01. The case file is only the starting point
Many of the criminal cases the author has handled had already passed the investigation stage when they were taken on. The file lies before you—the indictment opinion, interrogation records, victim statements, expert opinions, electronic data, fund flows and so on—and the materials appear complete. But in actual practice, the author's first step is not to rush to write a defence statement or legal opinion, but to read the file first as the result of investigative activity. Who found the evidence, why this piece, why not another, why only this segment of chat records was excerpted, why the upstream supplier was not traced, the original carrier not examined, the transaction background not verified—these questions matter more than simply extracting contradictions.
The Criminal Procedure Law provides that the duty of defence counsel is, on the basis of facts and law, to present materials and opinions showing that the criminal suspect or defendant is innocent, has committed a lesser crime, or should have criminal responsibility reduced or exempted, and to safeguard his litigation rights and other lawful rights and interests. In practice, the author understands this to involve two layers of work: one is examining the evidence in the file, the other is presenting materials and opinions. Where the materials come from and how the opinions are formed both depend on re-examining the facts of the case.
The investigative authorities usually have a starting point: a report, a tip-off, an administrative referral, an online lead, platform data, a victim statement. An initial hypothesis is then formed, and evidence is gathered around that hypothesis. Once the hypothesis is formed, the direction of evidence gathering tends to follow the narrative of guilt. In the author's view, the defence lawyer's job is to walk this road backwards: first find the supporting point of the accusation, then find the material beneath that supporting point, and finally see whether the material can sustain the elements of the offence.
This is investigative thinking in criminal defence. It is a method of handling cases: taking the file apart, taking the accusation apart, taking the process by which the evidence was formed apart. What is in the file must be examined; what is missing from the file must be examined even more.
02. Deconstructing the underlying logic of the accusation
One cannot begin with a preconceived shout of innocence. The first step in criminal defence is to break the charge down into facts to be proved. Each fact to be proved must correspond to evidence. Where there is no evidence, there is the point of dispute; where there is only inference and no fact, there is the breakthrough point.
Take the case the author handled in which the conviction for selling goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark was reversed. The prosecution usually has to prove four matters: that the goods were goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark; that the actor carried out an act of selling or holding for sale; that the actor knew subjectively; and that the amount or circumstances reached the threshold for criminal liability. The judicial interpretation on intellectual property crimes effective from 26 April 2025 lists several circumstances for finding "knowledge" in the sale of goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark, while preserving room for rebuttal, that is, except where evidence proves that the person did not actually know. This leaves practical room for the defence. A lawyer cannot merely say "there was no knowledge"; he must also ascertain what facts the prosecution uses to infer knowledge.
If the prosecution infers knowledge from "the purchase price being obviously low", then normal market discounts, clearance channels, platform subsidies and the agency price system must be examined. If the prosecution infers knowledge from "irregular channels", then the upstream supplier's qualifications, authorisation documents, the flow of goods, payment routes, logistics records, batch codes and anti-counterfeiting codes must be traced. The more specific the logic of the accusation, the more direction the defence investigation has.
The same is true of another fraud case the author handled, which ended in non-prosecution. Fraud is not the criminal-law expression of an ordinary failed transaction. A fraud charge must resolve the deceptive act, the mistaken understanding, the disposal of property, the result of loss and the purpose of illegal possession. If defence counsel only looks for contradictions in the victim's statement, it is easy to remain on the surface. What really needs to be examined is the actor's complete conduct before and after obtaining the property: whether risks were disclosed, whether there was preparation to perform, whether there was genuine investment, whether there was continuous communication, whether there was repayment or remediation, whether there was absconding, changing phone numbers or transferring property. The purpose of illegal possession usually cannot be proved by a single sentence; it must be inferred from the chain of conduct, and it can also be overturned by the chain of conduct.
03. Turning doubts into evidentiary leads that can be submitted
Writing "the facts are unclear and the evidence insufficient" in a defence submission is usually not difficult, and it is what many defence lawyers write. What is difficult is explaining what is unclear, why it is insufficient, what evidence is missing, and what should be obtained next. The Criminal Procedure Law allows defence lawyers, with the consent of the relevant units and individuals, to collect materials, and also allows them to apply to the People's Procuratorate or the People's Court to collect and obtain evidence. The Rules of Criminal Procedure of the People's Procuratorate also provide that where defence counsel believes that exculpatory or mitigating evidence collected by the public security organ during investigation has not been submitted, he may apply to the procuratorial organ to obtain it from the public security organ; after the case is transferred for prosecution, where defence counsel applies to the procuratorial organ to collect or obtain evidence, the procuratorial organ shall review it and explain the result of its handling. At the trial stage, the Supreme People's Court's interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law also sets out the route for defence counsel to apply to the People's Court to obtain exculpatory or mitigating evidence and to collect or obtain evidence from witnesses, units and individuals.
On paper these provisions are the basis of lawyers' rights; in practice they are important tools. For a tool to be usable, the application must not be vague. An application to obtain evidence should preferably state three things clearly: first, the name of the evidence or the evidentiary lead; second, the object of proof; third, why the evidence may affect conviction or sentencing.
04. How investigative thinking is put into practice
(1) The case of Zhao (pseudonym) for selling goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark
In cases such as the one the author handled for Zhao for selling goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark, a common defence mistake is to focus on the right holder's expert opinion and repeatedly argue about "whether the goods are fake". This direction needs to be pursued, but it is not enough. The source of the goods is more critical.
If a search through public channels reveals that some of the goods involved may have come from a gold medal agent of the trademark owner, the defence then has a new handle. The next step is to turn the leads behind the webpage screenshots into a chain of evidence: whether the agent actually exists; whether the authorisation period covers the time involved; whether the authorised region and category cover the goods involved; whether the transaction documents, payment records and logistics records correspond to the goods involved; whether the batch, anti-counterfeiting codes and packaging details match goods within the right holder's system; and whether the right holder or the agent can issue a statement or accept verification by the judicial authorities.
Through defence thinking and public channels, it was found that the vast majority of the goods came from this Company B, which was a gold medal agent of the trademark owner. Combined with the evidence in the file, the case was ultimately reversed.
(2) The case of Kuang (pseudonym) for illegal business operation
In another case the author handled, the non-prosecution case of Kuang (pseudonym) for illegal business operation, illegal business operation cases often rely on judgments such as "knowingly committing an illegal act", "joint operation" and "participation in decision-making". The chat records submitted by the investigative authorities usually highlight the segments pointing to illegal business operation. Defence counsel cannot simply follow these segments. One should return to the complete chat records and examine what the actor actually knew at the time, what he did not know, what he asked, what he was told, and what he was responsible for.
The key here is completeness. A single sentence "I did not know" has little force. Repeated inquiries, repeated explanations, the absence of any share in the operating profits, combined with the relationship with the other persons carrying out the illegal business operation, will significantly increase the probative force. In the end, by sorting out the evidence in the chat records showing that Kuang clearly did not participate in the factual criminal conduct, and combined with the final legal opinion, statutory non-prosecution was achieved.
(3) The fraud case of Xun
In the non-prosecution fraud case of Xun that the author handled, chat records were often used to prove fabricated facts or delaying deception. What defence counsel needs to examine is the full picture of the chat records. Before the incident, how did the actor introduce the matter; during the transaction, were the risks and difficulties disclosed; after a dispute arose, did he explain the reasons, propose solutions, continue to perform or return part of the money; did the victim understand the transaction risks; and was there a long-term cooperative relationship between the parties.
The basis of the prosecution's accusation was that the matter entrusted could not possibly be completed and that he exaggerated his own ability to handle cases, and it submitted the prosecution's version of the chat records. But by comparing the chat records, it was ultimately found that there were key differences between the prosecution's version and the defence's version: the prosecution's version had deleted three chat records, and these three key chat records showed that Xun had no intent to defraud—on the one hand, he himself believed the matter could definitely be accomplished, and on the other hand, he truthfully informed the other party of the true situation. In the end, the case naturally resulted in non-prosecution.
The greatest fear in fraud defence is saying only "there was no purpose of illegal possession". That sentence itself has no evidentiary force. What is truly useful is to express: which objective conduct is incompatible with a purpose of illegal possession, which materials can prove that the actor still had the will and ability to perform when obtaining the property, and which subsequent conduct shows that he was dealing with transaction risk rather than criminal proceeds.
05. What the reversal of wrongful convictions teaches defence lawyers
One common feature of criminal wrongful convictions is that once an early hypothesis of guilt is formed, subsequent proceedings tend to reinforce that hypothesis. When the Nie Shubin case was retried and he was acquitted, public materials showed that the case lacked objective evidence capable of establishing that he committed the crime, that there were major doubts about the time of the crime, the source of the instrument used, and the time and cause of the victim's death, and that the evidence on which the original judgment was based did not form a complete chain. In the Zhang Yuhuan case, the procuratorial organ's opinion at the retrial pointed out that the probative force of the original physical evidence was insufficient and that the confession of guilt differed materially on important points such as the place and method of the crime and the time of disposal of the body; the Jiangxi High People's Court ultimately declared Zhang Yuhuan innocent on 4 August 2020.[8] In the retrial of the Hugjiltu case, the Inner Mongolia High People's Court held that the original facts were unclear and the evidence insufficient, accepted the defence opinion and the procuratorial organ's opinion, and declared him innocent.
These cases remind criminal defence lawyers that they cannot treat "the materials already in the file" as the boundary of the facts. What really needs to be asked is whether there is objective evidence establishing the defendant's guilt; whether the confession corroborates the physical evidence, the scene and the timeline; whether the circumstantial evidence forms a complete chain; and whether there is another possibility that cannot be excluded.
The value of investigative thinking lies in blocking the advance of an erroneous narrative as early as possible. At the investigation stage, the review-for-prosecution stage and the first-instance stage, the cost of correction increases with each step forward. The earlier defence counsel clearly explains the evidentiary gaps and submits new evidentiary leads, the more likely it is that the case will be prevented from being pushed along by procedural inertia.
06. Make investigative thinking visualizable so that the path can be replicated
The author finds case work rather tiring, mainly because the case-handling machinery is very fine-grained. The author believes that investigative thinking cannot stop at feeling; it must be made visualizable. In practice, it can be advanced along the following path, for reference:
1. Break down the charge. Break the charged offense into its constituent elements and the facts to be proved, for example the act, the result, causation, subjective knowledge, the purpose of illegal possession, the amount, the circumstances, and the position in a joint crime.
2. Draw an evidence map. Place each piece of evidence under the corresponding fact to be proved, indicating what it proves, who formed it, when it was formed, how strong its probative force is, and whether it needs corroboration.
3. Work backward to the evidence-collection route. See where the investigative organ started, in what direction it collected evidence, which materials were focused on and fixed, and which materials did not appear.
4. List the missing evidence. Write out as a list the evidence that "should exist but did not appear," for example complete chat records, original carriers, authorization documents, logistics records, platform back-end data, detailed bank statements, and upstream supply materials.
5. Propose alternative explanations. Using the existing evidence and the evidence to be supplemented, construct another scheme that can explain the facts of the case, for example a lawful source, auxiliary role of the position, failed transaction, shared risk, or obstacle to performance.
6. Convert into procedural applications. Write the leads into applications to obtain evidence, applications for supplementary investigation, applications for re-examination, applications for witnesses to appear in court, applications for persons with specialized knowledge to appear in court, and applications to exclude illegally obtained evidence.
7. Form an evidence catalog. When submitting defense evidence, state the source, form, object of proof, and relationship to the constituent elements of the crime, and avoid submitting materials in a scattered manner.
07. Investigate lawfully and avoid turning the defense into a risk
Emphasizing investigative thinking must go together with emphasizing compliance boundaries. Defense lawyers do not have compulsory investigative powers; investigation and evidence collection must be lawful, truthful, and complete. The Criminal Procedure Law prohibits defenders from helping criminal suspects or defendants to conceal, destroy, or fabricate evidence or to collude in testimony, and also prohibits threatening or inducing witnesses to commit perjury and other acts that interfere with judicial activities.
Investigation by criminal defense lawyers is about finding facts that already exist, fixing them, and submitting them, and absolutely not about manufacturing evidence, contaminating evidence, or inducing testimony. In the author's experience, investigative organs are not naive; some defenders who guide clients to fabricate evidence or induce changes in testimony are usually just being clever, and they both harm the client and may harm themselves.
Conclusion
Criminal defense cannot be satisfied with finding contradictions in the case file. Good defense will dig downward along the prosecution's evidence to find the path by which the evidence was formed; it will also investigate outward against the alleged facts to find omitted facts.
The tracing of the source of goods in Zhao's case, the search for the "unaware" chat records in Kuang's case, and the restoration of the complete communication context in Xun's fraud case all point to the same judgment: criminal defense lawyers must have an investigative awareness. Without investigation, many doubts can only remain on paper; with investigation, doubts may become evidence, and evidence may change the direction of the case.
Investigative thinking applies equally in criminal defense. For criminal defense lawyers, it is the ability to "investigate" the case all over again: to examine where the evidence comes from, to examine whether there is another explanation for the facts, and to examine whether the accusation has excluded reasonable doubt. Criminal proceedings ultimately deal with people's freedom. In the face of freedom, good defense cannot be merely commentary on the case file. Defense should enter the facts, enter the evidence, and enter the scene and context in which the case occurred.
Questions and answers
What is investigative thinking in criminal defence?
It is a method of handling cases that treats the file as the result of investigative activity: taking apart the file, the accusation and the process by which evidence was formed, and examining what is missing from the file as well as what is in it.
How does the judicial interpretation on intellectual property crimes effective from 26 April 2025 affect defences to selling counterfeit trademarked goods?
It lists circumstances for finding knowledge in the sale of goods bearing a counterfeit registered trademark while preserving room for rebuttal, except where evidence proves the person did not actually know. This leaves practical room for the defence to examine the facts used to infer knowledge.
What should an application to obtain evidence in a criminal case state?
An application to obtain evidence should clearly state the name of the evidence or the evidentiary lead, the object of proof, and why the evidence may affect conviction or sentencing.
What compliance boundaries apply to criminal defence lawyers conducting investigation?
Defence lawyers do not have compulsory investigative powers; investigation must be lawful, truthful and complete. The Criminal Procedure Law prohibits helping suspects or defendants conceal, destroy or fabricate evidence, collude in testimony, or threaten or induce witnesses to commit perjury.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Criminal Procedure Law
Judicial interpretations
- judicial interpretation on intellectual property crimes effective from 26 April 2025
- Rules of Criminal Procedure of the People's Procuratorate
- Supreme People's Court's interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law
Cases
- Nie Shubin case
- Zhang Yuhuan case
- Hugjiltu case
References
- Article 37 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China.
- Article 4 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases of Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights (Fa Shi [2025] No. 5), effective April 26, 2025.
- Article 43 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China; see also Article 44 on the practice boundaries of defenders, such as not concealing, destroying, or fabricating evidence or colluding in testimony.
- Articles 50 and 52 of the Criminal Procedure Rules of the People's Procuratorate.
- Articles 49 to 52 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China.
- Provisions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, and the Ministry of Public Security on Several Issues Concerning the Collection, Extraction, and Review and Judgment of Electronic Data in the Handling of Criminal Cases, concerning requirements such as integrity protection of electronic data, sealing of original storage media, integrity check values, and at least two investigators.
- "Supreme People's Court Retrial Declares Nie Shubin Not Guilty," reposted on the official website of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, December 2, 2016.
- "Correcting the Zhang Yuhuan Case: A Rule-of-Law Footnote to 'No Punishment in Case of Doubt'," official website of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, February 3, 2021.
- "Inner Mongolia High People's Court Declares Hugjiltu Not Guilty on Retrial," official website of the Supreme People's Court, December 16, 2014.