01. ICC and Commercial Finance Rules
Today I will take a little time to report to you on the latest developments concerning the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) Global Banking Commission's rules on International Standard Banking Practice (ISBP) and related practice rules.
There is a saying now: "If you don't go to sea, you're out." There are two kinds of going to sea: one is enterprises and banks going global, and the other is law firms and lawyers going global. If you want to "go to sea," it's easy to talk about, but to actually go to sea, those who go must understand the "sea" and the "navigation rules" at sea, so that they can "swim" and withstand wind and waves, for example, being able to master the "rules of the game" in international commercial and financial transactions and law.
Currently, the ICC has more members than the United Nations. So from its establishment to now, the entire set of international commercial and financial rules formulated and promulgated by the ICC is basically the most widely accepted rules in the world. These rules are basically a "language" understood worldwide. So from Bangalore in India to Buenos Aires in South America, from the Netherlands in Europe to Rotterdam, to New York in the United States, to London in the United Kingdom, to Singapore and Hong Kong in East Asia, Indonesia and Malaysia, to the Middle East such as the UAE, to Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou in China, this set of language is a globally unified set of rules, a whole set of game rules for international commercial finance and even arbitration as a dispute resolution mechanism.
02. ICC Rules and Their Revisions
The most famous of these is, of course, the Incoterms. Every one of us who does foreign-related work, international trade, or has taken the judicial examination has studied this set of rules. Another most successful set of rules is the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits, i.e., UCP, a set of rules with a history of nearly one hundred years. It is now ICC Publication No. 600 (i.e., UCP600). Another set of rules with huge influence is on demand guarantees, i.e., URDG, currently ICC Publication No. 758 (i.e., URDG758).
These rules basically have a regular revision cycle, about once every 10 years. Because every 10 years, international banking practice, such as banking technology in message systems like SWIFT message technology and shipping technology, will change. For example, in the past, ships were not very fast, but now transport ships are very fast. Recently, the development of document electronization is also changing rapidly, and there is also the progress of AI technology, so trade and banking technology are developing very fast. The latest examples such as electronic bills of lading, electronic invoices, and various electronic documents and electronic signatures are forcing the industry to update these rules.
03. Revision Interpretation and Clarification of UCP600 and Official Opinions
So this time, when the ICC held its Banking Commission meeting in Paris in March 2026, there was a vote by national committees (NCs) worldwide on whether to revise UCP600. China voted in favor of revision. There were 8 countries in favor of revision, but the vast majority of countries, especially European countries, were unwilling to revise. Since it was decided not to revise UCP, the Banking Commission's Steering Committee proposed establishing 4 working groups. First, to further interpret and clarify the UCP and ISBP rules globally. In addition, I, together with American expert Mr. Glenn, co-lead the third working group concerning standby letter of credit rules and practice. Of course, as technical advisers, we will also participate in leading the work of the 4 working groups.
Countries like China, Indonesia, and Malaysia, where economic and trade development is relatively fast, use more letters of credit, so they advocate revision, but most national committees in the world do not advocate revision. So the ICC decided not to revise for now, but will issue some "patches" and strengthen training. So there will be a group responsible for global training to do this work in the near future. In addition, UCP already has a 2.0 version, eUCP, mainly to address electronic presentation and electronic examination of documents. Also, ISBP Publication No. 821 concerning document examination practice often has some "patches."
I am one of seven global experts in the Banking Commission's Technical Adviser (TA) team, and the only lawyer in the technical adviser team. Over the years, I have participated in the drafting, revision, and drafting of Opinions on these rules. So far, I have participated in the drafting and discussion of about 20 official Opinions. These Opinions are based on consultation questions raised by various national committees concerning the interpretation of the above ICC rules. Our technical adviser team will first draft a draft opinion, then seek comments from national committees. After global comments are consolidated, a final text is discussed and adopted at the formal meeting of the ICC Banking Commission as the official interpretation of the rules. So far, the opinion number has reached R956.
The technical adviser team has also published a series of "Briefings," which are concentrated explanations of banking practice issues deemed more important by the industry. This publication is not rules, but merely educational reference material. So far, more than 14 issues have been published. Chinese and English texts can be found on the ICC China website. The 15th and 16th issues are under discussion. There is a large Briefing drafting group worldwide, and representatives from many national committees provide comments.
04. Demand Guarantee Rules URDG758 and ISDGP and Official Opinions
The ICC also has a set of rules on demand guarantees. Because international trade, shipbuilding and financing, international engineering contracting, and many financial transactions worldwide inevitably require guarantees, especially demand guarantees. Therefore, the ICC has drafted a series of uniform rules on demand guarantees, abbreviated as URDG. The latest ICC publication number is 758. And the International Standard Demand Guarantee Practice, abbreviated as ISDGP, is also an ICC publication. The number of Opinions concerning URDG published by the Technical Committee is relatively small, but there are a few each year. The URDG rules appear not to be revised in the near future, but we may have new Opinions.
05. Revision of ISP98 and Chinese Edition of Official Commentary to be Published in China
Of course, demand guarantees and rules are more commonly used in commercial and financial transactions in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa, but in the United States, due to historical reasons such as restrictions under the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) regulations, banks cannot issue guarantees for others. So the United States developed a product and another set of rules for this business, namely the standby letter of credit and its rules. Standby letters of credit are generally recognized as governed by Article 5 (Letters of Credit) of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) as adopted by various states in the United States. In nature, it is still a letter of credit, so the U.S. banking practice community also developed a set of international standby letter of credit rules called ISP (International Standby Practices), published in 1998, hence ISP98. This is an international rule formulated and promulgated by the Institute of International Banking Law & Practice (IIBLP) in the United States. The ICC endorses this set of rules and recognizes it as ICC-recognized rules on standby letters of credit.
More than 30 years have passed since the rules were published, and the U.S. IIBLP still believes that no major revision is necessary. Moreover, even Professor James Byrne and lawyer James Barnes (both good friends of mine), who drafted the rules, have passed away, but the rules have not yet been changed. Because the Supreme People's Court of China drafted the judicial interpretation "Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases," the IIBLP immediately published two Official Interpretations after the judicial interpretation was announced, explaining that ISP98 is also a set of independent guarantee rules and therefore can directly connect with and apply to China's judicial interpretation on independent guarantees. At the same time, the IIBLP itself is also tirelessly publishing various standard forms of standby letters of credit recommended for global use, including various message formats.
Professor James Byrne and lawyer James Barnes also have an official commentary publication on ISP98. The team I organized is translating it into Chinese. It should be finished this year, and I hope the Chinese version can be published in China soon. The International Commercial Court of the Supreme People's Court in the recent authoritative case "Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch v. Bank of Jiangsu" has clarified that a standby letter of credit issued under ISP98 has a "guarantee function" in nature, and therefore the Supreme Court's judicial interpretation on independent guarantees will apply on issues of fraud and judicial remedies such as termination of payment (although I have a different opinion and I believe that is a judgment with an erroneous result). However, the future business development in China of international standby letters of credit issued under ISP98 and the application of this international practice will open a door for transactions. If you are interested, you can watch for the Chinese version of the official commentary on ISP98 that we will publish soon.
06. Other ICC Banking Rules: Uniform Rules for Collections and Forfaiting and Model Rules for Factoring
In addition, the ICC also has a set of Uniform Rules of Collection (URC) on international collections. The ICC has just recently published a new guideline, which is also a practical explanation of the rules on international collections. A collection is in practice a basic service product of banks; for example, where it is inconvenient to open a letter of credit, a collection is used for payment and receipt of money. Large disputes over international collections also frequently arise; for example, one bank has a major case involving a USD 160 million litigation dispute before a foreign court. So those engaged in banking business also need to understand this set of rules. There is no plan to revise these rules in the near future.
The ICC has also drafted a set of international uniform rules on forfeiting, called the Uniform Rules of Forfeiting (URF), but international acceptance seems not to be high. In addition, the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT), the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) and the International Factoring Association (IFC) have jointly drafted a Model Law on Factoring (MLF). As a member of the IFC Legal Committee and an observer on the drafting group, I participated in part of the drafting work. The IFC itself also has a set of factoring business rules (Grifs), which are also revised in a timely manner, with minor revisions and amendments occurring from time to time.
07. New rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL): the Convention on Negotiable Cargo Documents (NCD)
Recently there is also a relatively major international convention called the Negotiable Cargo Documents (NCD), namely the Convention on Negotiable Cargo Documents. This is a United Nations convention proposed under China's leadership; the convention has been adopted by the General Assembly but has not yet entered into force. The threshold for entry into force is signature by 10 countries, and I personally am not very optimistic about this. This is because the entire international maritime practice and legal community does not very much welcome this convention. But this is a convention led by China, which wants to promote this set of globally unified convention in "Belt and Road" countries. China is working hard to promote it and hopes there will be a good result.
The above is the content of my speech. Below is the disclaimer clause that must be stated. Thank you all.
Appendix to the article
* This article was compiled from the recording of Lawyer Jin Saibo's speech at the Qingdao business exchange meeting of the Financial Committee of the All China Lawyers Association on June 26, 2026. The author has revised several inaccurate expressions, and for ease of reading the author added subheadings afterwards. The information on rule updates mentioned in the article is information as of June 26, 2026.
Questions and answers
Will UCP600 be revised following the March 2026 ICC Banking Commission meeting?
No. At the March 2026 meeting, national committees voted on whether to revise UCP600. Eight countries, including China, voted in favor, but the vast majority, especially European countries, opposed revision. The ICC decided not to revise UCP600 for now, but will issue patches and strengthen training.
What are the four working groups established by the ICC Banking Commission?
The Steering Committee proposed four working groups. The first will further interpret and clarify UCP and ISBP rules globally. The third, co-led by a Chinese expert and American expert Mr. Glenn, concerns standby letter of credit rules and practice. Technical advisers will participate in leading all four groups.
How does China's judicial interpretation on independent guarantees apply to ISP98 standby letters of credit?
The Supreme People's Court's judicial interpretation "Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases" applies to ISP98 standby letters of credit. In Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch v. Bank of Jiangsu, the International Commercial Court clarified that an ISP98 standby letter of credit has a guarantee function, so the judicial interpretation applies on fraud and judicial remedies such as termination of payment.
What is the entry into force threshold for the Convention on Negotiable Cargo Documents (NCD)?
The Convention on Negotiable Cargo Documents, a United Nations convention proposed under China's leadership, has been adopted by the General Assembly but has not yet entered into force. The threshold for entry into force is signature by 10 countries. The speaker is not very optimistic about this because the international maritime practice and legal community does not very much welcome the convention.
What are the ICC Briefings and how many have been published?
The ICC Technical Adviser team publishes Briefings, which are concentrated explanations of banking practice issues deemed more important by the industry. They are not rules but educational reference material. So far, more than 14 issues have been published, with Chinese and English texts on the ICC China website. The 15th and 16th issues are under discussion.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
Judicial interpretations
- Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases
Treaties
- Convention on Negotiable Cargo Documents (NCD)
Standards
- Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP600)
- URDG758
- eUCP
- ISBP Publication No. 821
- International Standard Demand Guarantee Practice (ISDGP)
- Uniform Rules of Collection (URC)
- Uniform Rules of Forfeiting (URF)
- Model Law on Factoring (MLF)
- Grifs
Cases
- Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch v. Bank of Jiangsu
