The United States is the world's largest and most stable market, and also the market with the strictest requirements for product quality. Take product safety as an example: product liability civil litigation in the United States is highly developed. If a product safety accident occurs, consumers and consumer lawyers will not easily let manufacturers off the hook; they will persistently seek huge claims (see Nightmare for Manufacturing Enterprises - U.S. Product Liability Litigation). The U.S. government will not leave matters alone either. In fact, since 1972 the U.S. government has established a dedicated "ministerial-level" federal government department to regulate product safety: the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).

I. CPSC's Goals and Regulatory Approach

The ultimate goal of the CPSC is to reduce the product accident rate, that is, to reduce year by year the number of people who die or are injured due to consumer products. For example, in 2023, the number of deaths in the United States related to consumer products was 59,900, and in 2024 the number of injuries (requiring emergency care) related to consumer products reached 15.07 million. The CPSC's goal is to keep these numbers falling continuously. Therefore, the CPSC can be described as the "quality department" for consumer products nationwide in the United States, with the task of ensuring that the safety level of consumer products across the country continues to improve.

The CPSC itself does not produce consumer products. To accomplish the arduous task of raising the safety level of consumer products, there are only two paths: one is to raise product market access standards to ensure that the safety level of products entering the market continues to improve. The second is to promptly identify problematic products and implement recalls, recovering those "fish that slip through the net" that have entered the market for various reasons, thereby reducing the chances that problematic products are actually used.

II. CPSC's Role as Supervisor in Recalls

Before a product recall occurs, if a consumer has an accident due to a product, the consumer may complain to the CPSC, and the CPSC will notify the manufacturer. If a manufacturer discovers that a product may have a safety hazard, it is obliged to report to the CPSC. If a manufacturer wishes to implement a recall, it must submit a recall plan to the CPSC and may publish it only after approval. If the manufacturer does not voluntarily propose a recall, the CPSC may investigate the product safety, and upon confirming that the product is unsafe, make a determination and "recommend" or even "mandate" that the manufacturer implement a recall.

After a product recall occurs, the CPSC will issue a formal announcement through its official website and will also inform local cooperating media in advance, requiring local media to publish reports simultaneously. In 2025, the CPSC issued 357 recalls, averaging about one per day. Manufacturers must regularly report recall progress to the CPSC so that the CPSC can determine whether the recall plan needs adjustment or whether a further recall announcement needs to be issued. If consumers are dissatisfied with the recall process, they may also complain to the CPSC, and the CPSC will forward consumer complaints to the manufacturer and urge it to resolve them.

In many cases, the CPSC has the authority to impose fines, for example, where a manufacturer fails to report a product safety hazard in a timely manner after discovering it, where a manufacturer violates CPSC mandatory safety standards, where there is false representation, where products already recalled are sold, or where relevant certification marks (such as UL) are used without authorization. In 2025, the CPSC imposed fines of US$16.025 million and US$12.25 million respectively on a Canadian furniture manufacturer and a U.S. wearable device brand, with total fines amounting to US$28.275 million; since 2026, the CPSC has imposed a fine of US$11.5 million on a Japanese company.

Consistent with the principles by which other U.S. government agencies impose fines, the CPSC must also follow Due Process when imposing fines. Manufacturers have the opportunity to negotiate and communicate regarding the fine proposal put forward by the CPSC and to state their views, and if dissatisfied with a decision made by the CPSC, they also have the right to resolve the matter through litigation in federal court (rare in practice). For example, in 2017, a coffee machine company sued the CPSC over a CPSC fine; at the end of September that year, the judge determined the fine amount to be US$1.93 million rather than the US$30.3 million claimed by the CPSC.

If an enterprise fails to report a hazardous product to the CPSC in a timely manner, the enterprise and the relevant personnel may even face criminal liability. In June 2025, the U.S. subsidiary of a well-known Chinese enterprise, for failing to report to the CPSC the fire risk of its dehumidifier products, became the subject of the first criminal prosecution by the U.S. Department of Justice under the Consumer Product Safety Act (CPSA) against two of the enterprise's senior executives, who were ultimately sentenced to more than three years' imprisonment.

IV. China's "CPSC": the Defective Product Recall Technical Center

In fact, in recent years China has also gradually established a product recall system. The Measures for the Implementation of the Regulations on the Administration of Recall of Defective Automobile Products and the Measures for the Administration of Recall of Defective Consumer Products came into formal effect in 2016, and the Measures for the Administration of Food Recalls will come into effect on December 1, 2026. At the same time, the State Administration for Market Regulation has also stated that it will further strengthen recall supervision of cross-border e-commerce retail imported food and consumer products sold online. From the perspective of actual recall data, in 2025 a total of 1,081 consumer product recalls were implemented, involving 8.236 million products; the largest number of recalls involved food-related products, accounting for 21.7% of the total number of recalled products; 190 automobile product recalls were implemented, involving 6.846 million vehicles, of which 105 were recalls of new energy vehicles, involving 2.652 million vehicles, accounting for 38.7% of the total number of automobile recalls for the year.

On December 22, 2023, the State Administration for Market Regulation established the Defective Product Recall Technical Center, formerly the Defective Product Management Center under the former General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine. Its role is very similar to that of the U.S. CPSC. Slightly differently from the United States, in terms of administrative level the Technical Center is not a first-level department of the State Council, but a public institution directly under a department at the director-general level; in addition, the Technical Center manages both consumer product recalls and automobile recalls, whereas the U.S. CPSC manages only consumer product recalls, with automobile recalls managed by another agency, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

As the Chinese government and consumers pay increasing attention to product safety, it is believed that the role of the Defective Product Recall Technical Center in promoting product safety improvement will also become increasingly important.

Click to download the full version of Cross-Border Dispute Resolution Journal, Issue 45

Questions and answers

What is the role of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) in product recalls?

The CPSC oversees recalls by requiring manufacturers to report hazards, approving recall plans, and mandating recalls if necessary. It issues public announcements, monitors recall progress, and addresses consumer complaints to ensure defective products are effectively recovered.

What fines can the CPSC impose on manufacturers?

The CPSC can impose fines for failures to report hazards, violations of safety standards, false representation, selling recalled products, or unauthorized use of certification marks. In 2025, fines totaled US$28.275 million, and since 2026, a US$11.5 million fine was imposed on a Japanese company.

Can individuals face criminal liability for failing to report product hazards to the CPSC?

Yes, under the Consumer Product Safety Act, failure to report hazardous products can lead to criminal prosecution. In June 2025, two senior executives of a Chinese enterprise's U.S. subsidiary were sentenced to more than three years' imprisonment for not reporting fire risks of dehumidifiers.

How does China's Defective Product Recall Technical Center compare to the U.S. CPSC?

China's center, established in 2023, has a similar role but is not a ministerial-level agency; it is a public institution under a director-general level department. Unlike the CPSC, it manages both consumer product and automobile recalls, while the CPSC handles only consumer products, with automobile recalls managed by NHTSA.

Laws and cases cited

Laws

  • Consumer Product Safety Act (CPSA)

Regulations

  • Measures for the Implementation of the Regulations on the Administration of Recall of Defective Automobile Products
  • Measures for the Administration of Recall of Defective Consumer Products
  • Measures for the Administration of Food Recalls