When an investor/offeror initiates a Hong Kong stock delisting, it must engage a financial adviser to confirm that it has the necessary and sufficient financial resources for delisting a listed company. Following our "Hong Kong Stock Delisting Topic Series" introductions on topics such as "irrevocable undertakings" and "reducing delisting costs", this issue will introduce how to confirm that the necessary and sufficient financial resources for delisting a listed company are in place.
Confirmation of sufficient funds is a core concern of any Hong Kong delisting scheme. Given the tightening of financing in the Hong Kong stock market in 2024 and the certain difficulty in fundraising, Hong Kong regulators are paying closer attention to the offeror's financial sufficiency. This includes rigorous review, emphasising that the offeror must from time to time report to the market on the status of the confirmation of sufficient funds, and must ensure, before announcing, that the offeror has sufficient funds that can be withdrawn and used in Hong Kong to pay the delisting consideration.
The common sources of delisting funds for offerors in the market mainly include own funds, loans, or (if the offeror is a fund) an equity commitment letter (ECL). Note that the funds must already be in place with a Hong Kong financial institution. A cash confirmation letter is generally issued by the offeror's financial adviser to the Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong (SFC), to confirm that the offeror has the necessary and sufficient financial resources for delisting a listed company. Depending on the source of the delisting funds, the cash confirmation letter must contain the following:
(i) confirmation that the financial adviser is satisfied that the offeror has sufficient offshore financial resources to complete the delisting transaction in Hong Kong;
(ii) an explanation of the basis on which the financial adviser made the above confirmation, and details of the due diligence steps it took (for example, the list of documents reviewed), so as to satisfy itself that the offeror now has, and will continue to have, sufficient financial resources;
If the source of funds is own funds, the financial adviser must review the offeror's bank statements and, in accordance with market practice, open an escrow account under the joint supervision of the offeror and the financial adviser for payment of the delisting funds;
If the source of funds is a loan, the financial adviser must review the loan agreement and confirm that the financing is not subject to any subjective conditions and that the funds can be drawn in Hong Kong and used to pay the delisting consideration;
If the offeror is a fund, it will use an equity commitment letter (ECL); the financial adviser must review the equity commitment letter, the fund's structure and the limited partner investment agreement, etc., to confirm that the equity contribution can be used in Hong Kong and can be drawn at any time;
(iii) when performing its duties and issuing the cash confirmation letter, the financial adviser should observe the highest standard of care, act responsibly, conduct due diligence, and have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the offeror has such cash, so as to satisfy itself that the offeror's resources are sufficient.
There are also market cases where the source of funds stated in the cash confirmation letter is not the same as the funds ultimately paid; the key point is that the offeror can ultimately pay the relevant amount in full in Hong Kong and protect the interests of participating shareholders. For example: the source of funds mentioned in the cash confirmation letter is a loan or funds of another offshore entity within the group; the funds ultimately paid are outbound foreign investment (ODI) funds that have already left the country. Even if the offeror intends to use ODI funds to pay the delisting funds, it must also arrange offshore funds or loans that can be drawn and used at any time as a cash fallback plan, to satisfy the due diligence procedures required by the financial adviser before issuing the cash confirmation letter.
The cash confirmation letter must be issued to the SFC at the following times:
When submitting the 3.5 announcement for approval: when the offeror publishes the 3.5 announcement expressing a firm intention to delist, it must already have sufficient funds or financing arrangements for the delisting, to ensure it has sufficient funds to pay the delisting consideration. The SFC does not accept a delisting that is conditional on the offeror being able to obtain the relevant financing;
When submitting the delisting scheme document for approval: before publishing the delisting scheme document, the offeror's financial adviser should provide an updated cash confirmation letter, which may be in a form similar to the cash confirmation letter submitted with the 3.5 announcement for approval; and
If any change in circumstances may affect the confirmation already given by the financial adviser (for example, a change in the financing provider, such as when Max Tuner Limited recently made an offer for Mobile Internet (China) Holdings Limited, where the change in its financing provider was addressed by a supplemental announcement and a supplemental cash confirmation letter), the offeror and its financial adviser should work together to ensure that sufficient financial resources are available to pay the delisting consideration.
In addition to applying where the delisting consideration is paid in cash or includes a partial cash consideration, the cash confirmation letter also applies where the delisting consideration is any other asset or includes a partial asset (except for new securities the offeror intends to issue).
Note:
Cases where a shareholder breaches an irrevocable undertaking by failing to accept the offer are very rare. Shareholders who are required to, and do, provide irrevocable undertakings
In our practice acting for clients in delisting Hong Kong-listed companies, we have accumulated rich practical experience. If you have any questions in the process of a Hong Kong stock delisting, you are welcome to contact the professional team of Fangda Partners.
This article is the third of five articles in the "Hong Kong Stock Delisting Topic Series". Please note that the articles in the "Hong Kong Stock Delisting Topic Series" do not constitute formal legal advice, and all specific schemes must be subject to professional advice.
Questions and answers
What due diligence must a financial adviser perform on the source of delisting funds?
For own funds, the adviser must review bank statements and open an escrow account under joint supervision. For loans, it must review the loan agreement and confirm no subjective conditions and that funds can be drawn in Hong Kong. For funds using an equity commitment letter, it must review the ECL, fund structure and limited partner investment agreement to confirm the equity contribution can be used in Hong Kong and drawn at any time.
When must the cash confirmation letter be issued to the SFC?
The cash confirmation letter must be issued when submitting the 3.5 announcement for approval, when submitting the delisting scheme document for approval (an updated letter), and upon any change in circumstances that may affect the confirmation, such as a change in financing provider.
Can a Hong Kong delisting be conditional on obtaining financing?
No. The SFC does not accept a delisting that is conditional on the offeror being able to obtain the relevant financing. The offeror must already have sufficient funds or financing arrangements for the delisting when publishing the 3.5 announcement expressing a firm intention to delist.
Does the cash confirmation letter apply if the delisting consideration includes assets?
Yes. In addition to applying where the delisting consideration is paid in cash or includes a partial cash consideration, the cash confirmation letter also applies where the delisting consideration is any other asset or includes a partial asset, except for new securities the offeror intends to issue.
Laws and cases cited
Other
- Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong (SFC)
