crime case—fighting fakes or faking the fight?", Jiemian News, September 12, 2026.
  2. See Zhang Yuxin, "Blogger with a million followers arrested in organized crime case—fighting fakes or faking the fight?", Jiemian News, September 12, 2026, the portion of the article in which Xu Qin was interviewed.
  3. Article 23 and Article 274 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China; Articles 1 and 3 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases of Extortion (Fa Shi [2013] No. 10).
  4. See Zhang Mingkai, "Properly Treat Rights-Protection Conduct to Avoid Encouraging Illegal and Criminal Conduct", in Chinese Criminal Science, No. 5, 2020, pp. 3–19, especially Part III, "Professional Anti-Counterfeiting Conduct".
  5. Article 55, paragraph 1 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests; Article 148, paragraph 2 of the Food Safety Law of the People's Republic of China.
  6. Articles 12 to 17 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Cases Involving Disputes over Punitive Damages for Food and Drugs (Fa Shi [2024] No. 9), effective August 22, 2024.
  7. See the Typical Cases on Regulating Professional Claims and Maintaining Market Order issued on January 29, 2026 by the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the State Administration for Market Regulation, Case 2 (Xiang and others deliberately manufacturing food quality problems to claim compensation) and Case 5 (Shi purchasing expired food to claim compensation).
  8. Articles 161 and 162 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China; Article 11 of the Measures for Handling Complaints and Reports by Market Regulation Authorities (Order No. 121 of the State Administration for Market Regulation) on entrusted complaints. The act of agency itself must also comply with authorization and the relevant practice management rules; being paid is not inherently lawful or unlawful.
  9. Articles 266 and 274 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China. See also the Typical Cases on Regulating Professional Claims and Maintaining Market Order issued on January 29, 2026 by the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the State Administration for Market Regulation, Case 3 on the handling of circumstances in which Huang and others forged transaction information, orders and refund vouchers.
  10. Article 6 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Such as Defamation Committed by Using Information Networks (Fa Shi [2013] No. 21). That article expressly requires the use of threats or coercion to demand public or private property and the reaching of the threshold of a relatively large amount or repeated commission.
  11. See Articles 15 and 17 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests; Articles 1025 and 1026 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China on reporting in the public interest, public opinion supervision and the duty of reasonable verification. Reporting and criticism in the public interest must still observe legal boundaries such as not fabricating or distorting facts and not insulting others.
  12. Article 39 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests; Articles 18, 23 and 27 of the Measures for Handling Complaints and Reports by Market Regulation Authorities (Order No. 121 of the State Administration for Market Regulation).
  13. Articles 25 and 26 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China. See also Articles 6 and 11 of the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Criminal Cases Involving Evil Forces, which distinguish those who were deceived, those temporarily hired, and the subjective awareness of members.
  14. Article 294, paragraphs 1 and 5 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China. Paragraph 5 requires that an organization with the nature of a criminal syndicate simultaneously possess the four characteristics of organization, economic strength, conduct and harmfulness.
  15. Article 2 of the Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China; Articles 4 to 11 of the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Handling of Criminal Cases Involving Evil Forces.
  16. Guiding Case No. 187 of the Supreme People's Court, "Wu Qiang and others case of extortion, robbery and intentional injury", case number (2017) Su 0612 Xing Chu No. 830.
  17. Article 23 of the Anti-Organized Crime Law of the People's Republic of China.
  18. See Ma Long, "Correction of Criminal Soft Violence and Its Specific Application", in Journal of Chengdu University of Technology (Social Sciences), No. 5, 2022.
  19. Articles 1–5 and Article 8 of the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security and the Ministry of Justice on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Involving the Implementation of "Soft Violence".
  20. Article 293 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China; Articles 1 to 5 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble (Fa Shi [2013] No. 18).
  21. Articles 3, 6, 7, 9, 16, 17, 42 and 46 of the Measures for Handling Complaints and Reports by Market Regulation Authorities.
  22. Articles 52 and 55 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China; Article 27 of the Measures for Handling Complaints and Reports by Market Regulation Authorities; Article 17 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Cases Involving Disputes over Punitive Damages for Food and Drugs.
  23. Article 12 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China.