Introduction
On 13 December 2024, the General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR, Regulation (EU) 2023/988) became fully applicable, marking a new phase in EU product safety regulation. From a directive upgraded to a regulation, from the RAPEX system upgraded to Safety Gate, from an authorised representative expanded to a responsible person system — these changes are not a simple substitution of terminology, but a systematic reconstruction of the logic of EU product safety governance.
For Chinese companies exporting to Europe, the impact of this change is profound. In the past, many companies equated EU product safety compliance with obtaining the CE mark or completing the relevant test reports, and regarded regulatory risk as a "low-probability event". However, the data show that this is no longer an incidental risk that can be ignored. In 2023, the EU Safety Gate system issued a total of 2,630 notifications, of which 1,118 involved Chinese products, accounting for approximately 42.5%[1]; in 2024, notifications involving Chinese products numbered 1,032, accounting for approximately 41.1%. The product categories covered by the notifications include electronic products, toys, children's products, machinery and appliances, etc., and the reasons for notification are concentrated on high-frequency matters such as excessive chemical substances, electric shock risk, and suffocation risk. It can be said that receiving an investigation notice from a Member State competent authority is no longer a "black swan" event, but a routine compliance risk that any company exporting to Europe may face during the product life cycle.
However, what truly troubles Chinese companies is not the risk itself, but the structural complexity of the EU regulatory system. Many Chinese companies, through long-term export practice to the US, have developed relatively mature experience in dealing with the CPSC's regulatory logic of "a single agency, a single law, a 24-hour bright line". But when they face the fragmented landscape of the EU — "27 Member States, 27 sets of competent authorities, 27 enforcement rhythms" — this experience is no longer sufficient. The EU is not a larger version of the United States — the logic of product safety compliance cannot simply be transplanted.
In practice, companies that receive an investigation notice from a Member State often face, at the very first moment, a series of urgent and thorny questions: how much enforcement authority does the authority that issued the investigation notice have? Within exactly how many hours must "immediate reporting" be completed? Should they reply directly to the investigating country, or notify all countries of sale at the same time? What role does the company's authorised representative or responsible person play in this process, and does the scope of their contract cover enforcement response? For products sold simultaneously in multiple Member States, how should the recall requirements of different countries be coordinated? These questions point to a common core — Chinese companies lack a systematic understanding of the operating logic of the EU product recall system.
This article intends to start from the legal framework of EU product safety regulation and systematically sort out the practical questions that Chinese companies care most about when facing a recall investigation: who regulates, what standard triggers reporting, when to report, how to recall, what the consequences of violation are, and how to obtain remedies. The article compares the CPSC system where appropriate, in order to provide operable compliance guidance for Chinese companies targeting both the European and American markets. Of particular note is that the application of the GPSR has only just begun, and companies are in a critical window period of transition from the GPSD to the GPSR — clarifying the obligations and procedures under the new rules concerns not only compliance costs, but also the fundamental qualification for market access.
01. Overview of the EU Product Safety Regulatory System
(1) Core Regulatory Authorities and Division of Functions
A basic feature of EU product safety regulation is the decentralisation of regulatory power. Unlike the CPSC, which is a single federal regulator in the United States, enforcement power in the EU is dispersed among the 27 Member States.
The European Commission is responsible for policy coordination, standard-setting and the operation of the information exchange system, but does not directly exercise enforcement power. Enforcement decisions with binding force — including product detention, market bans and mandatory recalls — are all made by the National Competent Authorities of each Member State. Safety Gate (the rapid alert system for non-food consumer products) is the platform through which Member States exchange product risk information; when one Member State identifies a serious risk in a product, it notifies the other Member States through Safety Gate[2].
The direct consequence of this institutional design is that the same product being found non-compliant by the German competent authority does not affect its lawful sale on the French market. But the practical difficulty companies face is that they need to deal simultaneously with two separate enforcement procedures in Germany and France. If a product is sold in 10 Member States, in theory the company needs to be prepared to accept 10 different enforcement rhythms and requirements.
(2) Core Legal Framework: The Interface between the GPSR and the GPSD
On 23 May 2023, the EU officially published the General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR, Regulation (EU) 2023/988). The Regulation has been formally applicable since 13 December 2024 and simultaneously repeals the former General Product Safety Directive (GPSD, 2001/95/EC)[3].
This change is of substantive significance to companies. The old Directive needed to be transposed into national law by each Member State before it could apply, and differences existed among countries in the transposition process; the new Regulation has directly applicable legal effect, does not require transposition by Member States, and applies uniformly in all Member States. The upgrade from a "directive" to a "regulation" means that both the uniformity and the enforceability of EU product safety regulation have been strengthened.
Regarding the interface between the old and new rules, companies should note that for products placed on the market on or before 12 December 2024 under the GPSD, the compliance assessment still applies the GPSD standards; products newly placed on the market from 13 December 2024 must fully comply with the GPSR requirements. In addition, declarations of conformity issued under the GPSD remain valid after the GPSR becomes applicable and do not need to be reissued[3].
The GPSR continues the core principle of the GPSD — that a product does not constitute any risk, or constitutes only an acceptable minimum risk, under normal or reasonably foreseeable conditions of use[3]. At the same time, the GPSR makes more specific provisions on the chain of responsibility of economic operators, the obligations of online sales platforms, and the duties of authorised representatives.
02. Product Risk Determination Standards
(1) The Legal Definition of "Safe Product"
Article 3 of the GPSR defines a "safe product" as one that, under normal or reasonably foreseeable conditions of use, does not constitute any risk or constitutes only an acceptable minimum risk, and that risk is commensurate with the product's use function and is acceptable while ensuring a high level of protection of consumer health and safety[3].
"Reasonably foreseeable use" is a key concept in practice. It includes not only the normal use envisaged by the manufacturer, but also reasonably foreseeable misuse. For example, children's toys may be put in the mouth, electronic products may be used in a humid environment, batteries may be removed by children — these all fall within "reasonably foreseeable use" and should be taken into account by the manufacturer when conducting the safety assessment.
(2) Criteria for Determining "Serious Risk"
The GPSR requires that only product defects reaching the level of "serious risk" trigger the RAPEX notification procedure. Determining "serious risk" requires comprehensive consideration of the following factors: the severity of the risk (whether it may cause death or serious injury), the probability of the risk occurring, the scope and characteristics of the affected population (whether vulnerable groups such as children are involved), and the quantity and duration of the product's circulation on the market[4].
(3) The Manufacturer's Safety Assessment Obligation
A fundamental difference from the CPSC system lies in the timing of risk determination. The CPSC adopts a "post-market triggering determination" mechanism, that is, there is no mandatory pre-market safety assessment requirement when a product is placed on the market. When a company obtains information that reasonably supports the existence of a defect in a product that may constitute a substantial hazard, the 24-hour reporting obligation is triggered, and the CPSC then verifies through investigation whether the company's determination is accurate. Under the EU system, risk determination is an obligation that "must be completed in advance" — the manufacturer must complete a product safety assessment before placing the product on the market and must continuously track safety information after placing it on the market.
Article 9 of the GPSR expressly requires that, before placing a product on the market, the manufacturer should conduct an internal risk analysis, assess the safety of the product throughout its reasonably foreseeable life cycle, and draw up technical documentation[3]. In addition, after placing the product on the market, the manufacturer must continuously collect and analyse information related to product safety. When "new information" appears — including safety incident reports for similar products, new scientific research findings, and recall information for similar products of other manufacturers — the safety of the product needs to be reassessed, and on that basis it is determined whether the reporting obligation is triggered[3].
03. Reporting Obligations and Time Limits
(1) Who Bears the Reporting Obligation
The GPSR collectively refers to the various entities in the product supply chain as "economic operators" and clarifies their respective chains of responsibility[3]:
The Manufacturer is the primary responsible party and bears ultimate responsibility for all reporting obligations.
The Importer is responsible for verifying that the manufacturer has fulfilled its obligations and bears an independent reporting obligation.
The Distributor must notify the manufacturer and the competent authority after becoming aware of a risk.
For Chinese companies, the most common position is that of manufacturer — which means the reporting obligation cannot be transferred to the importer or distributor. In practice, the importer may assist by reporting on the company's behalf, but the party ultimately bearing legal responsibility is the manufacturer.
One of the key differences from the CPSC system lies in the authorised representative requirement. The CPSC does not require the designation of a legal representative in the United States; companies can communicate directly with the CPSC. However, Article 7 of the GPSR mandatorily requires manufacturers to designate an authorised representative within the EU (Authorised Representative)[3]. The authorised representative's statutory duties include: ensuring that the declaration of conformity and technical documentation are available for inspection by the competent authorities; and cooperating with the competent authorities by providing all necessary information upon request.
Regarding the authorised representative, two issues need attention in practice:
1) The authorised representative does not automatically assume enforcement response functions. A large number of authorised representative contracts cover only the custody of technical documentation and do not include formal communication with competent authorities or legal response.
2) Differences exist among Member States in determining the liability of authorised representatives — France requires the authorised representative to independently assume part of the compliance obligations when the manufacturer cannot be reached, while Germany places more emphasis on the joint and several liability of the importer and the manufacturer[5].
(2) What Circumstances Trigger the Reporting Obligation
Article 20 of the GPSR provides that an economic operator, after becoming aware that a product presents a safety risk, shall immediately notify the competent authorities of the Member States in which it has placed the product on the market[3]. Triggering the reporting obligation requires the following conditions to be met: the product presents a safety risk; the risk may cause serious consequences; and the relevant information is "new information" (i.e., information not available when the product was placed on the market).
Practical judgment examples: an electrical product has a risk of electric shock and there have already been 3 reports of minor injuries — this constitutes a serious risk and must be reported to the relevant member states; a small part of a toy detaches under standard testing but there has been no accident yet — it is necessary to assess whether the detached size falls within the range prohibited by the EN 71-1 standard, and decide whether to report depending on the circumstances; a product label omits non-critical information and does not affect safe use — this usually does not constitute a safety risk, and may be temporarily not reported but should be recorded on file.
(3) When to report: differences in time limits
Article 15(b) of the CPSC sets a clear 24-hour reporting obligation — an enterprise must report to the CPSC within 24 hours after obtaining reportable information [6]. This rule is simple, clear and predictable.
Article 20 of the EU GPSR requires reporting "immediately", or "without undue delay" [3]. This standard lacks a clear time scale. The competent authorities of different member states may interpret what constitutes "immediately" differently.
Although EU law does not expressly specify a concrete time limit, it is recommended that enterprises set an internal reporting target of 24-48 hours in their internal compliance systems. This has two practical meanings: first, even if the EU competent authorities' "immediately" standard is interpreted more leniently than 24 hours, the enterprise can still prove that it has made its best efforts; second, it can avoid the passive situation, when reporting to multiple member states is required, of "one country has been notified while another has not".
(4) To whom to report
Manufacturers should report risk information to the competent authority of each member state in which the product is placed on the market. If a product is sold in three countries — Germany, France and the Netherlands — and a safety defect is found in Germany, the manufacturer, while reporting to the German competent authority, should also assess whether the same information needs to be notified to the competent authorities of France and the Netherlands. Once a RAPEX notification is initiated by a competent authority, it means that the risk information about the product has spread to all member states, and the enterprise can no longer treat the issue as "an incident occurring only in Germany".
In summary, the EU product recall information reporting path (all information transmission is completed within the Safety Gate system): the enterprise submits unsafe product information immediately through the Safety Gate → the member state notifies the European Commission through the Safety Gate system within 4 working days → the European Commission, after verification within 4 working days, distributes it to all member states → after receiving the notification, the member states monitor and, as appropriate, notify follow-up measures within 4 working days.
04. Recall standards and recall methods
(1) Voluntary recall and mandatory recall
Under the EU system, the vast majority of recalls are initiated by enterprises on their own initiative (voluntary recalls), with the procedure being: the enterprise confirms the risk → notifies the competent authority of the relevant member state → negotiates the specific plan → issues a recall notice and implements it → submits an implementation report [4].
Mandatory recall occurs when an enterprise does not cooperate or the recall plan it proposes is inadequate, and the competent authority of the member state issues a mandatory recall order in accordance with the law [4]. The key difference lies in the initiative: in a voluntary recall the enterprise has considerable room for negotiation, while in a mandatory recall the enterprise can only passively accept. In cases involving multiple member states, a mandatory recall order in one member state may trigger chain actions in other member states through the Safety Gate system.
Where a product has a clear safety defect and may cause serious personal injury, actual accident reports already exist, and defective products have already circulated in large quantities on the market, it is advisable to initiate a recall on one's own initiative. Where the problem is merely label non-compliance, the defect appears only under extreme conditions of use, and the technical analysis has not yet been completed, voluntary recall may be deferred and investigation continued.
(2) Applicable scenarios of five recall methods
The GPSR does not lay down uniform provisions on recall methods; the enterprise proposes a plan and implements it after approval by the competent authority. Five methods commonly seen in practice are as follows:
1) Return and refund, applicable where the safety defect cannot be repaired or repair is uneconomical; the cost is the highest but acceptance by the competent authority is the highest.
2) Replacement, applicable where the problem is limited to a specific batch and the new batch has been confirmed to be compliant; the cost is relatively high, and customer relationships can be retained.
3) Repair/modification, applicable where the defect can be resolved by replacing partial components and the product value is relatively high; the cost is medium.
4) Software upgrade, applicable where the defect stems from a software logic error and the product has networking functions; the cost is relatively low, but it is necessary to ensure that users actually complete the upgrade.
5) Adding warnings/amending instructions, applicable where the risk is controllable and can be avoided once users are fully informed; the cost is the lowest, but it applies only to low-risk situations and not to products with substantive safety defects.
In practice, a single recall method is often insufficient. A piece of electronic equipment may require a combined plan of software upgrade, added warning labels and replacement of some batches at the same time. The design of the plan should fully consider consumer cooperation — for B2C products, if consumers need to actively send the product back or perform operations, the difficulty of implementation must be assessed and a multi-round notification mechanism designed.
(3) Institutional differences from the CPSC
The CPSC has a Fast-track Recall Program, under which an enterprise may apply within 20 working days after fulfilling its reporting obligation, greatly shortening the investigation cycle and reducing response costs [6]. The EU has no unified fast-track recall procedure; enterprises need to negotiate plans separately with the competent authorities of each country, and the predictability of the procedure is lower.
CPSC recall notices are all published uniformly through the CPSC official website, highly standardized and centralized. EU recall notices have no unified publication platform; the competent authorities of each country publish them separately, and the Safety Gate system only notifies serious risks and does not contain all recall information. The direct challenge this poses to Chinese enterprises is the need to prepare notices in multiple languages and adapt to the publication formats and content requirements of each country.
05. Consequences of violations and remedies
(1) Consequences of violations
1) Administrative fines: Article 46 of the GPSR requires each member state to establish a penalty system that is effective, proportionate and dissuasive [3]. Fine standards differ among member states: in Germany, for example, the administrative fines provided for in the Product Safety Act (ProdSG) can reach up to EUR 100,000; the upper limit of fines under the French Consumer Code is higher, up to EUR 100,000 for natural persons (which may be increased in serious circumstances) and up to several hundred thousand euros for legal persons; the Netherlands has a system of cumulative daily fines. Compared with the CPSC's per-day penalties (up to USD 121,950 per day of delay, under the standards adjusted as of 2025, with a maximum civil penalty of USD 19,903,000 per violation) [6], a single EU fine may appear lower, but an enterprise may be penalized by multiple member states at the same time, and the cumulative total is considerable.
2) Market exclusion: member states may issue temporary or permanent bans prohibiting the sale of specific products in their country. After a RAPEX notification, other member states may follow up with similar measures. A ban in one country may spread through the information-sharing mechanism into joint action by multiple countries.
3) Civil compensation: the Product Liability Directive (85/374/EEC, as amended by 1999/34/EC) establishes the principle of no-fault liability — consumers do not need to prove that the manufacturer was negligent; they only need to prove that the product was defective, that the defect caused damage, and that there is a causal link between the damage and the defect, in order to obtain compensation [7].
Differences in enforcement orientation from the CPSC: in the Gree case, the CPSC demonstrated a tough stance of pursuing individual criminal liability for late reporting. Two executives of Gree USA were sentenced to 40 months and 38 months of federal imprisonment respectively for conspiring to defraud the CPSC and violating the CPSA by failing to provide required information [8]. Under the EU system, criminal prosecution of individual executives is relatively rare, but administrative fines and orders to remove products from sale are usually enforced faster.
(2) Remedies for enterprises
1) Administrative remedies: after the competent authority makes a preliminary decision, the enterprise has the right to submit written opinions and evidence within a specified period to defend itself. Against the final penalty decision, it may apply for administrative reconsideration to the body that made the decision in accordance with the law. The application period in each member state is usually within 1 to 3 months from the date of receipt of the decision, subject to the administrative procedure law of each country.
2) Judicial remedies: where administrative reconsideration cannot resolve the dispute, an administrative lawsuit may be brought before the court of the member state that made the decision. If the dispute involves the interpretation of EU law, it may, in the course of the proceedings before the member state court, apply to refer the legal question to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) for a Preliminary Ruling [4]. Note, however, that a preliminary ruling of the CJEU deals only with questions of legal application and does not directly overturn the factual findings of the competent authority of a member state.
3) Risk communication strategy: the enterprise should show a cooperative attitude at the first response, proactively submit a rectification plan and regularly report progress, so as to seek a reduction in the severity of penalties. One lesson of the Gree case is that, in addition to late reporting, part of the information was concealed in the first report — the dishonest conduct directly led to the criminal charge of conspiring to defraud the CPSC [8]. The same principle applies to the EU system.
06. Summary of the core differences between the two systems and recommendations for response
(1) Comparison of core differences
(2) Practical recommendations for Chinese enterprises
First, establish an independent product safety compliance function. For enterprises exporting to both Europe and the United States, a product safety compliance officer position should be set up, responsible for collecting regulatory developments, managing the complaint system, and coordinating internal and external resources. Externally, professional legal counsel should be selected separately for the US market and the EU market — for EU legal counsel, it is recommended to choose a medium-to-large law firm with a practice network in the main member states, so as to cope with differences in enforcement among multiple countries.
Second, distinguish shared elements from differing elements. Product testing and certification, quality management systems, complaint record management, and supply chain traceability systems can be shared to serve both systems. However, technical documentation should be filed separately according to the two sets of requirements; the authorized representative serves only the EU; and the response pace of reporting paths and time limits should be set with independent internal processes for each of the two systems.
Third, grasp the practical operation of "immediately". Enterprises should set an internal reporting target of 24-48 hours in their internal compliance systems, which can both prove that best efforts have been made when questioned by the competent authority and avoid unsynchronized timing when reporting to multiple countries.
Fourth, choose the authorized representative prudently. The agreement should clearly specify whether the scope of services of the authorized representative includes responding to enforcement; understand the specific requirements of the main sales countries regarding the responsibilities of authorized representatives; and regularly confirm that the contact channels of the authorized representative are unobstructed.
Conclusion
Although CPSC recall investigations and investigations by the competent authorities of EU member states are both product safety enforcement actions, the two systems have substantive differences in core dimensions such as regulatory architecture, reporting time limits, risk determination and enforcement orientation. Directly responding to the EU with the habitual practices used to respond to the CPSC may lead to errors of direction.
For Chinese enterprises exporting to both Europe and the United States, dual compliance is not simply a "stacking of costs", but rather, through reasonable planning and professional division of labor, retaining independent response resources for differing elements while sharing basic elements. Product safety compliance is not a cost burden, but a passport to entering the international market. Only enterprises that demonstrate compliance capability under both institutional systems can walk more steadily and further in global competition.
Questions and answers
When did the EU General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR) become fully applicable and what did it replace?
The GPSR (Regulation (EU) 2023/988) became fully applicable on 13 December 2024 and simultaneously repealed the former General Product Safety Directive (GPSD, 2001/95/EC). The upgrade from a directive to a regulation means it applies directly in all Member States without national transposition, strengthening uniformity and enforceability.
Must Chinese manufacturers appoint an authorised representative in the EU under the GPSR?
Yes. Article 7 of the GPSR mandatorily requires manufacturers to designate an authorised representative within the EU. The representative's statutory duties include ensuring the declaration of conformity and technical documentation are available for inspection and cooperating with competent authorities. However, the representative does not automatically assume enforcement response functions unless the contract expressly covers this.
What are the consequences for violating EU product safety rules under the GPSR?
Consequences include administrative fines set by each Member State (e.g., up to EUR 100,000 in Germany under the ProdSG, higher in France), market exclusion through temporary or permanent bans, and civil compensation under the Product Liability Directive's no-fault liability principle. Penalties may be imposed by multiple Member States simultaneously, and a ban in one country may spread through the Safety Gate system.
How does the EU recall system differ from the US CPSC recall process?
The EU has no unified fast-track recall procedure like the CPSC's Fast-track Recall Program; companies must negotiate separately with each Member State's competent authority. EU recall notices are published separately by each country with no centralised platform, whereas CPSC notices are published uniformly on its website. This requires Chinese companies to prepare multilingual notices and adapt to different national formats.
Laws and cases cited
Laws
- Article 15(b) of the CPSC
- Product Safety Act (ProdSG)
- French Consumer Code
Regulations
- General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR, Regulation (EU) 2023/988)
- General Product Safety Directive (GPSD, 2001/95/EC)
- Article 3 of the GPSR
- Article 9 of the GPSR
- Article 7 of the GPSR
- Article 20 of the GPSR
- Article 46 of the GPSR
- Product Liability Directive (85/374/EEC, as amended by 1999/34/EC)
Standards
- EN 71-1 standard
Cases
- Gree case
Other
- Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)
References
- European Commission. 2023 Annual Report on the Safety Gate (RAPEX) System; 2024 Annual Report on the Safety Gate (RAPEX) System. Brussels: European Commission.
- Regulation (EU) 2023/988 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 on General Product Safety. Official Journal of the European Union, L 135/1, 23.5.2023. Article 34 (RAPEX system).
- Regulation (EU) 2023/988 (General Product Safety Regulation, GPSR). Article 3 (definition of safe product), Article 7 (authorised representative), Article 9 (obligations of manufacturers), Article 20 (reporting obligation), Article 46 (penalty regime).
- European Commission. Guidance on the Application of Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on General Product Safety. Brussels: European Commission, 2024.
- On the organisational structure of the product safety competent authorities of EU Member States and the legal provisions on the liability of authorised representatives, see the relevant national laws such as the German Product Safety Act (ProdSG), the French Consumer Code and the Dutch Commodities Act.
- Consumer Product Safety Act (CPSA), 15 U.S.C. §§ 2051-2089. Section 15(b) (15 U.S.C. § 2064(b)) on the 24-hour reporting obligation; the amount of civil penalties is adjusted annually pursuant to the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act, and the amounts listed in this article are the adjusted standards as of 2025, subject to the latest amounts published on the CPSC official website.
- Council Directive 85/374/EEC of 25 July 1985 on the Approximation of the Laws, Regulations and Administrative Provisions of the Member States concerning Liability for Defective Products, as amended by Directive 1999/34/EC.
- United States v. Simon Chu and Charley Loh, Case No. 2:19-cr-00166 (C.D. Cal. 2019, sentenced June 2025). For the findings of fact and judgment in the case of Gree Electric Appliances' U.S. subsidiary, see the announcements of the U.S. Department of Justice and the CPSC enforcement records.
