[Abstract]: Article 20 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees, formulated and promulgated by the Supreme People's Court of China in 2016, sets strict preconditions for permanently enjoining payment under an on-demand independent guarantee. Examining these conditions, especially how they are actually applied in real litigation cases heard by the Supreme People's Court itself, and in particular exploring the judges' reasoning and analytical approach in the judgments of real cases, and summarizing this in a timely manner, is truly necessary for guiding international and domestic commercial and banking practice, and also provides extremely useful guidance for Chinese courts at all levels hearing similar cases. This is the second part of the article.
5. Legal Principle Five: The plaintiff seeking to enjoin payment under a standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) bears the burden of proof, and the proof must meet the "beyond reasonable doubt" standard
5.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
Article 20 of the Judicial Interpretation provides: "Where, in hearing a case of independent guarantee fraud, the people's court is able to determine beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted, and none of the circumstances in Article 14, paragraph 3 of these Provisions exists, it shall rule that the issuer terminate payment of the amount claimed under the independent guarantee."
5.2 Authoritative precedents of the Supreme People's Court
5.2.1 The Supreme People's Court's position in the "Himalayan Bank case"
According to the "Himalayan Bank case"[1] and the "ANZ Bank case" published by the Supreme People's Court, where an applicant under an independent guarantee or standby letter of credit asserts that the beneficiary has committed fraud under the guarantee, its standard of proof must reach the level of "beyond reasonable doubt." The Supreme People's Court's judgment in the "Himalayan Bank case"[2] is quoted as follows:
"Article 6 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions provides: 'Where the documents submitted by the beneficiary appear on their face to conform to the terms of the independent guarantee and to one another, and the beneficiary requests the issuer to assume payment liability under the independent guarantee, the people's court shall support it. Where the issuer raises a defense against the payment obligation based on the underlying transaction relationship or the independent guarantee application relationship, the people's court shall not support it, except in the circumstances of Article 12 of these Provisions.' This article embodies the institutional value of the 'pay on demand' nature of independent guarantees and safeguards the commercial function of independent guarantees to 'pay first, dispute later.' A bank issuing an independent guarantee is only responsible for examining whether the documents submitted by the beneficiary conform to the terms of the guarantee and has the right to decide on its own whether to pay; the guarantor bank's payment obligation is not affected by any defense under the underlying transaction between the principal and the beneficiary. Therefore, the people's court's review of the underlying transaction should adhere to the principles of limited review and necessity. According to the facts ascertained in the original review, the independent guarantees issued by Himalayan Bank and Kathmandu Bank respectively stated: 'Himalayan Bank hereby irrevocably undertakes the following payment: upon receipt of the written demand and written statement of the Malange Committee reflecting that the contractor has breached its contractual obligations, without the Malange Committee needing to prove the circumstances and the amount demanded, Himalayan Bank will pay...' and 'Kathmandu Bank hereby irrevocably undertakes that upon receipt of the written demand and written statement of the Malange Committee reflecting that the contractor has used the advance payment for purposes other than project mobilization, in breach of its contractual obligations, Kathmandu Bank will pay...' Therefore, where a dispute has arisen between the parties over performance of the underlying contract, and no arbitral award or effective judgment has yet clarified and determined the rights and obligations the parties should bear in performing the contract, the Malange Committee's assertion that China Railway 15th Bureau breached the contract and its issuance of written payment demands to Himalayan Bank and Kathmandu Bank under the advance payment guarantee and performance guarantee, claiming amounts under the guarantees, conformed to the terms of the guarantees, and it cannot be found that the Malange Committee 'knowingly had no right to payment' yet still abused that right. China Railway 15th Bureau failed to submit sufficient evidence to prove that the Malange Committee's payment demand involved a fraudulent claim under Article 12 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions; the original judgment's refusal to support China Railway 15th Bureau's claim that the Malange Committee committed guarantee fraud was correct in its findings of fact and application of law. Therefore, China Railway 15th Bureau's grounds for retrial alleging that the Malange Committee committed guarantee fraud cannot be established."
5.2.2 The Supreme People's Court's position in an authoritative case involving an injunction against payment under a standby letter of credit
In the first-instance judgment[3] of the letter of credit fraud dispute case of China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch, et al., heard at first instance and with final effect by the Commercial Division of the Supreme People's Court, it was further made clear:
"Upon further trial, the evidence submitted by China Electric regarding the alleged fraud of ANZ Bank Manila Branch did not meet the proof standard of 'beyond reasonable doubt' under Article 20 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions..."
In the most recent and most authoritative standby letter of credit case of the Commercial Court of the Supreme People's Court, the 'letter of credit fraud dispute case of China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch, et al.'[4], the Supreme People's Court gave the following detailed explanation of the 'beyond reasonable doubt' proof standard set out in the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees:
"(2) Whether ANZ Bank Manila Branch committed the fraud circumstance provided in Article 12, item 5 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions
Article 12, item 5 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions provides: 'Where the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to payment, still abuses that right, the people's court shall find that independent guarantee fraud is constituted.' Under this provision, if the beneficiary's payment demand is made with knowledge that it has no right to payment, it constitutes an abuse of the right to payment and constitutes fraud. This Court holds that, although strictly speaking, in the fraud circumstance of abuse of the right to payment, the point in time for assessing the beneficiary's subjective bad faith should also be limited to the time of making the claim, in practice there indeed exist situations where the beneficiary's subjective state of knowledge changes. If, at the time of its claim, it believed in good faith that it had a right to payment, but subsequently, upon learning the fact that the right to payment had been lost, insisted on not withdrawing the claim, this may be found to constitute fraud, because at that point it no longer has a legally protected interest. However, the situation in this case is that Jiangsu Bank was originally supposed to pay USD 22,979,687.50 under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit based on the claim of ANZ Bank Manila Branch, but it paid only USD 7,313,543.30; after the court's injunction was lifted at the end of May 2019, Jiangsu Bank was then obliged to continue payment, and ANZ Bank Manila Branch's right to payment against Jiangsu Bank had not been extinguished. The Settlement Agreement signed between Kangsongji Company and ANZ Bank Manila Branch on May 11, 2017, and the Waiver Letter/Certificate issued on September 13, 2017, promising to withdraw the claim under the Standby Letter of Credit and acknowledging that the Standby Letter of Credit had expired and was no longer valid, also had no effect on ANZ Bank Manila Branch's right to payment under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit. This is because the Settlement Agreement resolved the claim under the Standby Letter of Credit, not the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit, and the Settlement Agreement provided that ANZ Bank Manila Branch should pay USD 6 million to Kangsongji Company and then return to Kangsongji Company the claim letters under the two standby letters of credit, the Standby Letter of Credit at issue and the Standby Letter of Credit of Zhongji Company, stamped 'cancelled'; only after Kangsongji Company received the USD 6 million did it unconditionally and irrevocably release the claims, assertions, liabilities and litigation against ANZ Bank Manila Branch under the two standby letters of credit. That is, Kangsongji Company's promise to waive its claim against ANZ Bank Manila Branch was premised on the consideration of ANZ Bank Manila Branch's payment of USD 6 million; in substance, the claim amount was reduced to USD 6 million and the claim for the remaining unpaid portion was withdrawn, and the USD 6 million actually paid by ANZ Bank Manila Branch was in substance not within the scope of the withdrawn claim. Because the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit is independent of the Standby Letter of Credit, Jiangsu Bank's payment obligation under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit was not extinguished by the repayment arrangement under the Standby Letter of Credit.
China Electric also asserted that the lawyer's letter sent by ANZ Bank Manila Branch to Jiangsu Bank on July 19, 2019, requesting payment of USD 6 million, was a new claim maliciously made by ANZ Bank Manila Branch under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit. It should be noted that there was only one claim and presentation under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit at issue, namely the conforming claim made by ANZ Bank Manila Branch on November 27, 2015; that claim was not fully paid and did not lapse. The lawyer's letter was in the nature of a written demand urging Jiangsu Bank to perform the payment obligation claimed under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit, and did not constitute a new claim. The lawyer's letter's statement that the claim amount was reduced from USD 15,666,144.20 to USD 6 million was in the nature of a voluntary waiver of part of the claim amount, and was also not a new claim. Jiangsu Bank also argued that the Settlement Agreement signed between Kangsongji Company and ANZ Bank Manila Branch covered not only the Standby Letter of Credit at issue but also the Standby Letter of Credit of Zhongji Company, etc.; however, the Settlement Agreement was not a matter subject to review as agreed in the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit, and based on the documentary and independent characteristics of standby letter of credit transactions, Jiangsu Bank had no right to defend against its payment obligation under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit by relying on the Settlement Agreement.
In summary, China Electric asserted that ANZ Bank Manila Branch committed the fraud circumstances provided in Article 12, items 4 and 5 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions, but the evidence it provided could not meet the proof standard of beyond reasonable doubt under Article 20 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions; China Electric's claims cannot be established and this Court does not support them." (Emphasis added by the author.)
From this authoritative precedent, to seek to enjoin payment under a standby letter of credit on the ground of the beneficiary's fraud or abuse of rights exception, the plaintiff's proof must meet the 'beyond reasonable doubt' proof standard. However, the proof of the appellee in this case falls far short of this standard.
6. Legal Principle Six: A Chinese court's 'limited review' of the underlying contract must not exceed the scope of 'limited and necessary'
6.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
Article 18 of the Judicial Interpretation provides: "In hearing a case of independent guarantee fraud or handling an application for injunction against payment, the people's court may review and determine the relevant facts of the underlying transaction with respect to the specific circumstances of Article 12 of these Provisions asserted by the parties."
The Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees provides for a "limited review" of the underlying contract only in Article 18, but this principle was unexpectedly interpreted and developed into the principle of "limited and necessary review" in later precedents [5]. However, the subsequent overwhelming number of authoritative cases of the Supreme People's Court did not follow this "limited and necessary review principle"; all of them supported the "limited review principle" [6]. The precedents of other provincial high courts did not follow this "development" that was inconsistent with the original drafting intent. Among the cases before the Judicial Interpretation took effect, the first case to apply limited review was the civil judgment on appeal of the Tianjin Higher People's Court, "Appellant Gribwal Cement Co., Ltd. v. Appellee Sinoma Equipment Group Co., Ltd. and Appellee Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited Tianjin Branch, Guarantee Fraud Dispute" (4 November 2013), and the appellate judgment in that case was upheld by the Supreme People's Court's ruling on retrial review [7].
6.2 Authoritative Precedents of the Supreme People's Court
6.2.1 The Position of the Supreme People's Court in the Retrial of the "Russian Construction Bank Case"
In the judgment in which the Supreme People's Court ordered retrial by itself, it expressly stated [8]:
"This Court holds that an independent guarantee is independent of the underlying transaction, and the guarantee and the counter-guarantee are each independent, and only a limited review should be conducted of the underlying transaction and of litigation under the underlying transaction. Shenyang Yuanda did not provide evidence proving that the claim of CCB Bank Esen Tepe Branch under the counter-guarantee constituted a circumstance specified in Article 12 of the Provisions on Independent Guarantees; therefore, it cannot be found that the claim of CCB Bank Esen Tepe Branch under the counter-guarantee constituted fraud."
6.2.2 The Position of the Supreme People's Court in the Ruling in the "Yiwu ICBC Retrial Case"
Supreme People's Court, Yiwu ICBC Case [9] "(10) On the issue of limited review of facts related to the underlying transaction
Article 18 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees provides: "When a people's court hears a case of independent guarantee fraud dispute or handles an application for stop-payment, it may, with respect to the specific circumstances of Article 12 of these Provisions asserted by the parties, review and determine the relevant facts of the underlying transaction." This article provides the principle of limited review in hearing cases related to independent guarantees. The word "may" in this provision indicates that a people's court may, according to the specific circumstances of the case, decide whether to review the relevant facts of the underlying transaction, rather than being required to review the relevant facts of the underlying transaction. The appellate court in this case reviewed part of the facts of the underlying contract and the underlying transaction, and also conducted a preliminary review of Zhonggao Company's breach, which conforms to the provisions of the above Judicial Interpretation. Yiwu ICBC's assertion that the appellate judgment erred by not conducting a limited review is inconsistent with both the facts of this case and the provisions of the above Judicial Interpretation."
7. Legal Principle Seven: The subject applying for a stop-payment order must be qualified. Only the applicant for the letter of credit and the issuer itself can apply for a stop-payment order; an issuer's guarantor or other interested party is not a qualified subject to apply for a stop-payment order
7.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
According to Article 13 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees: "Where the applicant, issuer or instructing party of an independent guarantee discovers any circumstance specified in Article 12 of these Provisions, it may, before instituting litigation or applying for arbitration, apply to the people's court at the domicile of the issuer or another people's court with jurisdiction over the independent guarantee fraud dispute case for suspension of payment of the funds under the independent guarantee, and may also make such an application during litigation or arbitration."
7.2 Authoritative Cases of the Supreme People's Court
In its civil retrial ruling (2021) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 5896 concerning the "China Railway 15th Bureau Independent Guarantee Case" made in 2022, the Supreme People's Court held that only the performing party that bears performance liability under the underlying contract is a qualified plaintiff. [10]
8. Legal Principle Eight: Payment under a terminated standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) cannot provide effective judicial relief: two previous cases involving Bank of China
8.1 Case 1: The parallel litigation case between Shandong courts and English courts concerning an independent guarantee: the "Rushan Shipyard Case"
According to the precedent of the Shandong Higher People's Court (2015) Lu Shang Chu Zi No. 71 [11], "Industrial and Commercial Bank of China... [sic: Bank of China] Shandong Branch v. China Electronics Import and Export Shandong Company, Rongcheng Xixiakou Shipbuilding Co., Ltd. and Xixiakou Group Co., Ltd., Right of Recourse Dispute", even though a Chinese court had ordered permanent stop-payment of the guarantee or standby letter of credit, the English court did not recognize it and was still able to enforce Bank of China's assets in England. Since Australia is also a Commonwealth country, English precedents apply. Therefore, even if a Chinese court permanently stops payment under the standby letter of credit at issue, an Australian court may still enforce Bank of China's assets in Australia to satisfy the judgment. The quotation is as follows:
"After the Qingdao Maritime Court issued the stop-payment ruling, Bank of China Shandong Branch did not voluntarily pay the funds under the guarantee. Because Bank of China Shandong Branch refused to pay, Seafort Company sued Bank of China Head Office in the English court, and the English court ruled that Bank of China Head Office should pay the funds under the guarantee. If Bank of China Head Office did not perform the judgment, it would not only damage its financial reputation, but also, since the judgment did not need to be recognized and enforced in China, Seafort Company could apply to the English court to enforce Bank of China Head Office's overseas assets. Therefore, Bank of China Head Office was forced to perform the judgment through its London Branch. Payment by Bank of China Head Office through its London Branch was equivalent to payment by Bank of China Shandong Branch of the funds under the guarantee. From the above facts it can be seen that Bank of China Shandong Branch's payment of the funds under the guarantee was not an intentional violation of the litigation preservation ruling made by the Qingdao Maritime Court, but was caused by Bank of China Shandong Branch's performance of the English court judgment after the objective circumstances changed; in this regard, Bank of China Shandong Branch was not at fault in its act of paying the funds under the guarantee."
8.2 Case 2: The parallel litigation case between the Guangzhou Intermediate Court and the Hong Kong court: the "Bank of China Guangzhou Intermediate Court Case"
In its first-instance judgment in the "Huodian Company v. Attarat Company Guarantee Fraud Case" [12], the Guangzhou Intermediate Court pointed out that the issuing bank's payment obligation under the guarantee is independent of the defences under the underlying contract; the issuing bank only needs to handle the documents stipulated under the guarantee, and as long as the documents conform, the issuing bank is obliged to pay the amount of the guarantee. Because under the guarantee in that case the Hong Kong ICC had already made Award No. 28089/XZG, confirming Bank of China Guandong Branch's payment obligation, the court dismissed Huodian Company's claim to terminate payment of the funds under the guarantee at issue. The quotation is as follows:
"In Case No. 28089/XZG in which Attarat Company applied for arbitration, the Hong Kong ICC has made an arbitral award, declaring that Bank of China Guangdong Branch breached the independent guarantee and that Bank of China Guangdong Branch should pay Attarat Company the funds under the independent guarantee and pay interest. Accordingly, Attarat Company's request that Bank of China Guangdong Branch pay has a sufficient basis. A guarantee is independent of the underlying transaction; Bank of China Guangdong Branch, as the issuer of the guarantee, is only responsible for examining whether the documents submitted by Attarat Company conform to the provisions of the guarantee and has the right to decide on its own whether to pay; Bank of China Guangdong Branch's payment obligation is not affected by the defences under the underlying transaction between Huodian Company and Attarat Company. Furthermore, even if the arbitral award between Huodian Company and Attarat Company on the underlying transaction finds that Attarat Company committed a breach under the EPC Contract, that fact of breach does not necessarily constitute a sufficient and necessary condition for guarantee fraud."
9. Conclusions and Recommendations of This Article
9.1 Conclusions
From the Chinese law set out in this article, in particular the Supreme People's Court's Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees and the Supreme People's Court's past cases, it can be concluded that although obtaining a temporary stop-payment order in China is relatively easy [13], Chinese law is extremely strict regarding the conditions for obtaining a permanent stop-payment order. Judging from the Supreme People's Court's cases to date, apart from a very few cases that successfully obtained permanent termination of payment, almost all other cases were ultimately rejected by the Supreme People's Court.
The Supreme People's Court's problem with permanent stop-payment orders appears to be that, when hearing some independent guarantee dispute cases, the judges or collegial panels show a lack of expertise and are somewhat "lay" in their understanding of the unique legal and banking practice rules of independent guarantees. This mainly stems from the Supreme People's Court's insufficient experience in hearing dispute cases in this field and its limited understanding of the unique legal regime of independent guarantees, an international rule and a legal regime in judicial practice of various countries that is still developing.
9.2 Recommendations
The analysis in this article of Chinese law and the Supreme People's Court shows that the litigation procedure for initiating a permanent stop-payment order in Chinese courts must be undertaken prudently, and at the same time particularly solid preparation must be made in sorting out the facts of the case and preparing evidence. Otherwise, it is better to settle than to lightly commence litigation proceedings.
Another important lesson and recommendation is that the outcome of judgments in litigation cases concerning permanent termination of payment under independent guarantees is somewhat like "opening a blind box": the outcome of handling a case depends on whether the judge or collegial panel hearing the case is professional and reliable; even in the Supreme People's Court, which represents the highest level of China's international commercial adjudication, there are not a few cases of unreliable or plainly erroneous judgments. This shows that there is an inherent risk of enormous uncertainty in litigation outcomes when litigating in courts at all levels and in all places in China. This is a very noteworthy enormous litigation risk.
Click to download the complete version of Cross-Border Dispute Resolution Publication, Issue 48
* Jin Saibo graduated from the School of Law of the University of International Business and Economics, successively obtaining a Master of Laws degree and a Doctor of Laws degree in international law from that school. He is an expert in handling letter of credit dispute cases and has been invited to participate in the drafting and revision of the Supreme People's Court judicial interpretation "Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Letter of Credit Dispute Cases." Lawyer Jin Saibo is also an expert in the handling of bank guarantee disputes and has been invited to participate in the drafting and revision of the judicial interpretation "Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Disputes over Independent Guarantees Payable on Demand." Since August 2023, he has been designated as a member of the Technical Adviser (TA) group of the Banking Commission (BC) of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC); he was previously a member of the Task Force on Demand Guarantees and is also a DOCDEX expert of the ICC for adjudicating letter of credit and independent guarantee disputes. He is Deputy Director of the East Asia Committee of the Institute of International Banking Law & Practice (IIBLP), a member of the committee for the revision of the Institute's International Standby Practices (ISP98), and a member of the editorial board of the Institute's electronic publication Documentary Credit World (DCW). He is a member of both the letter of credit and independent guarantee expert groups of ICC China. Lawyer Jin Saibo has handled a large number of litigation and arbitration cases concerning letters of credit and independent guarantees, bulk commodity sales including steel, copper oxide, alumina, palm oil, and ship sales. He has been elected for two consecutive terms as Vice Chairman of the "Finance and Securities Specialized Committee" of the All China Lawyers Association, and is an arbitrator of the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission, an arbitrator of the Beijing International Arbitration Center, and an arbitrator of many other arbitration institutions. He has been engaged as an expert of the Expert Committee on Civil and Administrative Supervision Cases of the Supreme People's Procuratorate. He has been invited to put forward opinions and suggestions on the drafting and revision of the judicial interpretations on the guarantee law part of the Civil Code. He is a member of the Chinese delegation to Working Group VI and Working Group V of the two projects of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, the Model Law on Secured Transactions and the Model Law on Insolvency. He is an observer of the drafting working group of the Model Law on Factoring (MLF) of the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT). He is a member of the Legal Committee (LC) of Factors Chain International (FCI). He is a member of the Academic Committee of the Commercial Factoring Committee of the Chinese Academy of International Trade and Economic Cooperation of the Ministry of Commerce. The English translation of this article was reviewed and revised by Jin Dian and Lawyer Gu Haoran of Lawyer Jin Saibo's team.
Questions and answers
What proof standard must a plaintiff meet to permanently enjoin payment under an independent guarantee in China?
The plaintiff must prove beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted and that none of the circumstances in Article 14, paragraph 3 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees exists. This standard is set by Article 20 and has been strictly applied by the Supreme People's Court.
What is the scope of a Chinese court's review of the underlying transaction in independent guarantee fraud cases?
Under Article 18 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees, the court may review and determine relevant facts of the underlying transaction only with respect to the specific circumstances of Article 12 asserted by the parties. This is a limited review, as confirmed by the Supreme People's Court in the Russian Construction Bank case and the Yiwu ICBC retrial case.
Who is qualified to apply for a stop-payment order against an independent guarantee in China?
Article 13 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees allows the applicant, issuer, or instructing party of an independent guarantee to apply for suspension of payment. The Supreme People's Court has held that only the performing party bearing performance liability under the underlying contract is a qualified plaintiff; an issuer's guarantor or other interested party is not qualified.
Can a Chinese court's permanent stop-payment order prevent enforcement of the guarantee in a foreign court?
No. In the Rushan Shipyard case, even though a Chinese court had ordered permanent stop-payment, the English court did not recognize it and enforced Bank of China's assets in England. Since Australia is a Commonwealth country, English precedents apply, so an Australian court may still enforce assets in Australia.
What are the practical risks of litigating to permanently enjoin payment under an independent guarantee in China?
Obtaining a temporary stop-payment order is relatively easy, but permanent stop-payment orders are extremely difficult to obtain; almost all cases reviewed by the Supreme People's Court were rejected. The outcome is uncertain and depends on the professionalism of the judge or collegial panel, so parties should prepare solid evidence or consider settlement.
Laws and cases cited
Judicial interpretations
- Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
- Independent Guarantee Provisions
Cases
- Himalayan Bank case
- ANZ Bank case
- China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch, et al.
- Russian Construction Bank Case
- Yiwu ICBC Retrial Case
- China Railway 15th Bureau Independent Guarantee Case
- Rushan Shipyard Case
- Bank of China Guangzhou Intermediate Court Case
- Huodian Company v. Attarat Company Guarantee Fraud Case
References
- December 1, 2023, Supreme People's Court, case number: (2023) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 1393, China Railway 15th Bureau Group Co., Ltd. v. China Construction Bank Corporation Henan Provincial Branch, Himalayan Bank Ltd., Kathmandu Bank Ltd., and Melamchi Water Supply Development Board, civil ruling on retrial of the independent guarantee fraud dispute, collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Chen Hongyu, Shen Jia.
- December 1, 2023, Supreme People's Court, case number: (2023) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 1393, China Railway 15th Bureau Group Co., Ltd. v. China Construction Bank Corporation Henan Provincial Branch, Himalayan Bank Ltd., Kathmandu Bank Ltd., and Melamchi Water Supply Development Board, civil ruling on retrial of the independent guarantee fraud dispute, collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Chen Hongyu, Shen Jia.
- Supreme People's Court, "China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch and others letter of credit fraud dispute," civil first-instance civil judgment (August 24, 2023), (2020) Zui Gao Fa Shang Chu No. 2, presiding judge Shen Hongyu, judge Xi Xiangyang, judge Sun Xiangzhuang, judge Yu Xiaohan, judge Guo Zaiyu.
- Supreme People's Court, "China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch and others letter of credit fraud dispute," civil first-instance civil judgment (August 24, 2023), (2020) Zui Gao Fa Shang Chu No. 2, presiding judge Shen Hongyu, judge Xi Xiangyang, judge Sun Xiangzhuang, judge Yu Xiaohan, judge Guo Zaiyu.
- See Guiding Case No. 109 of the Supreme People's Court: Anhui Foreign Economic Construction (Group) Co., Ltd. v. Orient Zhihua Real Estate Co., Ltd., guarantee fraud dispute (discussed and adopted by the Judicial Committee of the Supreme People's Court, issued February 25, 2019). 1. When determining whether independent guarantee fraud is constituted and it is necessary to examine the underlying transaction, the principle of limited and necessary examination should be adhered to, and the scope of examination should be limited to whether the beneficiary knew that the counterparty to the underlying contract did not in fact breach the underlying contract, and whether there existed facts showing that the beneficiary knew it had no right to demand payment. 2. The beneficiary's breach under the underlying contract does not affect its right to submit documents and demand payment in accordance with the provisions of the independent guarantee. 3. When determining whether fraud exists under an independent counter-guarantee, even if fraud exists under the independent guarantee, where payment has already been made in good faith under the independent guarantee, the people's court may not rule to stop payment of the funds under the independent counter-guarantee. Source of this case: Supreme People's Court Gazette, 2018 No. 3 (Total No. 257). The members of the collegial panel at that time were: presiding judge Chen Jizhong, judge Yang Honglei, judge Yang Xingye. Clerk Xu Yinglin (acting).
- For example, the Supreme People's Court's civil ruling on retrial review and trial supervision in "Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited Yiwu Branch, China National Technical Import and Export Corporation letter of credit fraud dispute" [the function of the advance payment independent guarantee and the beneficiary's right to claim] (December 28, 2017). Only the Beijing First Intermediate People's Court followed this standard in three cases of the same batch. See the Beijing First Intermediate People's Court's civil judgment on appeal in "Beijing Kaisheng Building Materials Engineering Co., Ltd. v. China Metallurgical Group Corporation guarantee contract dispute" (December 15, 2021) (Judgment No. 2425). Beijing First Intermediate People's Court's civil judgment on appeal in "Beijing Kaisheng Building Materials Engineering Co., Ltd. v. China Metallurgical Group Corporation guarantee contract dispute" (December 15, 2021) (Case No. 2424), and Beijing First Intermediate People's Court's civil judgment on appeal in "Beijing Kaisheng Building Materials Engineering Co., Ltd. v. Bank of Ningbo Co., Ltd. Beijing Branch and others guarantee contract dispute" (December 15, 2021) (Case No. 2426).
- Supreme People's Court, "Retrial Applicant Gribwal Cement Co., Ltd. v. Respondent Sinoma Equipment Group Co., Ltd., Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited Tianjin Branch guarantee fraud dispute," civil ruling on retrial (July 21, 2014).
- (2020) Zui Gao Fa Min Zai No. 265 "Construction Credit Bank Joint Stock Company Esentepe Corporate Banking Center Branch, Shenyang Yuanda Aluminium Industry Engineering Co., Ltd. letter of credit fraud dispute civil judgment on retrial" made by the Supreme People's Court on August 26, 2020, collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Li Guishun, Guo Zaiyu.
- (2017) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 4754, made by the Supreme People's Court on December 2, 2017, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited Yiwu Branch, China National Technical Import and Export Corporation letter of credit fraud dispute civil ruling on retrial review and trial supervision, collegial panel: Yu Xiaohan, Ren Xuefeng, Huang Xiwu.
- December 12, 2022, Supreme People's Court, case number (2021) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 5896, China Construction Bank Corporation Shenzhen Branch, Sichuan Qianheng Construction Engineering Co., Ltd. v. China Railway 15th Bureau Group Co., Ltd., third party Chang'an Guarantee Co., Ltd. Shenzhen Branch contract dispute, members of the collegial panel: Ren Xuefeng, Ma Dongxu, Shen Jia.
- March 7, 2016, Shandong Provincial Higher People's Court, case number: (2015) Lu Shang Chu Zi No. 71, Bank of China Limited Shandong Provincial Branch v. China Electronics Import and Export Shandong Company, Rongcheng Xixiakou Shipbuilding Co., Ltd., Xixiakou Group Co., Ltd. first-instance civil judgment on right of recourse dispute, collegial panel: Wang Qinglin, An Jingli, Zheng Yuanwen.
- July 30, 2025, first-instance judgment made by the Guangzhou Intermediate People's Court, (2023) Yue 01 Min Chu No. 760, plaintiff China Energy Engineering Group Guangdong Thermal Power Engineering Co., Ltd. v. defendant Attarat Power Company, third party Bank of China Limited Guangdong Provincial Branch, independent guarantee fraud dispute, collegial panel: Ning Jianwen, Sun Yuanfeng, Ouyang Fusheng.
- The author will write a separate article on the legal practice of relatively easily obtaining interim stop-payment orders in Chinese courts and a summary of Chinese court cases, and will not elaborate in detail here.
