In recent years, it has not been uncommon for U.S. companies to file for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Code—for example, well-known U.S. retailer Sears, U.S. fast-fashion retailer Forever21, and U.S. home goods retailer Bed Bath & Beyond have all filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy petitions. In recent years, Instant Brands, a rising U.S. kitchen appliance brand, Claire's, a well-known U.S. accessories retailer, Spirit Airlines, a well-known U.S. low-cost carrier, and iRobot, the pioneer of the robot vacuum industry, have also filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy petitions one after another. Because these retailers and well-known brands often purchase many products from China, and Chinese suppliers often extend certain payment terms when supplying these retailers and brands, once a U.S. retailer or brand files a bankruptcy petition, it frequently happens that a large number of Chinese suppliers' accounts receivable are listed as bankruptcy claims, and these Chinese suppliers may ultimately receive only a very small portion of repayment from the limited bankruptcy estate.
The Chapter 11 bankruptcy system is designed to enable distressed companies, after filing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition, to obtain a "rebirth" through "design" or reorganization, while protecting the interests of creditors and owners as much as possible. So, as creditors, after Chinese suppliers learn that their customers have filed a U.S. Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition, how should they best protect their rights and interests, and what matters should they pay attention to?
01. Handling of accounts receivable arising before the bankruptcy petition
The priority order of claim repayment under U.S. bankruptcy law can be summarized as: secured claims, administrative expenses (such as attorneys' fees and bankruptcy estate management fees, etc.), priority unsecured claims (such as wages, taxes, etc.), and ordinary pre-bankruptcy unsecured claims. Generally speaking, claims that Chinese suppliers hold against customers arising before the customer files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy often fall into the last priority of repayment—ordinary unsecured claims. How can such pre-bankruptcy accounts receivable be better recovered?
Generally speaking, after Chinese suppliers learn that their U.S. customers have filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings, they should promptly file a proof of claim (to file a proof of claim). Filing a proof of claim is an important step in bankruptcy proceedings; under Chapter 11 bankruptcy, filing a proof of claim can affect whether, how, and when creditors receive repayment from the debtor. Usually, after the debtor files a bankruptcy petition, creditors will receive a Chapter 11 proof of claim form (410 Proof of Claim) when they receive the notice of bankruptcy. The bankruptcy notice will state the bar date for filing proofs of claim, how to file a proof of claim, and where to submit it. If a creditor believes that the debtor's description of the amount and nature of the debt owed to it is inaccurate or disputes the debt, it should file a proof of claim before the bar date. However, even if the creditor believes the description of the amount and nature of the debt is accurate or does not dispute the debt, it may still file a proof of claim, and filing a proof of claim also has certain benefits. For example, the claim information filed by the creditor will replace the relevant information described by the debtor in its schedules of assets and liabilities; if a proof of claim is not filed before the bar date, it will be very difficult for the creditor to file one later, whereas amendments to claim information that was timely filed are usually relatively easy to obtain approval for. If a Chinese company's claim amount is large and it is listed among the top twenty creditors, it can generally also designate a representative to enter the debtor's committee.
When filing a proof of claim, for goods shipped within 20 days before the bankruptcy petition, Chinese suppliers may assert a 503(b)(9) request (also known as the "20-day request"), and Chinese suppliers should file it as an administrative expense claim (such claims rank immediately after secured claims and ahead of all unsecured claims), but to successfully file such a claim, the goods must have been shipped directly to the debtor. The Bankruptcy Code does not prescribe a form or deadline for such filings; the general procedure is to file a motion supported by documents such as invoices and shipping documents, but some cases have set deadlines for filing as well as requirements regarding the value and shipment of the goods.
In addition, most Chinese suppliers, when extending payment terms to U.S. customers, often purchase credit insurance to protect their collection; after learning that a customer has filed a bankruptcy petition, Chinese suppliers should notify the credit insurance company as soon as possible to complete a loss report. After the credit insurance company receives the loss report, it may also provide collection services to the Chinese supplier; at this point, the Chinese supplier needs to carefully consider whether to entrust the credit insurance company with collection on its behalf, and if it does, additional commissions may be incurred (if the collection is successful).
02. Using the critical vendor system to achieve priority repayment of unsecured claims
Even if Chinese suppliers file proofs of claim on time, as mentioned above, these claims generally are unsecured bankruptcy claims, and for such claims at the end of the repayment order, in reality the amount repaid is generally very small—the recovery rate is often less than 10%. However, if Chinese suppliers reasonably use the critical vendor system under U.S. bankruptcy law, they may also be able to obtain a larger proportion of repayment.
Generally speaking, bankruptcy law does not allow a debtor to continue paying pre-bankruptcy debts after bankruptcy, but Section 105 of Chapter 11 allows bankruptcy courts to "issue any order, process, or judgment that is necessary or appropriate to carry out the provisions of the Bankruptcy Code." In practice, a debtor may, by submitting an application to the court, assert certain suppliers' critical vendor status—that it is necessary to pay the pre-bankruptcy debts of such critical vendors in advance in exchange for continued supply by the critical vendors, thereby maintaining the debtor's continued operations to smoothly complete the bankruptcy reorganization process. The court may order and agree that the bankrupt company may repay the pre-bankruptcy debts of such critical vendors on a priority basis, because such orders are "necessary" for them to successfully complete the bankruptcy reorganization. Once the court approves such an application, the debtor may repay the pre-bankruptcy debts of such critical vendors in advance.
It should be noted that creditors cannot decide on their own that they will obtain critical vendor status; on the contrary, whether one can become a critical vendor depends on the debtor, and the debtor can decide who will be its critical vendors and apply to the court for approval. Because critical vendors can obtain the benefit of repayment of ordinary debts, the debtor will also negotiate on this basis and demand some "returns," such as obtaining longer payment terms or more favorable payment conditions. Generally, Chinese suppliers need to sign a critical vendor agreement with the debtor so that the debtor can apply to the court, and the specific terms are negotiated by both parties. However, because Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings proceed quickly, Chinese suppliers need to promptly and swiftly negotiate the critical vendor agreement with the debtor and make decisions, avoiding missing the best opportunity.
03. Actions during the pendency of bankruptcy proceedings
Under Section 105 of Chapter 11 of the U.S. Code, when a debtor files a Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition, the automatic stay is automatically triggered against all parties, and creditors must immediately stop any attempt to collect claims from the debtor. The provisions of Chapter 11 on this are very broad; for example, with respect to the debtor, any attempt to commence or continue legal proceedings shall be stayed, enforcement of obtained judgments shall be stayed, any attempt to possess or control the bankruptcy estate shall be stayed, any attempt to enforce a pre-petition lien shall be stayed, and any setoff against any pre-bankruptcy debt shall be stayed. In other words, once the debtor files a Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition, creditors can no longer pursue any pre-bankruptcy payment obligations from it.
However, Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings are actually reorganization proceedings, and the debtor still cannot avoid needing to continue purchasing a certain quantity of products to maintain operations during the bankruptcy period. At this point, Chinese suppliers will face the choice of whether to continue supplying the debtor during the bankruptcy proceedings. New claims arising from transactions during the bankruptcy period are generally considered administrative expense claims with a higher repayment priority, but there is still a certain risk of non-payment. In addition, once the debtor files a bankruptcy petition, the credit insurance company will very likely no longer provide coverage, which means that Chinese suppliers need to bear the collection risk themselves. Therefore, if Chinese suppliers wish to continue transacting with the debtor during the bankruptcy period, they need to carefully evaluate and consider it.
In any event, Chinese suppliers should keep abreast of developments in the bankruptcy case and avoid missing various deadlines. In Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings, there are often various applications submitted by the debtor to the bankruptcy court, and the court will also frequently schedule hearings to consider various motions and issue various orders; these applications, hearings, and court orders will also affect the rights and interests of Chinese suppliers. Therefore, Chinese suppliers should continuously monitor developments in the bankruptcy case, grasp the various deadlines in the bankruptcy proceedings, and avoid suffering damage to their rights and interests due to missed deadlines and becoming "victims" of the Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings.
Questions and answers
What should a Chinese supplier do after learning that its U.S. customer has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy?
The supplier should promptly file a proof of claim before the bar date to preserve its rights. It should also consider asserting a 503(b)(9) claim for goods shipped within 20 days before the petition, notify its credit insurer, and monitor the case for deadlines.
What is a 503(b)(9) claim and how can a Chinese supplier assert it?
A 503(b)(9) claim, or 20-day claim, is an administrative expense claim for goods shipped within 20 days before the bankruptcy petition. It ranks after secured claims and ahead of unsecured claims. The supplier should file a motion supported by invoices and shipping documents, and the goods must have been shipped directly to the debtor.
How can the critical vendor system help a Chinese supplier obtain priority repayment?
The critical vendor system allows the debtor, with court approval, to pay pre-bankruptcy debts of essential suppliers in exchange for continued supply. The supplier must negotiate a critical vendor agreement with the debtor, who then applies to the court. This can result in a larger repayment proportion than ordinary unsecured claims.
What is the automatic stay in Chapter 11 bankruptcy and how does it affect creditors?
The automatic stay under Section 105 of Chapter 11 stops all collection efforts against the debtor once the petition is filed. Creditors must immediately cease attempts to collect pre-bankruptcy debts, including legal proceedings, enforcement of judgments, and setoffs.
Should a Chinese supplier continue supplying a customer during its Chapter 11 bankruptcy?
New claims from transactions during bankruptcy are generally administrative expense claims with higher priority, but there is still non-payment risk. Credit insurance may no longer cover such transactions, so the supplier must carefully evaluate the risk before continuing to supply.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Chapter 11 of the U.S. Code
- Section 105 of Chapter 11
- 503(b)(9)
Other
- 410 Proof of Claim
