[Abstract] This article, combining the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China, the Exit and Entry Administration Law of the People's Republic of China, the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China and the Supreme People's Court's judicial interpretation on labor disputes, together with typical judicial precedents, systematically sorts out the conditions for lawful employment access for foreigners in China, the criteria for determining labor relations, the legal liability for illegal employment and the points of divergence in judicial adjudication, and clarifies the compliance boundaries of foreign-related employment and the differences in adjudicative standards.
I. Legal Application to Foreign-Related Employment Relations
According to Article 2 of the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China: "This Law applies to the establishment of labor relations between enterprises, individual economic organizations, private non-enterprise units and other organizations within the territory of the People's Republic of China (hereinafter referred to as employers) and workers, and to the conclusion, performance, modification, rescission or termination of labor contracts"; and Article 43 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations: "Labor contracts shall be governed by the law of the place where the worker works; where it is difficult to determine the place where the worker works, the law of the place of the employer's principal place of business shall apply. For labor dispatch, the law of the place of dispatch may apply."
It follows that China's labor laws apply to the employment conduct of domestic employers within the territory, including the employment of foreign workers by domestic employers, to which Chinese labor laws shall apply.
It should be noted that, although Article 43 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations exists, for situations where a domestic employer hires an employee to work abroad, most courts hold that, according to Article 8 of the Interpretation (I) of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations, the provisions concerning the protection of workers' rights and interests are mandatory provisions under the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations, and China's labor laws shall be directly applied.
II. Key Elements for Determining a Labor Relationship
According to China's current legal provisions, a foreign employee lawfully employed within the territory of China shall, in addition to meeting the conditions of (1) being at least 18 years old and in good health; (2) possessing the professional skills and corresponding work experience necessary for the job; (3) having no criminal record; (4) having a definite employing unit; and (5) holding a valid passport or other international travel document that can replace a passport (hereinafter referred to as a document replacing a passport), also obtain a work permit and lawfully stay and reside within the territory of China, or obtain permanent residence status.
According to the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China, the following documents shall specifically be processed:
Obligor
Document Name
Exemption Circumstances
Employer
Employment Permit
Foreigner Employment Permit Certificate of the People's Republic of China
(1) Foreign professional and technical personnel and management personnel directly funded and employed by the Chinese government, or foreign professional and technical personnel and management personnel funded and employed by state organs and public institutions who possess senior technical titles or special skill qualification certificates confirmed by domestic or international authoritative technical management departments or industry associations, and who hold a Foreign Expert Certificate issued by the State Administration of Foreign Experts Affairs;
(2) Foreign labor service personnel holding the Work Permit for Foreigners Engaged in Offshore Oil Operations in the People's Republic of China who engage in offshore oil operations, do not need to land, and possess special skills;
(3) Foreigners approved by the Ministry of Culture and holding a Temporary Business Performance License to conduct commercial artistic performances
or
(1) Foreigners who come to work in China under Chinese-foreign cooperative exchange projects and are employed in accordance with agreements or accords between the Chinese government and foreign governments or international organizations;
(2) Chief representatives and representatives in resident representative offices of foreign enterprises in China
Foreigner
Z Visa
Foreigner Employment Permit
(processed with the assistance of the employer)
(1) Foreign professional and technical personnel and management personnel directly funded and employed by the Chinese government, or foreign professional and technical personnel and management personnel funded and employed by state organs and public institutions who possess senior technical titles or special skill qualification certificates confirmed by domestic or international authoritative technical management departments or industry associations, and who hold a Foreign Expert Certificate issued by the State Administration of Foreign Experts Affairs;
(2) Foreign labor service personnel holding the Work Permit for Foreigners Engaged in Offshore Oil Operations in the People's Republic of China who engage in offshore oil operations, do not need to land, and possess special skills;
(3) Foreigners approved by the Ministry of Culture and holding a Temporary Business Performance License to conduct commercial artistic performances.
Foreigner Residence Certificate
Therefore, only on the premise that a foreigner has obtained permanent residence status in China or lawfully obtained employment documents can a labor relationship be established with a domestic employer; at the same time, the term of a labor contract shall not exceed five years, and a term exceeding five years may face the risk of the agreement being invalid.
III. Determination of the Relationship Where No Employment Permit or Employment Certificate Has Been Obtained
Although the law clearly provides that foreign personnel engaging in work in China shall process the above-mentioned required documents, in practice there still exists the phenomenon of failing to process the relevant documents as required. Some foreigners have not lawfully processed employment certificates and residence procedures; some foreigners have processed an employment certificate at one unit but work at another unit; and some persons holding tourist and student visas work within the territory. However, circumstances such as failing to obtain lawful employment qualifications, document information being inconsistent with the employing entity, and unlawful agreement on contract terms will all lead to serious consequences such as the non-establishment of a labor relationship, the invalidity of the contract, and even the possibility of administrative penalties.
In the case of (2024) Hu 0120 Min Chu No. 2245, the worker signed a labor contract with the employer without obtaining an employment certificate. Although the worker and the employer signed a Labor Contract, because the worker had not obtained a foreigner employment certificate, the labor relationship was not established, and the worker's claim for wages based on the labor relationship was not supported.
In the case of (2019) Chuan 0105 Min Chu No. 15226, the work unit stated in the Foreign Expert Work Permit for Coming to China held by the worker was the Education Center, which was inconsistent with his actual work unit, Dipont Company, violating the provision of Article 24 of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China that "the employing unit of a foreigner employed in China must be consistent with the unit specified in his or her employment certificate," thereby resulting in the invalidity of the labor contract.
It should be noted that, according to Article 80 of the Exit and Entry Administration Law of the People's Republic of China, where a foreigner is illegally employed or an employer illegally employs a foreigner, penalties such as fines and residence [restrictions] shall be imposed. Therefore, if a company fails to pay attention to the validity period of a foreign employee's employment permit or employment certificate, it may constitute illegal employment, illegal hiring and other unlawful circumstances.
IV. Impact of the Expiration of the Employment Permit on the Labor Contract
Articles 17 and 18 of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China provide that the term of a labor contract shall not exceed five years, and upon the expiration of the labor contract, the foreigner's employment certificate shall become invalid. If renewal is required, the employing unit shall, within 30 days before the expiration of the original contract, submit an application to the labor administrative department for extension of the employment period, and upon approval, process the extension formalities for the employment certificate.
Based on the above provisions, it can be seen that China adopts a permit system for the employment of foreigners; if a foreigner has not obtained employment documents, the legal relationship established between the foreigner and the company is not recognized as a labor relationship. However, in practice, for various reasons, there may be situations where the expiration date of a foreigner's employment certificate is inconsistent with the expiration date of the labor contract. At this time, whether the company may choose, when the labor contract has not expired but the employment certificate has expired, not to renew the employee's employment certificate but to terminate the labor relationship between the parties, requires further understanding of the judicial practice standards.
In the case of (2022) Hu 01 Min Zhong No. 1965, the court held that China's laws and regulations do not clearly provide that an employer has a mandatory obligation to renew a foreigner's employment certificate; therefore, the term of the labor relationship between the parties is limited by the term of the employment certificate. Since the employee's foreigner employment certificate expired on April 2, 2021, according to legal provisions, the valid term of the labor contract between the parties expired on April 2, 2021; therefore, the company's termination of the labor contract conformed to legal provisions.
However, in the case of (2018) Jing 02 Min Zhong No. 1661, the worker signed an open-ended labor contract with the employer, and thereafter the employer notified the worker of the termination of the labor relationship on the ground that the worker did not obtain approval for a foreigner employment certificate because he did not belong to the domestic urgently needed professional personnel. The court held that: although the agreement between the parties in the labor contract regarding the contract term violated the relevant provisions of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China, because the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China is a departmental rule of the State Council, the open-ended labor contract was not invalid for violating such provisions; in addition, the company should process the foreigner employment certificate and its extension for the employed foreigner, and the company failed to submit evidence proving the existence of the reason for terminating the labor relationship, namely that "the worker did not obtain approval for a foreigner employment certificate because he did not belong to the domestic urgently needed professional personnel." It was the company's own reason that caused the labor contract to be unable to continue to be performed; therefore, the company should pay compensation to the worker.
V. Whether Foreign Workers Can Claim Economic Compensation and Compensation Money
The Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China provide that the minimum wage standard, working hours, rest and vacation, occupational safety, and social insurance for foreign personnel employed in China shall apply the national statutory standards, but do not clarify whether economic compensation and compensation money are mandatorily applicable; adjudicative standards vary across localities:
In the case of (2023) Jing 02 Min Zhong No. 2931, the court held that the employer should pay economic compensation to the foreign worker.
In the case of (2022) Hu 0105 Min Chu No. 24122, the court held that "Articles 21 and 22 of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China provide that the wage of foreigners employed in China shall not be lower than the local minimum wage standard, and working hours, rest and vacation, occupational safety and health, and social insurance shall be implemented in accordance with relevant state provisions. Other labor rights and obligations agreed upon or performed by the parties beyond the above provisions may be determined according to the written labor contract, individual agreement or other agreements between the parties and the actual performance content. If, beyond the above policy provisions and the parties' written agreement and actual performance content, either party raises a claim to apply the relevant state labor standards and labor treatment requirements, such claim lacks basis." Because the parties did not agree on matters related to economic compensation in the labor contract, the employer did not need to pay economic compensation to the worker.
VI. Compliance Opinions
Regularly verify the validity periods of foreign employees' employment permits, employment certificates, residence certificates and other documents, so as to avoid the risk of being subject to administrative penalties due to non-compliant employment.
Refine the labor contract termination clauses. Foreign employees' employment within the territory is limited by their lawful residence status within the territory and the validity period of their employment certificates. Therefore, it is recommended to agree that when the documents related to the employment permit of the worker and the employer expire, the employer may proactively terminate the labor contract.
Click to download the complete version of Cross-Border Dispute Resolution Publication Issue 47
Questions and answers
What documents must a foreigner obtain to lawfully work in China and establish a labor relationship?
A foreigner must obtain a work permit and lawfully stay and reside in China, or hold permanent residence status. Specifically, the employer processes an Employment Permit and the foreigner obtains a Z visa and a Foreigner Residence Certificate, unless an exemption applies.
Does a labor relationship arise if a foreigner works without an employment certificate or if the certificate does not match the actual employer?
No. Courts have held that without a valid employment certificate, no labor relationship is established, and claims based on such a relationship are not supported. If the work unit on the certificate differs from the actual employer, the labor contract is invalid.
What are the consequences of illegal employment of foreigners in China?
Illegal employment or hiring can lead to administrative penalties, including fines and residence restrictions, under Article 80 of the Exit and Entry Administration Law. Employers may also face invalid contracts and non-establishment of labor relationships.
Can an employer terminate a labor contract when a foreign employee's work permit expires before the contract term ends?
Judicial practice is divided. Some courts hold that the labor relationship is limited by the permit's term, allowing termination upon expiration. Others hold that the employer has a duty to renew the permit and may be liable for compensation if it fails to do so without justified reason.
Are foreign workers in China entitled to economic compensation upon termination of employment?
Adjudicative standards vary. Some courts award economic compensation, while others hold that beyond minimum wage, working hours, rest and vacation, occupational safety, and social insurance, other labor rights depend on the parties' agreement, and compensation may not be mandatory if not agreed.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China
- Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations
- Exit and Entry Administration Law of the People's Republic of China
Regulations
- Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China
Judicial interpretations
- Interpretation (I) of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations
Cases
- (2024) Hu 0120 Min Chu No. 2245
- (2019) Chuan 0105 Min Chu No. 15226
- (2022) Hu 01 Min Zhong No. 1965
- (2018) Jing 02 Min Zhong No. 1661
- (2023) Jing 02 Min Zhong No. 2931
- (2022) Hu 0105 Min Chu No. 24122
