[Abstract] Article 20 of the Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Cases of Disputes over Independent Guarantees (the "Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees"), formulated and promulgated by the Supreme People's Court of China in 2016, sets strict preconditions for permanently enjoining payment under demand independent guarantees. Examining these conditions, and in particular how they are actually applied in real litigation cases tried by the Supreme People's Court itself, and especially exploring the judges' reasoning and analytical approach in the judgments of real cases, and summarizing this in a timely manner, is truly necessary for guiding international and domestic commercial and banking practitioners, and also provides extremely useful guidance for Chinese courts at all levels in trying similar cases. This piece is Part I of the article.
0. General Principles: The Supreme People's Court's Clear Position: Chinese Courts May Not Arbitrarily and Excessively Issue Injunctions against Independent Guarantees
0.1 The Supreme People's Court Opposes the Excessive Issuance of Injunctions against Independent Guarantees (Temporary Orders Suspending Payment and Permanent Judgments Terminating Payment)
After the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees was adopted and came into effect, Chief Judge Zhang Yongjian and Judge Shen Hongyu (both in their positions at the time), who were responsible for drafting the Judicial Interpretation, explained in the article "Correctly Understanding and Applying the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees"[1] that Chinese courts, in addressing the problem of excessive issuance of temporary injunctions against independent guarantees, clearly emphasized:
"...In judicial practice, the situation of arbitrarily enjoining payment under independent guarantees is relatively serious, which has already affected the circulation of independent guarantees issued by our country's financial institutions among various countries. Therefore, strictly regulating the procedure for temporary injunctions against payment under independent guarantees is the top priority of the Provisions. First, Articles 13 and 16 of the Provisions clearly characterize the injunction ruling as conduct preservation, but compared with the general conduct preservation provided in our country's Civil Procedure Law, it also has its own particularities, combining the characteristics of both procedural review and substantive review. In addition to complying with the conditions for taking preservation measures under the Civil Procedure Law, the people's court must conduct a preliminary substantive review of whether there are grounds for enjoining payment. Therefore, Article 16 provides that a people's court's ruling enjoining payment must include the facts preliminarily ascertained and the reasons for whether to permit the application to enjoin payment."
"...Second, Article 14 of the Provisions sets extremely strict procedural conditions for injunction rulings.... The strict regulation of the injunction procedure and conditions by the Judicial Interpretation both curbs the abuse of rights by beneficiaries and avoids abuse of the injunction procedure, powerfully safeguarding the transaction security of independent guarantees, protecting the parties' lawful rights and legitimate expectations, and maintaining the unity of procedural justice and substantive justice."
0.2 Chinese Courts Must Maintain a Precise Balance between the Independence of Independent Guarantees, the Fraud Exception, and the Exception to the Fraud Exception
The more difficult part in judicial practice is that when a court renders a judgment in a dispute over an independent guarantee, it must maintain a balance between the basic principles of the independent guarantee legal system—such as the principle of independence, the principle of documentary transactions, and the principle of strict compliance on their face—and the prevention of beneficiaries of independent guarantees from abusing their right to claim or even committing fraud; that is, while maintaining the vitality of independent guarantees as commercial and financial instruments, it must not allow those who use independent guarantees to commit fraud or abuse their right to claim to succeed, while at the same time encouraging more bona fide third parties participating in independent guarantee transactions to receive appropriate protection. Therefore, the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees maintains a delicate balance among Articles 3, 5, 6, 9, 12, 13, and 20. In my lectures on independent guarantee law, I often say that the institutional arrangements in Articles 1 to 10 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees are the rules of the game for "paper turning into gold," while the institutional arrangements in Articles 11 to 20 are the rules of the game for "gold turning into paper."[2]
0.3 The Analysis and Conclusions of This Article Also Apply to Standby Letters of Credit
After the Supreme People's Court Commercial Court rendered its first-instance final judgment and its ruling on the retrial review in "Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch v. Bank of Jiangsu," standby letters of credit issued under ISP98, because their "standby rather than used" guarantee function is similar in nature to independent guarantees, were ultimately held to be governed by the Supreme People's Court's Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Cases of Disputes over Independent Guarantees[3] with respect to the issues of fraud and enjoining payment under the standby letter of credit in that case. Therefore, the analysis and conclusions of this article also apply to standby letters of credit.
1. Legal Principle One: The Defendant in a Lawsuit to Enjoin Payment under a Standby Letter of Credit (Independent Guarantee) (Temporary and Permanent Injunctions against Payment), i.e., the Beneficiary under the Standby Letter of Credit (Independent Guarantee), Engaged in Malicious Fraud in Its Claim under the Standby Letter of Credit (Independent Guarantee)
1.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
Article 20 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees provides: "Where a people's court, after trying a case of dispute over independent guarantee fraud, can determine beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted and there are no circumstances specified in Paragraph 3 of Article 14 of these Provisions, it shall render a judgment that the issuer terminate payment of the amount requested under the independent guarantee."
Article 12 of the Judicial Interpretation provides: "Where any of the following circumstances exists, a people's court shall determine that independent guarantee fraud is constituted: (1) the beneficiary colludes with the guarantee applicant or others to fabricate the underlying transaction; (2) the third-party documents submitted by the beneficiary are forged or their contents are false; (3) a court judgment or arbitral award determines that the debtor under the underlying transaction bears no liability for payment or compensation; (4) the beneficiary confirms that the debt under the underlying transaction has been fully performed or confirms that the payment maturity event stated in the independent guarantee has not occurred; (5) other circumstances in which the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to claim payment, still abuses that right."
Article 14 provides: "A people's court's ruling to suspend payment of amounts under an independent guarantee must simultaneously satisfy the following conditions: (1) the evidence materials submitted by the applicant for the injunction prove that the circumstances specified in Article 12 of these Provisions exist with a high probability; (2) the situation is urgent, and failure to immediately take injunction measures will cause irreparable harm to the lawful rights and interests of the applicant for the injunction; (3) the applicant for the injunction has provided a guarantee sufficient to compensate the respondent for losses it may suffer as a result of the injunction. Where the applicant for the injunction requests an injunction on the ground that the beneficiary has breached the underlying transaction, the people's court shall not support it. Where the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued upon instruction, the people's court shall not rule to enjoin payment under an independent guarantee that safeguards the issuer's right of recourse."
The prerequisite for enjoining payment is that the beneficiary's claim under the standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) is made with fraudulent or abusive intent and malice. Ordinary disputes and controversies under the underlying contract do not constitute fraud or abuse. Moreover, where bona fide third parties exist, ruling and judging to enjoin payment is absolutely prohibited.
1.2 Authoritative Precedents of the Supreme People's Court: Payment under an Independent Guarantee (Standby Letter of Credit) May Be Enjoined (Temporarily and Permanently) Only Where the Beneficiary's Claim Constitutes "Malicious Fraud," "Intent to Defraud," or Malicious Abuse of the Right to Claim under the Independent Guarantee
1.2.1 The Supreme People's Court's "ANZ Bank Case": Standby Letter of Credit Fraud Requires Proof of the Beneficiary's "Subjective Malice" or "Intent" at the Time of Claim
In the Supreme People's Court Commercial Court's latest and most authoritative standby letter of credit case, "Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited v. Bank of Jiangsu (Standby Letter of Credit Case)"[4], the Supreme People's Court gave the following detailed explanation of the intent to defraud provided in the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees:
"(2) Whether Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch Engaged in the Fraud Circumstances Specified in Item 5 of Article 12 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions
Item 5 of Article 12 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions provides: "Where the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to claim payment, still abuses that right, the people's court shall determine that independent guarantee fraud is constituted." Under this provision, if the beneficiary's claim for payment is made knowing that it has no right to claim payment, it constitutes abuse of the right to claim payment and constitutes fraud. This Court holds that, although strictly speaking, in the fraud circumstance of abuse of the right to claim payment, the point in time for assessing the beneficiary's subjective malice should also be limited to the time of making the claim, in practice there indeed exist situations where the beneficiary's subjective state of knowledge changes. If, at the time of its claim, it in good faith believed that it had a right to claim payment, but thereafter, upon learning of the fact that the right to claim payment had been lost, it insists on not withdrawing its claim, this may be determined to constitute fraud, because at that point it no longer has a legal interest deserving protection. However, the situation in this case is that Bank of Jiangsu should have paid USD 22,979,687.50 under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit based on the claim of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch, but it paid only USD 7,313,543.30. After the court's injunction was lifted at the end of May 2019, Bank of Jiangsu was then obligated to continue payment, and the right to claim payment of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch against Bank of Jiangsu had not been extinguished. The Settlement Agreement signed between Kangsongji Company and Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch on May 11, 2017, and the Waiver Letter/Certificate issued on September 13, 2017, promising to withdraw the claim under the Standby Letter of Credit and acknowledging that the Standby Letter of Credit had expired and was no longer valid, also did not affect the right to claim payment of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit. This is because the Settlement Agreement resolved the claim issue under the Standby Letter of Credit, not the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit, and the Settlement Agreement provided that Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch should pay USD 6 million to Kangsongji Company, and then return the claim letters under the two standby letters of credit, namely the Standby Letter of Credit involved in the case and the Standby Letter of Credit of Zhongji Company, to Kangsongji Company stamped with "cancelled"; only after Kangsongji Company received the USD 6 million did it unconditionally and irrevocably release the claims, assertions, liabilities, and litigation against Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch under the two standby letters of credit. That is, Kangsongji Company's promise to waive its claim against Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch was premised on the consideration of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch paying USD 6 million; in substance, the claim amount was reduced to USD 6 million and the claim for the remaining unpaid portion was withdrawn, and the USD 6 million actually paid by Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch was in substance not within the scope of the withdrawn claim. Because the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit is independent of the Standby Letter of Credit, Bank of Jiangsu's payment obligation under the Counter-Guarantee Standby Letter of Credit was not extinguished by the repayment arrangement under the Standby Letter of Credit."
In this case, the Supreme People's Court required the plaintiff to prove the beneficiary's "subjective malice" or intent to defraud at the time of its claim under the standby letter of credit.
1.2.2 The Supreme People's Court, in Its Second-Instance Judgment and Retrial Ruling in the "Luoyang Hangjian Case," Clarified the Fact-Finding Standard for the "Fraud Exception"
In this case, the Supreme People's Court emphasized[5]:
“Among them, Article 12, Item 5, which is relevant to this case, is a general catch-all clause for obvious abuse of the right to demand payment, that is, where the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to demand payment, deliberately conceals the facts and still issues and submits documents that on their face conform to the terms of the guarantee, such as a demand for payment and a statement of default, inducing the issuer to pay erroneously; therefore, this kind of abuse of the right to demand payment constitutes guarantee fraud.......In this case, where UBAF had not received a conforming demand from Hyundai Korea, on the one hand it refused payment under the Advance Payment Guarantee to Hyundai Korea on the ground of discrepancies, and on the other hand it simultaneously concealed the facts, violated the good faith required of commercial banks, and falsely submitted a demand that on its face conformed to the provisions of the Counter-Guarantee for Advance Payment, which conduct falls within the situation provided in Article 12, Item 5 of the Provisions on Several Issues Concerning Independent Guarantees, namely 'the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to demand payment, still abuses that right', and constitutes independent guarantee fraud; the original instance's finding in this regard has factual and legal basis.......In this case, however, UBAF itself committed fraud and does not constitute 'payment in good faith'. This Court holds that, since the issuer under a counter-guarantee also has the rights of a 'beneficiary', it is entitled to demand payment from the counter-guarantor. That right is a right of recourse, which requires two elements: namely, that the beneficiary is entitled to claim against the issuer under the independent guarantee, and that the issuer is entitled to claim recourse against the counter-guarantor. Correspondingly, counter-guarantee fraud should also exist in two situations: first, where the issuer, knowing of the beneficiary's fraud, still pays the beneficiary and then turns to demand payment from the counter-guarantor under the counter-guarantee, which situation is 'double fraud'; second, where the issuer does not premise its claim on the beneficiary's fraud, but independently makes a fraudulent claim against the counter-guarantor based on its own status as 'beneficiary' of the counter-guarantee, to which situation the general provisions on independent guarantee fraud apply and which does not require 'double fraud' as an element. In practice, counter-guarantee fraud is mostly seen in the first situation, but UBAF's claim in this case falls within the second situation.”
1.2.3 The Supreme People's Court, in its second-instance judgment in 'Yangtze River Geotechnical Company v. CCB', clarified the factual criteria for finding 'abuse of the right to claim under an independent guarantee'
In that judgment the Supreme People's Court clarified[6]:
“In the case of Yangtze River Geotechnical Company v. Zhongbo Company and CCB Wenling Sub-branch concerning confirmation of ordinary bankruptcy claims, the Taizhou Intermediate People's Court of Zhejiang Province issued Judgment No. 1355, finding that the project at issue could not continue to be performed because of the civil war in Libya, which constituted impossibility of performance due to force majeure, and that Zhongbo Company had not committed any breach; that Zhongbo Company had completed works valued at no less than RMB 2.6695 billion and had no obligation to refund the advance payment to Yangtze River Geotechnical Company. Since Judgment No. 1355 had already determined the value of the works at issue, it was not improper for the original judgment not to determine the value of the works at issue on the basis of the construction contract and the contracting contract. Yangtze River Geotechnical Company's application for retrial, alleging that the determination of the value of the works was erroneous and that Zhongbo Company had committed breach, runs counter to the facts found in Judgment No. 1355. The original judgment, based on the facts found in the effective judgment, did not support Yangtze River Geotechnical Company's right to demand payment, which conforms to Article 12, Item 3 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees concerning 'a court judgment or arbitral award finding that the debtor of the underlying transaction has no liability to pay or compensate' and Item 5 concerning 'other situations where the beneficiary, knowing that it has no right to demand payment, still abuses that right'.”
2. The second legal principle: there is no good-faith third party in a standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) transaction
2.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees emphasizes that where a good-faith third party exists, a Chinese court may not even issue a ruling for a temporary payment injunction; that paragraph provides: 'Where the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued on instructions, the people's court may not rule to stop payment under an independent guarantee securing the issuer's right of recourse.' That article makes clear that if the 'issuer of the independent guarantee has already paid in good faith', no ruling to stop payment may be made. At the same time, Article 20[7] of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees again emphasizes that when a court judgment terminates payment under an independent guarantee, it must ensure that no good-faith third party exists before it may order termination of payment. That article provides: 'Where the people's court, in hearing a case of independent guarantee fraud, can find beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted and the situation in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of these Provisions does not exist, it shall order the issuer to terminate payment of the sums requested under the independent guarantee.' Once a good-faith third party exists in a standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) transaction, payment under the standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) may not be suspended or terminated even if fraud is found after a limited review of the underlying contract.
2.2 Authoritative precedents of the Supreme People's Court
2.2.1 The Supreme People's Court's second-instance judgment and retrial ruling in the 'Kamalanga case'
In a series of authoritative cases after the promulgation of the judicial interpretation, the Supreme People's Court further clarified this important principle, for example in its second-instance judgment and retrial ruling in the 'Kamalanga case'[8]:
“During the retrial application, Shandong Electric Power Construction submitted copies of the arbitral tribunal's Award on the underlying contract at issue and a Statement by the energy company's parent company, intending to prove that the energy company, knowing that it had no right to demand payment, still abused that right. Under the situations provided in Article 12 of the Provisions on Several Issues Concerning Independent Guarantees, a breach of the underlying contract does not necessarily constitute a fraudulent claim under an independent guarantee. Therefore, the above evidence is insufficient to find that the energy company's demand for payment under the guarantee was a malicious claim abusing that right, and is also insufficient to overturn the original judgment.
2.2.2 The Supreme People's Court's judgment in the 'Russian CCB retrial case'
The Supreme People's Court again clarified in the 'Russian CCB retrial case'[9]:
“1. Understanding of 'payment in good faith' provided in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions.
Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions provides: 'Where the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued on instructions, the people's court may not rule to stop payment under an independent guarantee securing the issuer's right of recourse.' Article 20 provides: 'Where the people's court, in hearing a case of independent guarantee fraud, can find beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted and the situation in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of these Provisions does not exist, it shall order the issuer to terminate payment of the sums requested under the independent guarantee.' This Court holds that in the case of a counter-guarantee, both a guarantee and a counter-guarantee exist; the 'payment in good faith' provided in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions is a provision made to protect the lawful rights and interests of an issuer that pays in good faith where the beneficiary's claim under the guarantee is fraudulent or highly likely to be fraudulent, and to balance the interests among the guarantee applicant, the guarantee beneficiary, the guarantee issuer and the counter-guarantee issuer. On the one hand, at the stage of deciding whether to issue a temporary payment injunction, upon the party's application, where there is a high probability that the beneficiary's claim under the guarantee is fraudulent, as long as there is no evidence showing that the guarantee issuer is highly likely to have participated in the guarantee beneficiary's fraudulent conduct, and no evidence showing that the guarantee issuer was highly likely to have known of the facts of the guarantee beneficiary's fraud and still paid the guarantee beneficiary, the guarantee issuer's payment in good faith shall be protected, and the counter-guarantee securing the guarantee issuer's right of recourse may not be stopped on the ground that the guarantee beneficiary committed fraud. On the other hand, where reasonable doubt has been excluded and the beneficiary under the guarantee is found to have committed fraud, when deciding whether to terminate payment of the sums under the counter-guarantee, as long as there is no evidence showing that the guarantee issuer itself committed fraud in its claim under the counter-guarantee, no evidence showing that the guarantee issuer participated in the guarantee beneficiary's fraudulent conduct, and no evidence showing that the guarantee issuer knew of the facts of the guarantee beneficiary's fraud and still paid the guarantee beneficiary, the guarantee issuer's payment in good faith shall be protected, and the sums under the counter-guarantee shall not be stopped.
2. The payment by CCB Essentaipe Branch to Larsen Company is different from the situation provided in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions
In this case, when the first-instance court decided to issue the temporary payment injunction, CCB Essentaipe Branch had not yet paid the beneficiary Larsen Company, so there was no need to examine the question of payment in good faith provided in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions. When considering whether ultimately to terminate payment under the two counter-guarantees, since Larsen Company's claim against CCB Essentaipe Branch on 15 April 2016 did not constitute fraud, and CCB Essentaipe Branch's claim against CCB Liaoning Provincial Branch on 19 April 2016 also did not constitute fraud, the condition provided in Article 20 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions, namely 'can find beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted', was not satisfied, and there was no need to consider the other element of that article, namely 'and the situation in Article 14, Paragraph 3 of these Provisions does not exist'. Therefore, Shenyang Yuanda's argument that CCB Essentaipe Branch's payment did not constitute 'payment in good faith' as found under Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions, and that CCB Essentaipe Branch's claim under the counter-guarantee should therefore be stopped, is untenable and is not supported by this Court.”
2.2.3 The Supreme People's Court's views in the retrial ruling in the 'Himalaya case'
In the 'Himalaya case' retried by the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Court clarified[10]:
“In this case, China Railway 15th Bureau claims that Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank committed guarantee fraud, and should adduce evidence to prove that Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank, knowing that the Malangi Committee had committed independent guarantee fraud, still paid in violation of the principle of good faith and further made a claim as beneficiary under the demand independent counter-guarantee. According to the facts found in the original review, on the one hand there is no evidence proving that Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank, when making a claim under the counter-guarantee to CCB Henan Branch in 2012, knew that the Malangi Committee's claim was a fraudulent claim; on the other hand, the Central Bank of Nepal had already deducted the corresponding sums under the independent guarantee from the accounts of Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank in 2015, and the passive payment by Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank constituted payment in good faith. Under Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Provisions: 'Where the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued on instructions, the people's court may not rule to stop payment under an independent guarantee securing the issuer's right of recourse.' On this basis the original judgment found that China Railway 15th Bureau's evidence that Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank's claim under the counter-guarantee issued to CCB Henan Branch constituted fraud was insufficient, and its findings of fact and application of law were not improper. China Railway 15th Bureau's grounds for retrial alleging that Himalaya Bank and Kathmandu Bank committed guarantee fraud cannot be established.”
3. The third legal principle: the first-instance plaintiff has no other possible judicial remedy, and if payment under the standby letter of credit (independent guarantee) is not terminated, the plaintiff will face 'irreparable loss'
3.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
Article 14 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees provides that "where a people's court rules to suspend payment of funds under an independent guarantee, the following conditions must be met simultaneously: (1) the evidence submitted by the applicant for suspension proves that there is a high probability of the existence of the circumstances in Article 12 of these Provisions; (2) the situation is urgent, and failure to immediately take suspension measures will cause irreparable harm to the lawful rights and interests of the applicant for suspension; (3) the applicant for suspension has provided a guarantee sufficient to compensate the respondent for losses it may suffer as a result of the suspension.
Where the applicant for suspension requests suspension on the ground that the beneficiary has breached the underlying transaction, the people's court shall not support it."
Although this article of the judicial interpretation addresses the preconditions for suspending payment under an independent guarantee where a court issues a temporary suspension ruling, in both procedural and substantive terms, if a people's court is requested to rule on permanently terminating payment under an independent guarantee, then in addition to satisfying the three conditions set out in Article 20 (first, that independent guarantee fraud is constituted; second, that no bona fide third party exists; third, that the burden and standard of proof of "excluding reasonable doubt" are satisfied) [11], another key condition set out in Article 14 must also be satisfied, namely "(2) the situation is urgent, and failure to immediately take suspension measures will cause irreparable harm to the lawful rights and interests of the applicant for suspension". If the plaintiff has already obtained sufficiently effective judicial relief under the underlying contract or the independent guarantee, such as a damages remedy, then in such circumstances it will not be regarded as a situation of "urgency", nor as one in which the failure to provide injunctive relief would cause the plaintiff at first instance's "lawful rights and interests" to face "irreparable harm".
Although Article 20 of the judicial interpretation does not list this condition, because the traditional "injunction" remedy derived from the Anglo-American common law system is an equitable remedy, generally a remedy in personam provided only where monetary compensation cannot make the claimant whole, the preconditions for a court to grant injunctive relief are therefore much stricter than the legal and evidentiary requirements for ordinary monetary relief. Usually, one of the four test conditions for granting injunctive relief under Anglo-American common law is the so-called "balance of interests". Moreover, in the field of letters of credit and independent guarantees, the purpose of injunctive relief provided by courts is mainly to prevent money under the letter of credit or independent guarantee from being transferred out of the court's jurisdiction, which would result in a future judgment of the court terminating payment ultimately being unenforceable and thus ultimately damaging the authority of the court. Therefore, although Article 20 of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees does not list it again, it is already included in Article 13 of the institutional design of the judicial interpretation. [12]
4. The fourth legal principle: standby letters of credit (independent guarantees) must follow the principle of "pay first, argue later"
4.1 Provisions of the Judicial Interpretation on Independent Guarantees
In the article "Understanding and Application of the <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases>" by Zhang Yongjian and Shen Hongyu of the Supreme People's Court, the intended purpose of this judicial interpretation is stated as follows:
"The third category consists of disputes in which the guarantee applicant and others bring suit requesting the court to suspend or terminate the issuer's payment of funds under an independent guarantee, mainly involving issues such as the nature of the suspension order, the determination of the principle of independence of independent guarantees and its exceptions, and the standard for determining fraud. ...
How to determine the exceptions to the principle of independence and balance the interests of the parties to an independent guarantee transaction was a difficult point in drafting the Provisions. On the one hand, it is necessary to genuinely respect the credit circulation function of independent guarantees as a substitute for cash security and to maintain the parties' contractual arrangement of 'pay first, argue later'; on the other hand, it is necessary to prevent and curb beneficiary fraud and abuse of rights. ..." [13]
4.2 Authoritative precedents of the Supreme People's Court
According to Guiding Case No. 109, the "Anhui Foreign Economic Construction Case" [14], and the "Camargo Case" [15] published by the Supreme People's Court, a beneficiary's breach of the underlying contract cannot automatically constitute fraud by the beneficiary under an independent guarantee.
4.2.1 The position of the Supreme People's Court in the retrial judgment of the "Anhui Foreign Economic Construction Case"
The Supreme People's Court held that even if an arbitration award under the underlying contract found that the beneficiary had breached the contract first, the beneficiary still has the right to make a claim under the independent guarantee. The quotation from the judgment is as follows [16]:
An independent guarantee is independent of the underlying transaction between the principal and the beneficiary. The bank issuing the independent guarantee is only responsible for examining whether the documents submitted by the beneficiary comply with the provisions of the guarantee and has the right to decide on its own whether to pay; the guarantor bank's payment obligation is not affected by any defence under the underlying transaction between the principal and the beneficiary. As the beneficiary, when Dongfang Zhiye Company submitted preliminary evidence proving the existence of engineering quality problems, even if it had not initiated any dispute resolution proceedings such as litigation or arbitration, and even if the other party's breach had not been confirmed through such proceedings, this would not affect the realization of its rights under the guarantee. Even if litigation or arbitration proceedings concerning the underlying contract are ongoing, so long as the relevant dispute resolution proceedings have not made a final determination that the debtor under the underlying transaction bears no liability for payment or compensation, this will likewise not affect the realization of the beneficiary's rights under the guarantee. Furthermore, even if an effective judgment or arbitration award finds that the beneficiary has breached the underlying contract, the existence of such breach does not necessarily constitute a sufficient and necessary condition for constituting "fraud" under the guarantee. (Emphasis added by the appellant.)
4.2.2 The position of the Supreme People's Court in the judgment in the "Camargo Case"
The judgment in that case is quoted as follows [17]:
During the retrial application period, Shandong Electric Power Construction submitted copies of the arbitral tribunal's "Award" on the underlying contract at issue and the "Statement" of the energy company's parent company, intending to prove that the energy company knew it had no right to claim payment but still abused that right. Under the circumstances provided in Article 12 of the <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning Independent Guarantees>, a breach of the underlying contract does not necessarily constitute fraudulent calling under an independent guarantee. Therefore, the above evidence is insufficient to find that the energy company's request for payment under the guarantee was an abuse of that right through malicious calling, and is also insufficient to overturn the original judgment. (Emphasis added by the author.)
4.2.3 The retrial case "Sinohydro Engineering Bureau 4 Co., Ltd. v. China National Machinery Import and Export Corporation, letter of credit fraud dispute" decided by the Supreme People's Court
In this case retried by the Supreme People's Court [18], the Supreme People's Court once again clarified the clear position of the previously cited "Anhui Foreign Economic Construction Case":
"... IV. Whether the beneficiary has committed a breach of the underlying contract does not necessarily affect its exercise of the right to claim under the guarantee. The principle established by this Court in the civil judgment (2017) Zui Gao Fa Min Zai No. 134 issued on December 14, 2017, in the case of the guarantee fraud dispute between the retrial applicant Dongfang Zhiye Real Estate Co., Ltd. and the respondent Anhui Foreign Economic Construction (Group) Co., Ltd., with the original third party Banco de Costa Rica and China Construction Bank Corporation Anhui Provincial Branch, is that the beneficiary's breach under the underlying contract does not necessarily affect its right to submit documents and claim payment in accordance with the provisions of the independent guarantee. After an independent guarantee is issued, it shall be deemed that the guarantee applicant has waived its defence under the underlying relationship against the guarantee beneficiary's breach. Therefore, whether there is a fact of breach under the underlying contract in this case and its causation do not affect China National Machinery's exercise of its rights under the guarantee. Sinohydro Bureau 4's claims that China National Machinery itself had breaches in performing the underlying contract, that there is a logical causal relationship between such breaches and the facts on which its calling of the guarantee at issue is based, and that China National Machinery's claim on that ground constitutes fraudulent calling under an independent guarantee, cannot be established and are not supported by this Court." (Emphasis added by the author.)
Click to download the full version of Cross-border Dispute Resolution Publication Issue 47
* Jin Saibo graduated from the School of Law of the University of International Business and Economics, successively obtaining a Master of Laws degree and a Doctor of Laws degree in international law from that school. An expert in handling letter of credit dispute cases, he has been invited to participate in the drafting and revision of the Supreme People's Court judicial interpretation <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Letter of Credit Dispute Cases>. Lawyer Jin Saibo is also an expert in handling bank guarantee disputes and has been invited to participate in the drafting and revision of the judicial interpretation <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Demand Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases>. Since August 2023, he has been designated as a member of the Technical Adviser (TA) group of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) Banking Commission (BC); previously he was a member of the Task Force of Demand Guarantee and is also an ICC DOCDEX expert for adjudicating letter of credit and independent guarantee disputes. He is Deputy Director of the East Asia Committee of the Institute of International Banking Law & Practice (IIBLP), a member of the committee for the revision of the Institute's <International Standby Practices (ISP98)>, and a member of the editorial board of the Institute's electronic publication <Documentary Credit World> (DCW). He is a member of both the ICC China letter of credit and independent guarantee expert groups. Lawyer Jin Saibo has handled a large number of litigation and arbitration cases relating to letters of credit and independent guarantees, and disputes relating to bulk commodity sales including steel, copper oxide, aluminium oxide, palm oil, and ship sales. He has been elected for two consecutive terms as Vice Chairman of the "Financial and Securities Specialized Committee" of the All China Lawyers Association, and is an arbitrator of the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission, an arbitrator of the Beijing International Arbitration Court, and an arbitrator of many other arbitration institutions. He has been engaged as an expert of the Expert Committee on Civil and Administrative Supervision Cases of the Supreme People's Procuratorate. He has been invited to provide opinions and suggestions on the drafting and revision of the judicial interpretation on the security law part of the <Civil Code>. He is a member of the Chinese delegation to Working Group VI and Working Group V of the two UNCITRAL projects, the <Model Law on Secured Transactions> and the <Model Law on Insolvency>. He is an observer of the drafting working group of the UNIDROIT <Model Law on Factoring> (MLF). He is a member of the Legal Committee (LC) of the International Factoring Association (FCI). He is a member of the Academic Committee of the Commercial Factoring Committee of the Service Trade Research Institute of the Ministry of Commerce. The English translation of this article was reviewed and revised by Lawyer Jin Dian and Lawyer Gu Haoran of Jin Saibo's team.
[1] <Understanding and Application of the <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases>>, Zhang Yongjian and Shen Hongyu of the Supreme People's Court. Source: <People's Judicature (Application)>, Issue 1, 2017. Link to the article: https://www.faxin.cn/lib/flwx/FlqkContent.aspx?gid=F497876 Zhang Yongjian's position at the Supreme People's Court at the time was Chief Judge of the Fourth Civil Division; he is currently a judge of the Singapore International Commercial Court. Shen Hongyu's position at the time; she is currently Chief Judge of the Fourth Civil Division of the Supreme People's Court.
[2] For the English common law formulation of an independent guarantee as being close to cash in hand, see Jin Saibo and Li Jian, <Letter of Credit Law>, p. 115. Law Press, first edition, March 2003. For a detailed discussion of the legal principle that "fraud unravels all", see p. 208 of the same book.
[3] The Supreme People's Court judicial interpretation "Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases" (Fa Shi [2016] No. 24) was adopted at the 1688th meeting of the Judicial Committee of the Supreme People's Court on 11 July 2016, is hereby promulgated, and came into force on 1 December 2016. It was published on the Supreme People's Court website on 18 November 2016. Link: http://gongbao.court.gov.cn/Details/c18a4f45c4e9721e6b9151495bb325.html. For a detailed commentary on this case, see my Chinese-English Newsletter Issue No. 26, e-book link: https://jinsaibo.yunzhan365.com/books/fgzw/mobile/index.html
[4] Civil judgment of first instance of the Supreme People's Court in "China Power Engineering Co., Ltd., Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch and others, letter of credit fraud dispute" (24 August 2023) [nature of the standby letter of credit and applicable law, and fraud and stop-payment]. Presiding Judge Shen Hongyu; Judges Xi Xiangyang, Sun Xiangzhuang, Yu Xiaohan and Guo Zaiyu.
[5] On 1 February 2021 the Supreme People's Court issued the Civil Ruling on Review and Trial Supervision of the Application for Retrial in the letter of credit fraud dispute between Union de Banques Arabes et Françaises (Hong Kong) Limited and Kaimai (Luoyang) Aviation Protective Equipment Co., Ltd., (2020) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 6923; collegial panel: Wang Zhaohui, Jia Jinsong and Zhang Daien. On 6 May 2020 the Supreme People's Court issued the Civil Judgment of second instance in the letter of credit fraud dispute between Union de Banques Arabes et Françaises (Hong Kong) Limited and Kaimai (Luoyang) Aviation Protective Equipment Co., Ltd., (2018) Zui Gao Fa Min Zhong No. 1216; collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Guo Zaiyu and Chen Hongyu.
[6] Civil Ruling on Review and Trial Supervision of the Application for Retrial issued by the Supreme People's Court on 7 August 2020 in the letter of credit dispute between Changjiang Geotechnical Engineering Corporation and China Construction Bank Corporation Wenling Sub-branch, (2020) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 2578. Collegial panel: Sun Xiangzhuang, Guo Zhonghong and Wang Zhaohui. Civil Ruling on Review and Trial Supervision of the Application for Retrial issued by the Supreme People's Court on 28 June 2019 in the letter of credit dispute between Changjiang Geotechnical Engineering Corporation and China Construction Bank Corporation Wenling Sub-branch, (2019) Zui Gao Fa Min Zhong No. 302. Collegial panel: Wang Shumei, Ma Dongxu and Guo Zaiyu.
[7] Article 14, paragraph 3 of the Independent Guarantee Judicial Interpretation: where the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued upon instructions, the people's court shall not order stop-payment under an independent guarantee that secures the issuer's right of recourse.
[8] On 7 April 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the Civil Judgment of second instance in the foreign-related guarantee fraud dispute "India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited, State Bank of India Bangalore Branch", (2019) Zui Gao Fa Min Zhong No. 513; presiding judge Ma Dongxu, judges Li Guishun and Guo Zaiyu. On 29 December 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the Civil Ruling on Review and Trial Supervision of the Application for Retrial in the letter of credit fraud dispute "PowerChina Shandong Electric Power Construction Co., Ltd., India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited", (2020) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 6776; presiding judge Guo Zhonghong, judges Sun Xiangzhuang and Wang Zhaohui.
[9] Civil Judgment on Retrial issued by the Supreme People's Court on 26 August 2020 in the letter of credit fraud dispute "Construction Credit Bank Joint Stock Company Esentepe Corporate Banking Center Branch, Shenyang Yuanda Aluminium Industry Engineering Co., Ltd.", (2020) Zui Gao Fa Min Zai No. 265; collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Li Guishun and Guo Zaiyu.
[10] 1 December 2023, Supreme People's Court, case number: (2023) Zui Gao Fa Min Shen No. 1393, Civil Ruling on Retrial in the independent guarantee fraud dispute between China Railway 15th Bureau Group Co., Ltd. and China Construction Bank Corporation Henan Provincial Branch, Himalayan Bank Limited, Kathmandu Bank Limited and Melamchi Water Supply Development Board; collegial panel: Ma Dongxu, Chen Hongyu and Shen Jia.
[11] Article 20 Where, in trying an independent guarantee fraud dispute case, the people's court is able to determine beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted and the circumstances in Article 14, paragraph 3 of these Provisions do not exist, it shall order the issuer to terminate payment of the amount requested under the independent guarantee.
[12] For a detailed discussion of the four tests for injunctive relief in Anglo-American law, see Jin Saibo and Li Jian, Letter of Credit Law, Law Press, first edition, March 2003. See Chapter 8 of that book, "Fraud and Injunction Issues in Letters of Credit", beginning at page 488. Section 7, "On the degree and determination of letter of credit fraud and the 'security test' in granting injunctive relief for fraud", see page 574. And Section 11, "Common law and equitable principles for granting injunctive relief for letter of credit fraud in Anglo-American law". See page 620. Section 12, "Conditions for applying to a court for injunctive relief on the ground of letter of credit fraud in Anglo-American law", see page 632. In particular Section 13, "Reasons why Anglo-American courts refuse to grant injunctions", see page 660. Among these, under subsection 13.1.3, "the applicant cannot prove that it will suffer irreparable loss if the injunction is not granted", or the so-called "irreparable harm" under subsection 13.1.7. For relevant cases under English law, see Mr Yang Liangyi's book Letters of Credit, China University of Political Science and Law Press, published 1998, see pages 175-181, and the letter of credit case precedents cited therein. For the provisions of American law, see Section 5-109(b) of the United States Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), quoted as follows: 5-109 (b) If an applicant claims that a required document is forged or materially fraudulent or that honor of the presentation would facilitate a material fraud by the beneficiary on the issuer or applicant, a court of competent jurisdiction may temporarily or permanently enjoin the issuer from honoring a presentation or grant similar relief against the issuer or other persons only if the court finds that:(1) the relief is not prohibited under the law applicable to an accepted draft or deferred obligation incurred by the issuer ;(2) a beneficiary , issuer , or nominated person who may be adversely affected is adequately protected against loss that it may suffer because the relief is granted;(3) all of the conditions to entitle a person to the relief under the law of this State have been met; and(4) on the basis of the information submitted to the court, the applicant is more likely than not to succeed under its claim of forgery or material fraud and the person demanding honor does not qualify for protection under subsection (a)(1). (Chinese reference translation: "Where the applicant claims that the documents are forged / materially fraudulent, or that payment would facilitate a material fraud by the beneficiary on the issuing bank / applicant, the court may issue a temporary / permanent stop-payment order only if all of the following 4 conditions are met: (1) the relief does not violate the law applicable to an accepted draft or the issuing bank's deferred obligation; (2) the beneficiary, issuing bank or nominated bank that may be harmed is adequately secured against loss; (3) the applicant has met all preconditions for an injunction under the law of this State (such as security, jurisdiction); (4) the court finds that the applicant's probability of success is greater than 50%, and the party demanding payment does not belong to the category of good-faith protected persons (§5-109(a)(1)).) The earliest letter of credit stop-payment case in New York State, for example, is the Sztejn precedent. Subsequent series of cases in various states have all emphasized these statutory provisions in UCC Article 5 and court precedents.
[13] "Understanding and Application of the <Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Independent Guarantee Dispute Cases>", Zhang Yongjian and Shen Hongyu of the Supreme People's Court. Source: People's Judicature (Application), 2017 Issue No. 1. Link to the article: https://www.faxin.cn/lib/flwx/FlqkContent.aspx?gid=F497876. Chief Judge Zhang Yongjian held his position at the Supreme People's Court at that time and is currently a judge at the Singapore International Commercial Court. Shen Hongyu's position at that time is currently Chief Judge of the Fourth Civil Division of the Supreme People's Court.
[14] On 14 December 2017, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2017) Zuigao Fa Min Zai No. 134 "Civil Judgment on Retrial of the Letter of Guarantee Fraud Dispute between Dongfang Zhiye Real Estate Co., Ltd. and Anhui Foreign Economic Construction (Group) Co., Ltd." Presiding Judge Chen Jizhong; Judges Yang Honglei and Yang Xingye.
[15] On 7 April 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2019) Zuigao Fa Min Zhong No. 513 "Civil Judgment of Second Instance on the Foreign-Related Letter of Guarantee Fraud Dispute between India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and State Bank of India, Bangalore Branch." Presiding Judge Ma Dongxu; Judges Li Guishun and Guo Zaiyu.
On 29 December 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2020) Zuigao Fa Min Shen No. 6776 "Civil Ruling on Review and Adjudication Supervision of the Letter of Credit Fraud Dispute between PowerChina Shandong Electric Power Construction Co., Ltd. and India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited." Presiding Judge Guo Zhonghong; Judges Sun Xiangzhuang and Wang Zhaohui.
Questions and answers
What are the conditions for a Chinese court to permanently enjoin payment under an independent guarantee?
A Chinese court may permanently enjoin payment only if it finds beyond reasonable doubt that independent guarantee fraud is constituted, no good-faith third party exists, and the situation is urgent such that failure to act would cause irreparable harm to the applicant. The applicant must also provide a guarantee sufficient to compensate the respondent.
What constitutes independent guarantee fraud under Chinese law?
Independent guarantee fraud is constituted where the beneficiary colludes to fabricate the underlying transaction, submits forged or false third-party documents, a court or arbitral award determines the debtor bears no payment liability, the beneficiary confirms the debt has been performed or the payment maturity event has not occurred, or the beneficiary, knowing it has no right to claim payment, still abuses that right.
Does a breach of the underlying contract automatically constitute fraud under an independent guarantee in China?
No. A breach of the underlying contract does not necessarily constitute fraud under an independent guarantee. The beneficiary's breach does not automatically affect its right to claim payment, and Chinese courts require proof of malicious fraud or abuse of right beyond a mere contractual breach.
How do Chinese courts treat good-faith third parties in independent guarantee transactions?
Chinese courts may not enjoin payment if a good-faith third party exists. Specifically, if the issuer has already paid in good faith under an independent guarantee issued upon instructions, the court may not rule to stop payment under a counter-guarantee securing the issuer's right of recourse.
What is the 'pay first, argue later' principle in the context of independent guarantees in China?
The 'pay first, argue later' principle means that independent guarantees are treated like cash, and payment must be made upon compliant demand before disputes are resolved. Chinese courts respect this principle by limiting injunctions to exceptional cases of fraud, thereby maintaining the credit circulation function of independent guarantees.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Civil Procedure Law
- United States Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
Judicial interpretations
- Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Cases of Disputes over Independent Guarantees
Standards
- ISP98
Cases
- Guiding Case No. 109
- Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Manila Branch v. Bank of Jiangsu
- Luoyang Hangjian Case
- Yangtze River Geotechnical Company v. CCB
- Kamalanga case
- Russian CCB retrial case
- Himalaya case
- Anhui Foreign Economic Construction Case
- Camargo Case
- Sinohydro Engineering Bureau 4 Co., Ltd. v. China National Machinery Import and Export Corporation
References
- On 14 December 2017, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2017) Zuigao Fa Min Zai No. 134 "Civil Judgment on Retrial of the Letter of Guarantee Fraud Dispute between Dongfang Zhiye Real Estate Co., Ltd. and Anhui Foreign Economic Construction (Group) Co., Ltd." Presiding Judge Chen Jizhong; Judges Yang Honglei and Yang Xingye.
- On 7 April 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2019) Zuigao Fa Min Zhong No. 513 "Civil Judgment of Second Instance on the Foreign-Related Letter of Guarantee Fraud Dispute between India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and State Bank of India, Bangalore Branch." Presiding Judge Ma Dongxu; Judges Li Guishun and Guo Zaiyu. On 29 December 2020, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2020) Zuigao Fa Min Shen No. 6776 "Civil Ruling on Review and Adjudication Supervision of the Letter of Credit Fraud Dispute between PowerChina Shandong Electric Power Construction Co., Ltd. and India GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited." Presiding Judge Guo Zhonghong; Judges Sun Xiangzhuang and Wang Zhaohui.
- On 28 August 2019, the Supreme People's Court issued the (2019) Zuigao Fa Min Zhong No. 349 "Civil Judgment of Second Instance on the Letter of Credit Fraud Dispute between Sinohydro Bureau 4 Co., Ltd. and China National Machinery Import and Export Corporation (CMC)." Collegiate panel: Yang Xingye, Li Guishun, Chen Hongyu.
