When clients consider launching a privatisation of a Hong Kong-listed company, they must inevitably arrange the funds required for the privatisation. Our "Hong Kong Privatisation Topic Series" has attracted clients' attention and interest. Following the previous instalment on irrevocable undertakings, this instalment focuses on how to reduce privatisation costs in the privatisation process.

In 2024 the Hong Kong stock market remained volatile, which on the one hand provides market opportunities to leverage valuation advantages to reduce privatisation costs, and on the other hand, with financing and borrowing costs relatively high, the offeror must minimise privatisation costs as far as possible.

The most common privatisation method in the market is the scheme of arrangement, initiated by the offeror under the law of the place of incorporation of the listed company. Under the Hong Kong Takeovers Code, a court meeting to approve a scheme of arrangement must obtain the approval of more than 75% of the equity held by the independent shareholders present at the meeting, and the number of votes against must not exceed 10% of the voting rights of all independent shareholders.

In a scheme of arrangement, by designing the transaction structure and reducing the size of the offer, the following two ways of achieving cost reduction are available:

1. Rollover

(a) Management rollover

If the management of the listed company holds shares, the offeror also considers that the existing management team can be maintained, and the management is willing to accept a rollover arrangement, the delisting funds need not include the amount of the management's shareholding. Note that a rollover arrangement is usually regarded by the regulators as a special deal, requiring the approval of 75% of the independent shareholders, and the rolling-over management generally cannot vote as independent shareholders. Delisting cases involving management rollover include Jinzai Food Group Co., Ltd. (金嗓子控股集团有限公司) and others. In addition, under the target listed company's management share incentive plan, consideration may be given to rolling over the award shares under the incentive plan as a package, for example, Dali Foods Group Company Limited (达利食品集团有限公司) and others, to continue to be used to incentivise the company's management after delisting.

(b) Major shareholder rollover

If the existing shareholders of the listed company have historical and potential contributions to the business, operations and development of the listed company, they may also apply to roll over in the privatisation. Because a rollover arrangement is usually regarded by the regulators as a special deal, requiring the approval of 75% of the independent shareholders, the rolling-over shareholder also loses its independence because it enjoys an advantage over other shareholders in the special deal (it can continue to be a shareholder after delisting), and cannot vote as an independent shareholder. Therefore, the offeror must consider and balance whether, after excluding the shareholding subject to the rollover arrangement, the likelihood of approval by the votes of the other independent shareholders will be affected. Delisting cases involving major shareholder rollover include China Hongtai Industrial Municipal Development Co., Ltd. (中国宏泰产业市政发展有限公司), Jiangnan Group Limited (江南集团有限公司), Golden Eagle Retail Group Limited (金鹰商贸集团有限公司) and others.

The previous instalment of the "Hong Kong Privatisation Topic Series" — Irrevocable Undertakings — introduced the collection of irrevocable letters from shareholders, with independent shareholders issuing irrevocable undertakings to enhance the certainty of the privatisation. This will not be repeated here. The offeror may consider using rollover together with irrevocable undertaking arrangements, which both ensures a relatively high turnout of independent shareholders and saves privatisation costs.

2. Using shares as privatisation consideration

The offeror may consider offering a choice between cash consideration and share consideration, fairly giving all shareholders the opportunity to choose. If a shareholder chooses share consideration, it will remain an indirect shareholder of the delisted company after the privatisation. For the broad public shareholders, holding shares in the delisted company may carry liquidity risk, and public shareholders are generally cautious about choosing share consideration. The offeror may combine this with irrevocable undertakings to obtain the support of major or strategic shareholders, who undertake that they will choose share consideration, thereby both ensuring the independence of such shareholders and saving privatisation costs. Delisting cases involving share consideration include Huifu Payment Limited (汇付天下有限公司), Suchuang Gas Corporation Limited (苏创燃气股份有限公司) and others.

In practice, offerors each have different commercial considerations and needs, and the shareholding structures and businesses of listed companies also differ, so each privatisation case has its own characteristics. If necessary, the offeror may also consider, after publishing the Rule 3.5 announcement, engaging a proxy solicitation firm to canvass the remaining independent shareholders to vote in favour of the privatisation proposal. Our firm has accumulated rich practical experience in representing clients in privatising Hong Kong-listed companies. We are willing to assist you in carrying out analysis and tailoring the most suitable privatisation transaction structure for you. You are welcome to contact the professional team of Fangda Partners.

Questions and answers

What shareholder approval thresholds apply to a scheme of arrangement under the Hong Kong Takeovers Code?

A court meeting to approve a scheme of arrangement must obtain approval of more than 75% of the equity held by independent shareholders present at the meeting, and the number of votes against must not exceed 10% of the voting rights of all independent shareholders.

How does a management rollover reduce privatisation costs in a Hong Kong privatisation?

If management holds shares and agrees to roll over, the delisting funds need not include the amount of management's shareholding, reducing the offer size. However, a rollover is usually regarded as a special deal requiring 75% independent shareholder approval, and the rolling-over management cannot vote as independent shareholders.

What are the regulatory considerations for a major shareholder rollover in a Hong Kong privatisation?

A major shareholder rollover is usually regarded as a special deal requiring 75% independent shareholder approval. The rolling-over shareholder loses independence and cannot vote as an independent shareholder, so the offeror must consider whether approval by other independent shareholders is still likely after excluding the rollover shares.

How can share consideration be used to reduce privatisation costs in a Hong Kong privatisation?

The offeror may offer a choice between cash and share consideration. If shareholders choose shares, they remain indirect shareholders of the delisted company. Combining this with irrevocable undertakings from major or strategic shareholders to choose share consideration can save costs while ensuring independence.

Can rollover arrangements be combined with irrevocable undertakings in a Hong Kong privatisation?

Yes, the offeror may consider using rollover together with irrevocable undertaking arrangements, which both ensures a relatively high turnout of independent shareholders and saves privatisation costs.

Laws and cases cited

Regulations

  • Hong Kong Takeovers Code
  • Rule 3.5 announcement